What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

***The OFFICIAL TOP 10 Dynasty Players*** (1 Viewer)

moderated

Footballguy
this is the official list of how players should be valued in dynasty leagues at this point. I don't like to give this info out as i'm not getting paid so consider this a freebie that likely won't happen again in your lifetime.

Also please don't PM me for advice as it's not worth my time or energy to respond. I'll explain some of the rankings but the others seem obvious to me so on those i won't. I'll check in the thread on occasion and respond to good points/questions, but people asking ridiculous questions like why P.thomas or Fred Jackson aren't ranked will be ignored as i don't want to ridicule them and get banned.

Based on FBG's scoring system, so NON-PPR, although since it's separated by position the PPR rankings wouldn't be much different.

QB's

1)Aaron Rodgers - Has a dynamite WR in Jennings, is young, and will be running an explosive passing offense.

2)Drew Brees - I know, a lot of people are going to whine about this. Brees is great but has a bunch of years on Rodgers and Colsten doesn't look to be consistent due to health.

3)Peyton Manning

4)Tom Brady

5)Tony Romo

6)Matt Ryan

7)Jay Cutler - Down a bit because the guys ahead of him have more heart and their teams weren't shopping them. Also his #1 WR will be in prison down the line.

8)Matt Schaub - Yes Matt Schaub, get over it. He's got all world AJ to throw to.

9)Ben Roethlisberger - Just don't see him as a great FF QB. Love him as a real QB but he is more of a 25 TD a season cap guy until Pitt completely changes their offense, which would be stupid of them and won't happen within the next 3-5 years.

10)Joe Flacco - Nice young gunslinger. I like his style and so should you.

RB's

1)AD - No brainer, anyone with a different RB ranked #1 should be ignored and never listened to.

2)Action Jackson

3)Jonathan Stewart - He's good, real good. Will share for a couple more years but even then will be solid and when he starts to carry the load will be a complete animal that will wow and amaze everyone who is lucky enough to see him. Would have him #2 if DeAngelo died or something.

4)Chris Johnson - The real deal, don't let anyone tell you different. 4.24, case closed, let's move on.

5)DeAngelo Williams - Another super talented guy in a time-share, but in a couple years he's gonna be on another team carrying the load on his own...and even sharing he's gonna put up top 5-10 numbers.

6)MJD - Very very talented player and will be a staple in the top 8-15 RB's, but i don't see him adding more touches then he has gotten the past couple seasons. He just isn't meant to carry the ball 300+ times. Jax will be getting a backfield mate to get the touches FT left behind.

7)Frank Gore

8)Darren McFadden - Don't let a bad rookie season scare you away, he's on a bad team but will progress and become an explosive player in the NFL, bank on it.

9)Michael Turner - hate how he's so one dimensional, but is very good at that one dimension

10)Marshawn Lynch - Being kind of stupid lowers him.

WR's

1)Larry Fitzgerald - Larry/Calvin are a coinflip, both will have HOF careers barring major injury, no weaknesses with either.

2)Calvin Johnson

3)AJ

4)Greg Jennings

5)Dwayne Bowe

6)Roddy White

7)Randy Moss

8)Steve Smith

9)Reggie Wayne

10)Anquan Boldin

TE's

1)Jason Witten

2)Antonio Gates

3)Dustin Keller - Don't sleep on him, he's undervalued big right now, the next great receiving TE

4)Kellen Winslow - body is a wreck so very risky longterm

5)Owen Daniels

6)Dallas Clark

7)Greg Olsen

8)Jon Carlson

9)Chris Cooley

10)Tony Gonzalez

 
this is the official list of how players should be valued in dynasty leagues at this point. I don't like to give this info out as i'm not getting paid so consider this a freebie that likely won't happen again in your lifetime.Also please don't PM me for advice as it's not worth my time or energy to respond.
:moneybag:
 
Didn't think there could be a thread that could top the EBF/Forte egomaniacal debacle, but this one has a chance.

Unless this is an EBF alias...

 
No way this can be official. You left out Tatum Bell and Brett Favre. Like weeds and bugs, you think they're gone but they keep coming back.

 
Two running backs from the same team in the top 5 (D-Will & J.Stewart)? Wow....Carolina's running game surely must be electric over the next 5 years (sarcasm).

 
"10)Marshawn Lynch - Being kind of stupid lowers him."

The smartest thing you said in your entire post. Lynch has rocks for brains.

 
Alex Smith should be in the top 10 at QB, I mean maybe not top 5 but to leave him out all together just seems wrong.

