Trade Achane + JCM for Gibbs? (1 Viewer)

[Wangster]

12 team 0.5 PPR, start QB / 2RB / 2WR / TE / 2FLX.

QB - Dak, Lawrence
RB - JT, Achane, Henderson, JCM, Mason, Allen
WR - BTJ, McMillan, Ridley, Egbuka, Pearsall
TE - McBride

Gibbs owner is panicky after a week 1 loss. He made 2 offers:

1 - Achane + JCM for Gibbs
2 - Achane, JCM, Dak for Gibbs, Bo Nix

Thoughts on either offer? If it matters, Justin Fields is on waivers and I will be going aggressively after him tonight.

 

[Gally]

This all comes down to your belief in Achane and JCM. If you think Achane is a top 10 RB and JCM will be a top 15 guy then you probably hold them. If you think Achane is an injury waiting to happen and that Ekeler will be there all year capping Bill's upside then take the deal.