Steve Smith = Alexander? (1 Viewer)

[jagerbomb]

I have my DD adjusted for my 0.5 ppr auction league and it has Steve Smith valued just under Alexander and just over Maroney (at #11). Is this way off? Or is it reasonable to elevate Smith's value this much for 0.5 ppr? Starters are 1/2/3/1/1/1. I don't mean to turn this into a draft dominator discussion, as I know how to adjust the base values. I'm more interested to know other's opinions on how much the 0.5 ppr increases the top WRs.

 

[BigSteelThrill]

Makes sense if you have Steve with 90 catches and Shaun with 20.

Thats an extra 35 points.

Shaun at 1600 with 14tdx6 + 10 = 254

Steve at 1300 with 10tdx6 + 45 = 235

As an example.

But Smith would be very hard pressed to get past the 1400 range and more then 12-13 tds.

Shaun could crush those numbers to the tune of 1900 and 19+ tds.

Which would make a 50+ point spread at the ceiling.

 

[Penguin]

If you look at Dodd's projections for both you will see that he has...

Alexander with 1310 rushing yds & 12 TD's and 20 receptions for 125 yds & 1 TD = 221 points in a non PPR league. SA's 20 rec x 0.5 = 10 pts. 221 + 10 = 231 pts

S.Smith with 90 receptions for 1314 yds & 10 TD's = 191 points in a non PPR league. Smith's 90 rec x 0.5 = 45 pts. 191 + 45 = 236 pts.

 

[Penguin]

In an auction league I would think that S.Smith would come significantly cheaper than Shaun Alexander, even though Smith could end up slightly ahead of Alexander due to the scoring system.