Trade E.Elliot for O.Beckham? (1 Viewer)

[pooner23]

I’ve been offered Beckham for my Elliot in PPR league, redraft, start 2rbs 2wrs and 1 flex. Other owner in bad need of rbs. I know at first sound this may be a no brainer on paper. but here is roster 

My rbs are currently: Elliot, david johnson, s.michel, m.mack,  n chub, yeldon

my wrs are: Hopkins,m.evans, schuster-smith, woods, t.boyd

YES ITS A SMALL LEAGUE. LOL

do I have enuf rb depth to afford losing Elliot?

 

[Gally]

Is this a dynasty league?  What are the starting requirements?  If it's a start 1 RB vs a start 3 RB with a flex makes a big difference on whether or not you have the depth to move Zeke.

You aren't hurting at WR so it's not critical to get OBJ.  I think it boils down to who do you think will score more moving forward. 

 

[pooner23]

Is this a dynasty league?  What are the starting requirements?  If it's a start 1 RB vs a start 3 RB with a flex makes a big difference on whether or not you have the depth to move Zeke.

You aren't hurting at WR so it's not critical to get OBJ.  I think it boils down to who do you think will score more moving forward. 

Edited my post with more info. Thanks for the heads up. 

 

[Gally]

Edited my post with more info. Thanks for the heads up. 

So essentially this would put JuJu on the bench if you get OBJ.  Because of that I would rather keep Zeke.

 

[wlwiles]

You already have more startable guys than you can actually start (which leads to too many "I should have started X over Y" scenarios).  The trade is fair but I don't see how it helps you any.

 

[travdogg]

I'd do it, but positional value is meaningless based on your roster, I simply think in PPR, Beckham will score more points.

ETA: Assuming D.Johnson is David and not Duke.

 

[pooner23]

I'd do it, but positional value is meaningless based on your roster, I simply think in PPR, Beckham will score more points.

ETA: Assuming D.Johnson is David and not Duke.

Yes it’s David Johnson