Torturing Self Over Chubb Trade Offer (1 Viewer)

[wellbub]

10 team standard

6 points per touchdown pass

Start 1 QB 2 RB 2 WR 1 RB/WR 1 TE 1 D/ST 1 K

My Roster:

QB Mahomes, Stafford

RB David Johnson, Mixon,  Ingram, Chubb, Yeldon, Howard, Malcolm Brown, Foreman

WR Davante Adams, Diggs, Watkins, Corey Davis

TE Graham, Kittle

D/ST Rams

K Justin Tucker

His Roster:

QB Dalton, Mayfield

RB Elliot, Kerryon Johnson, Hyde

WR JuJu, K Allen, E Sanders, John Brown, T Gabriel, A Wilson, M Goodwin

TE Hooper, Uzomah

D/ST Bears, Chargers

K Maher

Offer:

He offered JuJu for Chubb. JuJu helps my roster more than losing Chubb hurts it on average I think, but I wonder what Chubb's ceiling is.

Possible Counter Offer:

I'm thinking of offering David Johnson, Chubb, and Corey Davis for Elliot and JuJu. He's big Cowboys fan, so chance of accepting is <20% I think, but he's really wanting Chubb.

I think I'm going to look back at this decision as a pivotal part of my season. I'm currently 5-1, and a 10 point dog this week. Any thoughts on the initial offer, the counter, potential other offers, and just a general plan with this roster moving forward are appreciated.

 

[themeistersinger]

In standard I'd probably value Chubb some place between RB10 and RB15, a little lower in PPR.  I'd probably put JuJu in the same range at WR, so pretty even deal.  I don't see how it helps you that much.

Generally, RB is more scarce than WR, so RB10 should be more valuable than WR10.  

I also would not accept your counter offer if I were him.  I'm a Davis owner and I am debating dropping him.  Now Johnson and Chubb for Elliott I might accept if I were him, and I'd also consider it if I were you.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/771630-ekeler-value-if-melvin-gordon-is-out-vs-tennessee/

 

[wellbub]

Thanks for the reply. That pretty much matches my thinking on the JuJu Chubb offer. I just wonder if making a move somewhere with Chubb now is the best idea. If I could get WR4 or 5 for him, that seems like a good idea. I'm just not entirely sure who that is.

 

[beerbuff]

I'd move him before the game. If he flops and Duke becomes the main guy which could easily happen you'll be better off.

 

[cloppbeast]

U might be able to squeeze Keenan Allen out of him. If not straight up then a 2 for 1 might convince him. Throw in your kicker. 

 

[wellbub]

I'm considering offering DJ, Chubb, and Diggs for Elliot and JuJu. Would this clearly be a win? I think giving Chubb and DJ for Elliot is a slight value hit given my league's format.