Trade advise (1 Viewer)

[glamis79]

In a 10 team standard scoring PPR starting 1QB 2RB 2WR Flex TE DEF K

What would be the better trade:

Blount & Brady for ODB & Melvin Gordon

 

[Gally]

This is nearly impossible to answer without any other information.   What other QB's do you have?  What WR's do you have? 

• Blount is a script dependent RB that depends on NE to be ahead (which is likely most of the time) but then must also have them decide to run even with the lead.  There are times that doesn't happen and you get screwed.
  
• Gordon is a TD/volume play that hasn't been very good on a per touch basis.  His bright side is that he is the only guy and will get all the touches.  They have also been feeding him inside the 5 leading to incredible TD numbers.  
  
• Brady vs OBJ is somewhat dependent upon what you have at those positions.  Both are elite top 5 guys at their position.  I do have some worry about OBJ however not enough to move him just to move him.    If you have a strength at WR and need QB help go Brady.  If you are the other way around I would rather have OBJ. 
  

Bottom line is that you can't give a quality evaluation without knowing the roster construction.

 

[glamis79]

Thanks Gally..... I left it vague on purpose because this trade went through but there are talks of the trade being veto'd because they feel it is a lop sided. 

 

[Gally]

Thanks Gally..... I left it vague on purpose because this trade went through but there are talks of the trade being veto'd because they feel it is a lop sided. 

Never veto a trade unless it is clear cut collusion.   I don't even know how you can consider that a lopsided trade.