Trade: Who comes out ahead? (1 Viewer)

[gridiron-ghost]

Have been kicking around a trade offer I received a few days ago. I'm torn, so thought I let you sharks vote on it. Feel free to explain your choice.

Dynasty League - DF score as much as offense.

Thanks

 

[Jene Bramel]

Have been kicking around a trade offer I received a few days ago. I'm torn, so thought I let you sharks vote on it. Feel free to explain your choice.

Thanks

Close. But assuming this is a dynasty league with standard scoring, I go with the side that has the more stable and established linebacker - Urlacher. Possible that Barnett could move to the strong side sometime in the next season or two. I like Tillman better than Taylor (and more than just about anyone else around here apparently ), but there've been rumblings about a change of position and corners are always volatile.Pretty close though.

 

[houndirish]

I disagree with Jene on Tillman versus Taylor. I tend to think Taylor still has the potential to develop into an elite fantasy DB. However there are the obvious behavioral red flags.

I too voted Urlacher/Taylor.

 

[Spartans346]

Urlacher is the obvious choice when it comes to the linebacker part. As for the DB's with Archuleta playing SS, the will have to run in Taylor's direction now.

 

[DonFue]

Urlacher and Taylor...classic no-brainer! Barnett is an average football player that has played on one of the worst defenses in modern NFL history from a talent standpoint. Tillman may be a push with Taylor. I'd take 2 high 1st round picks that have already played well (current value plus potential for more)!