Stafford or Manning (1 Viewer)

[Country Boy]

Semi Finals of my dynasty league and that's the choice.  I've played matchups all year with Stafford getting most of the reps.  Now I'm worried about the finger!  But Eli has been bad the last few weeks.  Only to complicate my question, the Giants are one of my defenses.  Right now I'm leaning Stafford and playing the Giants defense so picks are neutralized.  I'm a heavy favorite because D Johnson and Zeke are my RBs.

Thoughts?

 

[Country Boy]

No thoughts or you can't believe that's my best option?

 

[starks]

i'm starting Eli over Stafford. His finger, the weather, and most importantly Riddick being out has me concerned 

 

[IAMFLIPPER]

I personally would go Eli.  The uncertainty of the finger injury deems that necessary.  Maybe a different conversation next week.

 

[Rubi]

Eli