Trade Feedback (1 Viewer)

[rrekaj]

12-team PPR league, 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, FLX, D, K

Currently 4-3, but every team is within a game or so of each other.

My roster:

QB: Watson, Cousins

RB: McCoy, Lynch, Blount, Ellington, Forte

WR: Baldwin, Hogan, Tate, Paul Richardson

TE: Delanie Walker, Ed Dickson

D: Jags, Bears (streaming for the week)

K: Lutz

Trade offer:

Give: Hogan + Watson/Cousins

Receive: Mike Evans

The other player is entertaining another offer of Jordy Nelson + McCaffrey

Tempted to take it because it's not clear if Hogan will sustain the high production for the rest of the year. On the other hand, what I really need is a stable RB2 and I'm not sure this helps my roster enough significantly to trade away solid assets.

 

[oddsbodkins]

I would. Either QB you have is more than fine ROS and Evans is an elite talent. Selling high on Hogan isn't a bad call. Use that extra roster spot on a lottery ticket.

Please see mine: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/762110-trade-advice-whir/

 

[snoochieboochies]

Both watson and cousins have very tough play off schedules. Watson facing the number 1 and 2 pass defenses week 15 and 16, but I would say watson has the better regular season schedule and is playing better. Depends if you are confident you can make the playoffs. 

Outside of this week and week 16, Evans wont face a pass defense higher than 13. Mostly bottom half pass defenses. However, I am concerned about Winston. if Winston is injured and cannot throw like he has been evans value drops. Same thing happened to jordy earlier this year. Jordy without rodgers isnt nearly as valuable. So i would take Evans if Winston shows he is healthy this week. 

CMC in ppr would be a great addition, as you could plug him in for a start right away. I would vote to move lynch/forte/cousins in order to get CMC plus a wr. Lynch and Forte are not as reliable as someone with less name recognition. Dion lewis has been showing well recently and could be a ww add. Assure you can make the playoffs with depth at rb and wr, and as you get closer to the playoffs acquire a qb with better sos.