Tier up QB or get younger? (1 Viewer)

[chadgorick]

10 team dynasty SF start 11

Would you offer both of these? If so, which one first?

1. Give: Purdy, Tyreek and Jeudy
To
Get: Hurts and a 2026 3rd
Or
2. Give: Purdy, Tyreek and Conner
To
Get: BYoung, Addison and RJ Harvey
My team:
I’m trying to add a screenshot of my team but I’m not having any luck.

 

[Footballguys Staffer]

Great question. These are both fair offers. The upgrade from Purdy to Hurts in deal 1 is pretty substantial, and both Tyreek and Jeudy are diminishing assets. I make this offer first, especially if you can win this year without those WRs. The second offer upgrades you at both RB and WR, but is a mild downgrade at QB, though if last year was any indication, there is huge upside in Young. I make this offer second, or, if you realistically are one or two years away from a title, I would do this one first.

 

[chadgorick]

Great question. These are both fair offers. The upgrade from Purdy to Hurts in deal 1 is pretty substantial, and both Tyreek and Jeudy are diminishing assets. I make this offer first, especially if you can win this year without those WRs. The second offer upgrades you at both RB and WR, but is a mild downgrade at QB, though if last year was any indication, there is huge upside in Young. I make this offer second, or, if you realistically are one or two years away from a title, I would do this one first.

Very cool, thanks. My squad is Purdy, Dak, Kyler, ARich, Jeanty, Hampton, Judkins, Kamara, Conner, Dobbins, Tyreek, DAdams, Puka, GWilson, MEvans, Hunter, Pickens, Jeudy, Downs, Bowers, Warren, Loveland, Pitts. I’m leaning toward the Hurts deal…but wondering if they succeed in banning the tush push in 2026. That would make Hurts pretty average I’m thinking.

 

[Footballguys Staffer]

Nah, he'll still find a way to score. That team is EPIC and YOUNG. Get Hurts

 

[chadgorick]

Same squad, 10 team SF start 11, .5 TEP.
I sent this offer:
give - Purdy, Tyreek and Jeudy
Get - Hurts and 2027 3rd

Counter: he says he’s in if I add Loveland and he adds a 2026 2nd (est 2.02 to 2.04)

I’m thinking I can add Loveland if he adds his 2026 1st (est 1.07 to 1.10)

My TE’s are Bowers, Warren, Loveland, Pitts, Waller

Would you add Loveland for the 1st or for the 2nd or stick to the original?

 

[Footballguys Staffer]

Same squad, 10 team SF start 11, .5 TEP.
I sent this offer:
give - Purdy, Tyreek and Jeudy
Get - Hurts and 2027 3rd

Counter: he says he’s in if I add Loveland and he adds a 2026 2nd (est 2.02 to 2.04)

I’m thinking I can add Loveland if he adds his 2026 1st (est 1.07 to 1.10)

My TE’s are Bowers, Warren, Loveland, Pitts, Waller

Would you add Loveland for the 1st or for the 2nd or stick to the original?

You clearly don't need Loveland, but ask for the first, first. Otherwise, the 2 provides the right value. Always a chance, Loveland is another Pitts or Kincaid instead of a Bowers.