Trade (1 Viewer)

[smbkrypt24]

12 Team PPR. start 1QB, 1-3RB, 1-3WR, 1TE.  4 point passing TD.

Which side do you prefer

A. Dalton, J. White, 2.08, 2.09

or

R. Wilson, Steve Smith

 

[fightingillini]

R Wilson is the best player in the deal, so I like that side better, even though Smith is on his last legs.  Dalton is just an average QB, White is always going to share in NE's backfield, and the mid-late 2nds are just throw ins to me.

 

[One More Rep]

Wilson for me also

 

[aaj1997]

I would go Wilson also.  He is clearly the best player in the deal.  I would like to have 2.08 and 2.09 but all in all none of the pieces given up for Wilson would give me much heartburn to part with.

 

[smbkrypt24]

The counter was:

his R. Wilson, 2018 1st (guess top 6)

for

A. Dalton, 1.05

 

[Warhogs]

The Wilson side wins in the first offer.  As far as the counter offer this becomes very close.  I prefer Wilson over Dalton but you may lose a bit on the 1.05 this year over a 2018 1st round pick.  I still would do this because I like Wilson quite a bit more than Dalton.

 

[Gally]

I am on the Wilson side for both offers.  The first offer is a no brainer accept for the Wilson side and the counter offer is a little more to think about but it is still an accept.  Wilson's down year was primarily injury driven as he had knee/ankle injuries that zapped all of his best skill (escapability to extend plays into big plays).   Without that he was a solid QB but didn't have the skill that makes him an elite QB.  That should be back next year - barring another injury of course.

 

[smbkrypt24]

I am on the Wilson side for both offers.  The first offer is a no brainer accept for the Wilson side and the counter offer is a little more to think about but it is still an accept.  Wilson's down year was primarily injury driven as he had knee/ankle injuries that zapped all of his best skill (escapability to extend plays into big plays).   Without that he was a solid QB but didn't have the skill that makes him an elite QB.  That should be back next year - barring another injury of course.

Yeah, I never have viewed Qbs in a 12 team league as that valuable.  I see there are a couple responses that favor the Wilson side.  

I countered that he add in a 2018 2nd for that reason and he didn't see the benefit since he was downgrading his QB2 and adding in the 2018 2nd.