Trade TY Hilton for Mahomes (1 Viewer)

[notoriousbill]

Was offered this trade to get Mahomnes but I declined prior to game yesterday. 

My other QBs are Cam Newton and Case Keenum.  My WRs are Hilton, JuJu, Larry Fitz (inj???), Ununwa, Agholor and Kupp....

Did I just make a mistake I will regret the rest of the season/

 

[beerbuff]

It all depends on your scoring system. Chances are you did the right thing. 

 

[Gally]

I probably would have accepted but I have never been a fan of Hilton.  You have Agholor and Kupp to get most of Hilton back in the lineup and I don't see Mahomes slowing down.  He is a top 5 guy.  I also think you could trade Newton and one of those WR's to get a Hilton replacement if you really wanted to.   I would do the deal.

 

[notoriousbill]

It all depends on your scoring system. Chances are you did the right thing. 

1 pt/10 yds rush/rec, 1 ppr, 1 pt/20 yds pass, 6 pts all TDs, -2 fumbles/ints

 

[Guru]

Keep Hilton

 

[brainee]

Was offered this trade to get Mahomnes but I declined prior to game yesterday. 

My other QBs are Cam Newton and Case Keenum.  My WRs are Hilton, JuJu, Larry Fitz (inj???), Ununwa, Agholor and Kupp....

Did I just make a mistake I will regret the rest of the season/

I would've declined too. Mahomes looks great, but Cam could very well finish as the higher ranked fantasy QB this year when all is said and done. Even if he doesn't, I think the loss of Hilton hurts your starting WRs more (especially with Fitz hobbled and having an awful QB).

Can you have a look at mine? https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/770479-offering-conner-to-get-ingram-or-obj-will-help-in-return/

 

[Here's Johnny]

No way, you are fine at QB, and Hilton could be your best WR.  I have Mahomes and I am shopping him for suckers.  Don't do it.