4.08 The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky (Drama)
I guess it won't surprise many people to know that this is one of my all-time favorite books, and I had it as a must-draft. So far, all the books I've chosen have been fairly short and easy reads, so a good, dense Russian novel is good for variety. This is also my first selection from outside the 20th century. Dostoevsky is arguably the greatest novelist who ever lived. He is to the novel what Shakespeare is to the play. Both men share a rare gift for creating living, breathing, three-dimensional characters who seem to live independently of their creators. I could not in good conscience complete this draft without having this particular author represented in my library.
The Brothers Karamazov is, in my opinion, Dostoevksy's best work. When the degenerate Fyodor Karamazov is murdered, his four sons (Alyosha, Dmitri, Ivan, and Svidrigalov) must deal with the aftermath. As you'd expect, Dostoevsky plumbs the depths of each of these characters and in the process raises a variety of philosophical points with heavy Christian overtones. Redemptive suffering, psychological sickness, the broad nature of "guilt," etc. all play a role here.
This novel is the only one I'm aware of that features a chapter that is often sold and read as a stand-alone work. "The Grand Inquisitor" is a short story written by Ivan in which Christ returns to earth during the Spanish inquisition. He's imprisoned and accosted by the Grand Inquisitor for giving mankind too much freedom, a mistake the church has taken upon itself to rectify. It's a good, theologically meaty work written by a diseased mind, which Dostoevsky renders with perfect pitch.
From a draft strategy perspective, I was tempted to go with a different Dostoevsky work. Unfortunately,
The Brothers Karamazov is not as widely read as a couple of his other books. But I can't pass over my favorite, and I'm confident that even if the judges/voters haven't read this particular book, they're at least familiar enough with it and its author to appreciate its literary merits.