Trade Ethics - Was offered a lopsided deal...in my favor (1 Viewer)

[OldTomMesko]

One of the owners in my league is a huge Raiders fan, and approached me and offered Blount and J. Hill for L. Murray. It's a keeper league, only start 1 RB. With flex for a second. Zeke is my #1, so I'd be getting good depth for at least this year, and the two best players in a three player deal. Is it fair for me to accept this? Or do I need to include more? 

 

[cjack]

If the league/commish lets it through, take the deal.

 

[dkp993]

Fair.  As long as there is no collusion let owners manage teams how they like.  Take it and run.  

Please take a look at mine.  Thx

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/750266-trade-l-miller-for-cj-and-crabtree/

 

[jeaton6]

This ia not that bad.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Take it

See mine please https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/750250-dynasty-maclin-ertz-for-1-2017-1st-and-2-2nds/

 

[pjhathaway77]

Take it, trading is a function of what you know and what you think you know that you think other people don't know. If this guy has a feeling about Murray and is giving you what he feels is fair value, then that's a fair trade. If it works out the way you think, you'll be vindicated and feel good, this guy is maybe taking the chance that Murray magically becomes a top 5 back ROS (not saying it is likely, but if it happens he is vindicated and the trade looks even more fair). 

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/750289-gordonrobinson-murray-montgomery-trade-advice/

 

[Nero]

Hill has been garbage in 5 of 7. I cut him in the one league I owned him. Not as lopsided as you think.

 

[umrebel]

You can easily make a case against wanting to own any of those three guys and could also make a case of why each one of them is the best #2 RB going forward.. All I know for sure, is that you've probably jinxed Blount and Hill the rest of the way.. haha.. good luck, and yes, I'd rather have your end of the deal if I had to choose

 

[NeverEnough]

Not so lopsided IMO

 

[stmfh]

Fair.  As long as there is no collusion let owners manage teams how they like.  Take it and run.  

Agreed

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/750302-ww-pickup-moncrief-coleman-lafell-or-meredith/

 

[Upchuck]

Yeah, not as bad as you think.  Murray should do better ROS.  I do own him but have started Michael and L Miller most weeks.   As an 'outside' owner, I wouldn't be pissed at this trade going through.

 

[Charybdis]

Considering its a 2 for 1 you'll have to drop someone too to make your roster the right size again. Do you have someone you can drop? If so, I'd say do it.

Please see mine: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/750359-who-to-pick-up-dion-lewis-or-kenneth-dixon-or-rob-kelley/