 
Great job on the rankings. It's not your usual-predictable thinking inside the box type rankings. Outside of a very few names like McFadden, Boldin, great job :confused:

 
bicycle_seat_sniffer said:
No Rivers at QB.try again
He's not as good as the 10 guys listed, but he'd be around 11-13.Last year was a statistical Fluke year for him, he's not a great QB as far as putting up numbers goes.
 
salmonstud said:
Two running backs from the same team in the top 5 (D-Will & J.Stewart)? Wow....Carolina's running game surely must be electric over the next 5 years (sarcasm).
They won't both be on the same team over the next 5 years.
 
Young 8 said:
moderated said:
Young 8 said:
no Colston or Marshall ?wow.....
Marshall won't be in the league in 3 years.
Steve Smith and Randy Moss will be 33 & 35 yrs old in 3 years
Yes, and Marshall will be out of the league by then and in the short-term will probably have a few more suspensions during the years he's still in the league.WR's can be productive into their mid-30's and SS and Moss will be more reliable over the next couple years plus will probably still be playing by the time Marshall is in prison.
 
duece2626 said:
moderated said:
Young 8 said:
no Colston or Marshall ?wow.....
Marshall won't be in the league in 3 years.Colston is in a great offense, but is a gimp and is replaceable. Great possession receiver but nothing special.
Didn't he put up the most receptions and yards in his first 2 seasons then anyone in NFL history? Sounds like nothing special.
He's in a special offense, he himself isn't special and is injury prone. He is a very very good WR, just not a great one.
 
9)Ben Roethlisberger - Just don't see him as a great FF QB. Love him as a real QB but he is more of a 25 TD a season cap guy until Pitt completely changes their offense, which would be stupid of them and won't happen within the next 3-5 years.
You sold me. :goodposting:
 
Joe Flacco higher than Rivers? I will not be PM'ing you for advice sir.
This one's a no-brainer. Flacco >>> Rivers in every way dynasty wise.
Why?
only thing Rivers have over Flacco is the supporting cast, which is huge. But if Flacco ever get some receivers, he should be better than Rivers.
thanks for answering for me as i thought it was obvious.As Taxman says, all Rivers has on flacco is Supporting Cast and Experience. He isn't in the same league as Flacco as far as QB dynasty value goes.
 
you got the D.Keller ranking right :tumbleweed:
ya, i think most with long-term vision can see Keller is a superstar fantasy TE, but thankfully there are still tons of dynasty players without vision who value guys like Tony G and Dallas Clark over him.Keller is going to be dynomite and put up some very big numbers during his career.
 
Joe Flacco higher than Rivers? I will not be PM'ing you for advice sir.
This one's a no-brainer. Flacco >>> Rivers in every way dynasty wise.
Why?
only thing Rivers have over Flacco is the supporting cast, which is huge. But if Flacco ever get some receivers, he should be better than Rivers.
thanks for answering for me as i thought it was obvious.As Taxman says, all Rivers has on flacco is Supporting Cast and Experience. He isn't in the same league as Flacco as far as QB dynasty value goes.
I asked you why Flacco >>> Rivers and your answer is because Rivers has a better supporting cast?
 
Buddy Ball 2K3 said:
moderated said:
LBH said:
you got the D.Keller ranking right :bye:
ya, i think most with long-term vision can see Keller is a superstar fantasy TE, but thankfully there are still tons of dynasty players without vision who value guys like Tony G and Dallas Clark over him.Keller is going to be dynomite and put up some very big numbers during his career.
The Number 1 reason why I disagree with you.
Baker had his best season with Clemens QBing. KC has had a strong tendency to lean on the TE and it's been evident in the daily practice reports out of jets camp throughout the preseasons. He looked to S.Ryan a lot when Ryan was a back up with the Jets. Of course none of this really matters because it's going to be Brett Ratliff claiming the starting job and hitting Keller in stride for a lot of TDs for the next 8-10 years :popcorn:
 
Well I ran a test of dynasty rankings with one, two and three asterixs over the past 7 years.

3 asterixs was 83% official.

2 asterixs were 64% official.

1 asterix was only 43% official.

Then I realized this was inconsequential and just a random occurance over those 7 years because:

Statistical results

In many scientific publications, the asterisk is employed as a shorthand to denote the statistical significance of results when testing hypotheses. When the likelihood that a result occurred by chance alone is below a certain level, one or more asterisks are displayed. Popular significance levels are 0.05 (*), 0.01 (**), and 0.001 (***).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asterisk#Statistical_results
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top