Tiki vs Clinton vs Peyton (1 Viewer)

[zarconius]

I don't know how my draft will start, I assume LJ,SA,LT with first three. Assuming one of the three above is gone (#4 is open for trade offers).

1qb

2rb

3wr

1te

1def

1k

15 man roster

Standard rules apply, 1 point per reception, etc. No bonus for 300+ yard games.

My thanks

 

[Snotbubbles]

PPR I'm going Tiki over Portis. Manning isn't even a consideration.

 

[valence]

if you consider manning here, you might as well wave the white flag.

whoever is left of portis\barber is the answer

 

[Mooks77]

if you consider manning here, you might as well wave the white flag.

whoever is left of portis\barber is the answer

 

[zarconius]

if you consider manning here, you might as well wave the white flag.

whoever is left of portis\barber is the answer

My Thanks, I agree and just wanted to take a poll. I am hoping Tiki is there, but I have a feeling it's Portis, which I would be fine with as well. There are a couple die hard Peyton fans in my group that choose later, hopefully they will trade up.

 

[SSOG]

I prefer Portis to Barber, even in PPR leagues. Saunders has a ridiculous history of RB success (as well as of throwing to the RB), and Portis has good hands. Mostly, though, it's an age/injury/carries thing. Barber's older, has more wear-and-tear, and is more likely (in my opinion) to get injured. He'll also be losing goal-line touches to Jacobs. He's still my #5 RB, but I do have Portis ahead of him by a whisker, even in PPR. Not that I'd be upset if Barber was what was left.

 

[Chaka]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

 

[jziccfbg]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

 

[Chaka]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

 

[Mooks77]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

You're crazy.

 

[jziccfbg]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

You're crazy.

Rackers is so far above the other kickers --- I'm taking him in the 5th..... jk

 

[Chaka]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

You're crazy.

That doesn't make me wrong.

 

[jurb26]

I prefer Portis to Barber, even in PPR leagues. Saunders has a ridiculous history of RB success (as well as of throwing to the RB), and Portis has good hands. Mostly, though, it's an age/injury/carries thing. Barber's older, has more wear-and-tear, and is more likely (in my opinion) to get injured. He'll also be losing goal-line touches to Jacobs. He's still my #5 RB, but I do have Portis ahead of him by a whisker, even in PPR. Not that I'd be upset if Barber was what was left.

 

[MLBrandow]

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

You're crazy.

That doesn't make me wrong.

I would agree if Palmer wasn't starting week 1. But because he is, and because he's going in the fourth round, I have to disagree.I think you could warrant both as early 2nd rounders, but I don't think you can take Manning in the first round because Palmer is right there with him.

 

[John Mamula]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

based on what exactly?he has never finished as the #1 QB...

Year        Value        Pos. Rank    Overall Rank--------------------------------------------------1998          34             9             401999          84             4             142000         106             3             112001          70             3             162002          60             4             242003          53             2             302004         150             2              22005          34             3             34--------------------------------------------------             592

 

[Noahs Troopers]

Redraft, this is easy, Barber.

Redraft and if PPR, shocked this was even a question.

 

[qimqam]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

based on what exactly?he has never finished as the #1 QB...

Year        Value        Pos. Rank    Overall Rank--------------------------------------------------1998          34             9             401999          84             4             142000         106             3             112001          70             3             162002          60             4             242003          53             2             302004         150             2              22005          34             3             34--------------------------------------------------             592

I could be wrong but I don't think LT ever finished as the top RB yet he is always in the top 3 players picked and usally 1 or 2.Tiki is 32? Go with Portis

 

[John Mamula]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

based on what exactly?he has never finished as the #1 QB...

Year        Value        Pos. Rank    Overall Rank--------------------------------------------------1998          34             9             401999          84             4             142000         106             3             112001          70             3             162002          60             4             242003          53             2             302004         150             2              22005          34             3             34--------------------------------------------------             592

I could be wrong but I don't think LT ever finished as the top RB yet he is always in the top 3 players picked and usally 1 or 2.Tiki is 32? Go with Portis

you're right...he has been a consistant 3rd.
Year Value Pos. Rank Overall Rank--------------------------------------------------2001 85 7 112002 155 3 32003 202 3 32004 130 3 52005 174 3 3-------------------------------------------------- 747however, when do the other top 2 RBs get picked? 1 and 2 overall. where do the other top QBs get picked? rounds later.poor and lazy drafting to draft manning in the first round.

 

[SSOG]

Barber over Portis.

Manning over both.

echoing others : Barber over Portis (only in ppr) both over peyton --- qb in the 1st round works out some times but not worth the hit it causes in other positions...

IMO Manning is so far ahead of the competition at QB that I would consider putting him in the top 3.

based on what exactly?he has never finished as the #1 QB...

Year Value Pos. Rank Overall Rank--------------------------------------------------1998 34 9 401999 84 4 142000 106 3 112001 70 3 162002 60 4 242003 53 2 302004 150 2 22005 34 3 34-------------------------------------------------- 592

I could be wrong but I don't think LT ever finished as the top RB yet he is always in the top 3 players picked and usally 1 or 2.Tiki is 32? Go with Portis

you're right...he has been a consistant 3rd.
Year Value Pos. Rank Overall Rank--------------------------------------------------2001 85 7 112002 155 3 32003 202 3 32004 130 3 52005 174 3 3-------------------------------------------------- 747however, when do the other top 2 RBs get picked? 1 and 2 overall. where do the other top QBs get picked? rounds later.poor and lazy drafting to draft manning in the first round.

Look at the overall ranks, too. Manning's only twice been in the overall top-12 (and since we're comparing players across positions, the overall rank is a better measure). Tomlinson's never been OUTSIDE the overall top-12.