What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The US has Nine Political Tribes - FFA makeup? (1 Viewer)

Which Political Tribe are you?

  • Faith and Flag Conservative

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Committed Conservative

    Votes: 12 12.1%
  • Populist Right

    Votes: 2 2.0%
  • Ambivalent Right

    Votes: 27 27.3%
  • Stressed Sideliners

    Votes: 6 6.1%
  • Outsider Left

    Votes: 17 17.2%
  • Democratic Mainstays

    Votes: 3 3.0%
  • Establishment Liberals

    Votes: 17 17.2%
  • Progressive Left

    Votes: 11 11.1%

  • Total voters
    99

Sand

Footballguy
From this article, which I thought was a pretty good breakdown.  I'd suspect we have a goodly number of committed conservatives and establishment liberals in here and not much else.

Faith and Flag Conservatives

This group is 'intensely conservative in all realms', according to Pew. They make up 23 per cent of Republicans and independents who lean Republican, making them one of the two largest GOP-leaning groups. They are majority white and Christian. They're more likely than other groups to argue that government policies should support religious values. They're also less likely to believe in compromise in politics. Most say that Trump is probably the winner of the 2020 election, believing the so-called 'big lie.' Pew found that 79 per cent of this group believes too much attention has been paid to the January 6 Capitol attack. 

Committed Conservatives

This group holds views that are similar to the 'flag and faith conservatives' but with, as Pew put it, a 'softer edge.' They account for 15 per cent of Republicans and independents who lean GOP. They are pro-business and pro-small government. They would be more likely to support an immigration compromise than flag and faith conservatives and members of the populist right. They also believe the U.S. should prioritize relationships with foreign allies. While members of this group voted for Trump, they're not as enthusiastic about him - preferring former Republican presidents like Ronald Reagan.  

Populist Right

This group tends to be less educated than other groups with members often living in rural communities. It also accounts for 23 per cent of Republicans and GOP-leaning independents. They are highly critical of U.S. immigration policy and also U.S. corporations. They are the only Republican group that argues the economic system in the U.S. unfairly supports powerful interests. They believe, which is something that Democratic President Joe Biden has proposed, that taxes should be raised on Americans making more than $400,000. Eighty-one per cent of this group told Pew pollsters they'd like to see Trump remain a prominent political figure. 

Ambivalent Right

This group is the youngest set of conservative-leaning voters. They hold traditional conservative opinions on issues such as favoring small government, the economic system, as well as race and gender. However, they're more likely to support the legalization of marijuana and support abortion rights and same-sex marriage. While a majority voted for Trump in the last election, 63 per cent say they don't want to see him continue to be a major political figure in the Republican Party.  A quarter of this group identifies as Democrats or Democratic leaners, while it makes up 18 per cent of Republicans and GOP-leaning independents. 

Stressed Sideliners

This group makes up 15 per cent of the American populace, but just 10 per cent of voters. Those included hold a mix of liberal and conservative views. They tend to be more liberal economically and conservative socially. They also tend to be economically stressed. What they have in common is a general disinterest in politics. Only 45 per cent of this group voted in the 2020 election, with about half choosing Biden.

Outsider Left

This is the youngest group of Democratic voters. They account for 16 per cent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents. They supported President Joe Biden in the last election, but are deeply frustrated with the political system, including the Democratic Party. They are liberal, especially on the issues of race, climate change and immigration. They often consider themselves to be political independents. They don't vote reliably, but will choose a Democrat over a Republican candidate.

Democratic Mainstays

This is the oldest, on average, group of Democrats, who are loyalists to the party, and are more moderate on some issues. They're less likely than other Democratic groups to be college-educated. They account for 28 per cent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents. They may personally identify as politically moderate. Most of their views are liberal, however. On immigration, they may view illegal immigration as a bigger problem than other Democratic-leaning groups. They are also more pro-military. Forty per cent of black Democrats are included in this group.  

Establishment Liberals

'Establishment liberals,' on the other hand, are very liberal - but they're more resistant to sweeping change, instead supporting incrementalism and political compromise. A majority believe the party should be inclusive of those who believe GOP viewpoints on some issues. They account for 23 per cent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents, Pew found. 

