Trade Advise (1 Viewer)

[Mkha2240]

10 Team Half PPR - 1 QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 W/R/T, 1 Def, 1 K, 6 bench

Was offered Henderson & Hollywood for Kittle. Do I go for it or counter offer? Feel that Henderson has been killing it but would it eventually settle down with Akers being given more than touches? I know Hollywood is good too and I do need depth at WR.

My Team (Currently 2nd Place)
QB: Wilson,  Big Ben 
WR: DJ Moore, Diggs, Hilton, Tim Patrick, E Sanders
RB: Henry, Mostert, Drake, Kelley
TE: Kittle, Jonny Smith
Def: Patriots | K: Bullock

Opponent’s Team (7th place)
QB: Murray
WR: Hill, Golladay, Hollywood, Diontae Johnson, Justin Jefferson, Cooks
RB: Helaire, Gurley, Carson, Henderson, Edmonds
TE: Engram
Def: Giants | K: Blankenship

 

[wlwiles]

Not nearly enough.  I mean nowhere close to being enough.  He's trying to buy arguably THE TE1 with an RB3 and a WR2?  No way.   Henderson is part of a now 3-headed RBBC, there's not nearly enough value there.  

Kittle for Golladay and Carson would be my counter, or Kittle for Hill + Gurley after that if he says no. 

 

[Mkha2240]

Not nearly enough.  I mean nowhere close to being enough.  He's trying to buy arguably THE TE1 with an RB3 and a WR2?  No way.   Henderson is part of a now 3-headed RBBC, there's not nearly enough value there.  

Kittle for Golladay and Carson would be my counter, or Kittle for Hill + Gurley after that if he says no. 

That’s what I was thinking but with Grappolo having all those issues, I wasn’t sure if he’d retain his value with back up QBs. Thanks for the help!

 

[Jayded]

Or counter back with Jonnu Smith. You have the ability to sell while that iron is hot because you have Kittle too. Might as well reap the benefits of having a super hot backup-sellable asset. That's at least remotely more comparable in value.

Would appreciate thoughts : https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/789488-trade-ceh-for-cook/