belljr said:
In their Primes Jack's competition was harder on a whole compared to Tiger's prime.
Today's era is tougher than both of those because of Tiger, imo
There's just no way this can be true. The talent pool has undergone a massive expansion over the last couple decades. Just comparing the flags on the leaderboard at majors makes it pretty clear, whether you use the 2000s or now. At the start of Jack's career Euros and Aussies didn't even make the trip to compete in the US
in majors sometimes. For example in writing this post I read about a Nicklaus semi-contemporary whose name I barely even recognize, Peter Thomsen, who is apparently considered the greatest Aussie golfer of all time. During the 1960s the dude finished in the top ten at the British Open eight times, including a win. He only played in other majors three times during that entire decade. In his career he won the British Open as many times as he
played in the US Open (5).
Now people from those countries blanket the leaderboard of events like the Valspar Championship. Plus there's an entire continent of golfers that basically didn't exist in Jack's era. And the game is much more popular in America too, thanks to both of them.
Basically, Nicklaus beat a bunch of Americans who grew up in country clubs along with the occasional random from another English-speaking country. Tiger is beating the planet.