Progressive Left

The 'progressive left' is the only majority white group of Democrats. They make up 12 per cent of Democrats and independents who lean Democratic. They have very liberal views on nearly every issue. They differ from what Pew calls 'establishment liberals' because they support sweeping changes to address racial injustice. They want a big expansion of the social safety net. They're the most politically engaged of the Democratic groups.  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think I've moved from ambivalent right to established liberal, but it is a coin toss.  Would like to see the Ben Sasse, Liz Cheney type candidates take on the Mark Kelly, Pete Buttigieg crowd.  

 
Ambivalent Right pretty much nailed me to a T.  I'm a registered Democrat but want smaller government and legalized Mary J and I don't want Trump to run again.

 
Ambivalent Right pretty much nailed me to a T.  I'm a registered Democrat but want smaller government and legalized Mary J and I don't want Trump to run again.
I thought the definitions were pretty well laid out.  I fit the committed conservative pretty well, though I like Trump less than the definition.

 
Outsider Left

This is the youngest group of Democratic voters. They account for 16 per cent of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents. They supported President Joe Biden in the last election, but are deeply frustrated with the political system, including the Democratic Party. They are liberal, especially on the issues of race, climate change and immigration. They often consider themselves to be political independents. They don't vote reliably, but will choose a Democrat over a Republican candidate.
This, other than the young part. Especially the bolded. 

 
How can there be two 'youngest group of Democratic voters'?  I'm confused.

I tend to vote straight D except when it comes to state treasurer....I vote R usually.  I want a grownup in charge of the money.  But I think republicans are out of touch and wrong on every single social issue, so.....what am I?

 
Democratic Mainstay. I'm very frustrated with politics in general including the Democratic Party. I generally support what the Progressives push, but don't like their tactics and feel they're too extreme - especially with the current infrastructure bill.

 
How can there be two 'youngest group of Democratic voters'?  I'm confused.

I tend to vote straight D except when it comes to state treasurer....I vote R usually.  I want a grownup in charge of the money.  But I think republicans are out of touch and wrong on every single social issue, so.....what am I?


Really, this should be it's own thread.  What is General Malaise...

 
Id be more of a stressed sideliner although opposite in terms of fiscal conservative and more socially liberal.  There was no one place in the liberal side to put me.  Im not going to generally vote for the Democratic candidate...and I do not have a disinterest in politics.  Also not all that economically stressed.  I don't have FBG money...but we do ok.

 
Just kidding - but I will say that I have a tough time fitting myself in to one of those groups.

I guess if I were forced it would Outsider Left - I have some fairly extreme liberal views (for example, I hate all guns) - but I also think some of the woke culture has become ridiculous and tries to make everyone fit some neat little profile that only they approve of.  I like inappropriate jokes and humor (I really enjoyed the latest Dave Chappelle special, for example), I've become very anti-organized religion over the last decade (although the government should still stay out of it).  While I've become anti-organized religion I've embraced more of the teachings of Jesus (or try to at least).  I think greed is killing us and Social Media isn't far behind.  I think being a decent person makes you much more successful in life then how much money you make.  I don't subscribe to the idea that Capitalism is the greatest thing ever........I could go on but I think Outsider Left is about the only option I have that kind of fits.

 
I don't fit into any of these. I'm libertarian on most issues. Least amount of government involvement as possible is my ultimate dream. Voted for mostly Republicans or 3rd party if the R was a waste (McCain, Romney). Did vote for Bush twice in my 20's and while I would never vote for Gore or Kerry, I disagree with everything Bush did now that I've come to understand the gravity of his actions. 

So I guess I'm tribeless.

 
None of these feel like they really fit for me but of the options closest is Ambivalent Right.  The first half of that nails me to a tee but the Trump part doesn’t.  Part of the Outsider Left rings true in the frustration with the political system and identifying as an independent.  But rest doesn’t.   Ultimately voted AR.  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Interesting and well constructed groups.

