Thoughts on these offers (1 Viewer)

[Matt's Eagles]

12 team dynasty PPR

QB Matt Stafford, Matt Ryan, Siemien

RB McCoy, Lacy, Mathews, D Washington (det), Sproles, Smallwood, Darkwa, Perkins, Peterson IT

WR Fitz, Sanders, Edelman, Smiff, Bolden, Decket, VJax, Allen IR

TE JT, Gates, Huermann

trade A

i get Crowell or L Murray and Desean Jackson

I give Fitzgerald, Smiff

Trade B

I get Tyrell Williams, Hugabee, 2 2017 3rds

i give Matt Stafford

 

[HairySasquatch]

Who is Smiff?

I would have a hard time trading Stafford....I don't believe in Matt Ryan.  He is going to have some difficult games over the next few weeks and I have been burned by him in the past.  He has a lot of games of where he only gets 1 or 2 tds to go with 275 yards.....not horrible numbers, but nothing to get excited about.  Right now he is the second leading scorer at QB.  I don't see him keeping this up.  I predict that he finishes out of the top 10....and I wouldn't be surprised if he finishes out of the top 15.  He is the player I would be trying to trade.  I also don't think Siemien is the long term answer in Denver.  If you make this trade, you will either need to draft a qb early next year or throw darts in the later rounds and hope one sticks.  So, long story short, I would pass on trade B.

Here's mine if you don't mind having a look:   https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/748905-dak-prescotts-value-in-dynasty/

 

[Matt's Eagles]

Smiff is Steve Smith for Baltimore.

 

[pjhathaway77]

I don't think I like either trade for you, Crowell would make a nice 3rd RB but you lose your best WR, I don't think DJ is a comparable fantasy asset to Fitzgerald certainly or even Smith. Stafford has played well and I think you want to keep in case Matt Ryan comes back down to earth, you get a lot in that deal, but you could be screwed at a key position for this season. Now take all that with a grain of salt because I only play in redraft or one keeper leagues so I may be valuing players differently than a dynasty player would.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/748931-kenneth-dixon-or-allen-hurns-ros/

 

[CKoz24]

Neither are really good for you. If you are finding that your season is in shambles the Fitz trade may be good to give you some more RBs but I probably stay pat.

Thanks for answering mine.

 

[whc420]

Never played Dynasty, but Fitz and Smiff are towards the end of their careers. I love Fitz, but how much longer will be producing at this level?

 

[booda]

I would not do any of those trades in a dynasty league.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749036-pick-2-rbs-out-of-4/

 

[smilerz]

Getting a solid RB that is still young for two aging WRs sounds like a steal to me.