Start J.Hebert or C. Williams? (1 Viewer)

[mgodbee22]

Subject says it all. Hebert with no practice or roll the dice with the rookie in a good matchup?

 

[GPS]

I roll with Williams. I think I could score 16 pts with those weapons. Not really, but in truth I still can't wrap my head around what that Chargers offense is really going to look like.

 

[Jaruby]

I’d go Williams. They built the damn team for him. Hes gonna throw, throw, throw. Even if he sucks he’s gonna get ya some points. No clue on Herbert atm.

 

[Gally]

If you want ceiling go with Caleb. If you want floor go with Herbert.

 

[Jamesinaz]

I kinda agree with Gally. Herbert is an experienced QB and will do SOMETHING. But I think his ceiling is very limited with his recent injury and recievers. Caleb was a guy I really wanted as my backup QB but missed in my draft. I think he will end up the best rookie QB this season. But not a top 5 guy because he will be a more traditional QB not a run and gun like WIlliams. Still, I think Caleb has a better chance at a big game than Herbert.

 

[mgodbee22]

Good news! I would have lost no matter who I started. LOL! That said Caleb is on the bench for now. I may pick up mayfield or Geno to have a 3 man rotation for matchups.