Results don’t seem to jibe with the board being far left like I see repeated a lot.

 
We have many problems and tribalism is absolutely one of them. No one fits inside of a defined box nor should they feel obligated to try to do so. 

 
Stressed Sideliner here. The only thing about the "definition" which doesn't quite fit me is the is "a general disinterest in politics." Well, I guess that's been true most of my adult voting life. I always voted in all elections, local up to national, and took some time to research candidates but, for the most part was disinterested in politics the rest of the time. Five years ago that changed for me. In all honesty it was because of DJT. 

Side note: I feel I should mention a bit of my past involvement in politics. When I was 32, married, with 3 very young children, I was appointed to fill a recently vacated council members seat in the small borough I lived in, in 1998. The appointment was for the remainder of the term of the vacating member. This was for about 8-10 months I believe. After that term ended, if I wanted to retain the seat, which I did, I needed to run in the next election. I did run, and I was then elected to a full 2-year term. I then served about another year before resigning my seat mid-term due to some family issues at home with the wife & the kids. While technically this would classify me as formerly being in politics, getting involved on the local level had much more to do with my desire to help my community and hopefully make it a great place for my family to live in and my kids to grow up in. I was raised in the next town/borough over and truly considered the area a wonderful place to raise a family. The actual "politics" of serving my community were a downright pain in the keister and oftentimes put a damper on the progress I was hoping to accomplish. I didn't care for any of the "politics" at all. Hated it really. Even still, I enjoyed my relatively short stint serving my community and have very fond memories of that time in my life. On the plus side of my experience, I actually was able to accomplish some of the things I had hoped to, and those things are still around to this day and very much a part of that community.

 
None of these feel like they really fit for me but of the options closest is Ambivalent Right.  The first half of that nails me to a tee but the Trump part doesn’t.  Part of the Outsider Left rings true in the frustration with the political system and identifying as an independent.  But rest doesn’t.   Ultimately voted AR.  
Yeah, I'm some mix of Ambivalent Right and Outsider Left.  

 
Interesting and well constructed groups.

Results don’t seem to jibe with the board being far left like I see repeated a lot.
Well...to be fair, the usuals haven't all found the thread yet to tell us what we all REALLY are so......

I wish this would have been public poll, but then likely it would die within a day or two.

 
Faith and Flag Conservatives ---"Most say that Trump is probably the winner of the 2020 election, believing the so-called 'big lie.' Pew found that 79 per cent of this group believes too much attention has been paid to the January 6 Capitol attack."

5.56% ?!!?? This seems quite low as these folks here fill up much of the conservative discussion.  I suspect some identify next level up, but drop down to get in the mud with libs here.

'

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ambivalent Right

This group is the youngest set of conservative-leaning voters. They hold traditional conservative opinions on issues such as favoring small government, the economic system, as well as race and gender. However, they're more likely to support the legalization of marijuana and support abortion rights and same-sex marriage. While a majority voted for Trump in the last election, 63 per cent say they don't want to see him continue to be a major political figure in the Republican Party.  A quarter of this group identifies as Democrats or Democratic leaners, while it makes up 18 per cent of Republicans and GOP-leaning independents. 
Seems overly ambiguous and I don't think coincidental that the majority of poll respondents put themselves here since its open to a lot of interpretation.  I'd guess a lot of posters that many here would consider "Left" put themselves here.

If you hold traditional conservative opinion on race and gender...but support abortion rights and same sex marriage...what are the other traditional opinions on race and gender being held?

I also think if they elaborated more on what holding traditional conservative opinions on favoring small government and the economic system meant more of the 25% of democrats would select out of this group.  Less government programs than we have now, same or lower taxes....I'd consider that traditional.

 
Probably could fit into 3-4 groups as listed.  

Who else beside Squid voted for progressive left?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well...to be fair, the usuals haven't all found the thread yet to tell us what we all REALLY are so......

I wish this would have been public poll, but then likely it would die within a day or two.
The groups in this article are very cleverly written so I think people wouldn’t have a problem saying publicly what they are. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top