Trade: Breece Hall or Achane in PPR Redraft? (1 Viewer)

[Pietaster2]

Who wins this trade?

 

[Gally]

I would rather have Breece Hall for this year

 

[Jaruby]

The Hall side wins. I have Hall in my main league and would consider trading him only because I can’t stand the way AARon plays but I would not take Achane for him. I would quickly decline that.

 

[Allanmania]

As a fed up Breece Hall manager I would make this trade. But thats only cos I am frustrated with him at the moment.

Give me a few hours and I will come to my senses and say keep Hall lol.

 

[mogrod]

As a Breece manager, I'm more frustrated at the usage more than anything. They change coordinators and he gets the 80%+ usage and Braelon Allen isn't a thing. All of a sudden it's back to what seems to look like a split backfield AND Allen gets the goal line TD. Anyone can have a rough game for whatever reason, even in what was supposed to be a smash spot, but that's the scariest thing for him going forward.

BUT, saying all of that, there are very few RBs I would trade him for. I also have Achane on my team, and really like him, but I too am not sure I would make that trade. If I could trade Breece for Kyren I would SERIOUSLY consider it though.

 

[Pietaster2]

Thanks everyone who posted in here. I appreciate the thoughtful replies.

I'm the Achane owner and the dysfunction in the Meadowlands gives me pause. Breece leads on RoS rankings lists, but one situation is rising and the other looks like it's hitting some bumps. Plus I own Wright but probably won't be able to get Allen. I'm probably just going to sit tight with Achane.

 

[Gruden's Keyboard]

I have a redraft team with Breece, Achane, and Kenneth Walker and I like them very similarly.

Breece's bigger body and previous production in cold weather games makes him more appealing than Achane.

 

[Pietaster2]

I have a redraft team with Breece, Achane, and Kenneth Walker and I like them very similarly.

Breece's bigger body and previous production in cold weather games makes him more appealing than Achane.

That's a killer trio of backs for a redraft team. You're going to be hard to beat.

Breece certainly is more durable than Achane. That would be the one reason I'd make this trade.