Trade value - Andre Johnson, Calvin Johnson, Steve Smith CAR (1 Viewer)

[Qmaster]

Can you give some thought process on your choice? TIA

 

[swidman]

I chose Smith for this season. I think the Panther have an a slightly easier schedule.

If you are talking dynasty league, you have to go with Megatron, as long as Detroit can decide upon a QB.

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

This is going to turn into a "Which WR do you own" poll pretty quickly.

 

[Challenge Everything]

I would rather have Kevin Walter, Roy Williams and Mushin Muhammed.

Is this not an assistant coaches forum poll?

 

[JetMaxx]

This is going to turn into a "Which WR do you own" poll pretty quickly.

I own AJ but voted Smith with a slightly higher value.

 

[Tanner9919]

I chose Smith for this season. I think the Panther have an a slightly easier schedule. If you are talking dynasty league, you have to go with Megatron, as long as Detroit can decide upon a QB.

I'm sure Houston will get things rolling pretty soon, but for my $.02, I'm taking Steve Smith only because of their schedule, its a piece of cake against lousy defenses ( save for TB) over the next 8 weeks...-disclaimerI have AJ and Smith in a league, so I'm hoping for both to 'arrive'..

 

[JetMaxx]

I have AJ and Smith in a league, so I'm hoping for both to 'arrive'..

$$$$.

 

[NeverEnough]

Dynasty/keeper? CJ2 (I hav him) Smith a close 2nd

Redraft I'd take Smith 1st

 

[FUBAR]

I have both Johnsons in a dynasty league and voted Smith.

Clearly I don't understand the rules.

 

[bjabrad]

I voted for Calvin Johnson due to his health. Both Steve Smith and Andre Johnson have had injury issues that have kept them from playing a significant number of games. CJ is also a freak physically and athletically and "may" be able to fight off injury more so than the other two guys.

 

[simey]

I voted for Calvin Johnson due to his health. Both Steve Smith and Andre Johnson have had injury issues that have kept them from playing a significant number of games. CJ is also a freak physically and athletically and "may" be able to fight off injury more so than the other two guys.

Calvin Johnson is only in his second year in the NFL compared to Smith (8 years) and Johnson (6 years), so it's not surprising that Smith and Johnson have had to deal with more injury issues. Since being a starting WR, Smith has only had two injuries that have kept him from playing. One year he missed the season due to a broken leg in game 1, and then he missed two games a couple years ago due to a hamstring+ingrown toenail surgery issue. I don't consider that as being a player labeled with injury issues. Smith has played sore various time, and right now he is playing through a sore shoulder. He is tough as nails.

 

[Road Warriors]

I went with CJ2 for the rest of the year, but I can see all of them potentially in the top 5.

 

[NY/NJMFDIVER]

Own CJ2 and AJ in multiple leagues, but voting SS for the rest of this season, now that he's past the suspension. He has the most stable QB situation. I actually think Megatron is a trade high because you don't want Drew Stanton slingin him the rock.