Trade (1 Viewer)

[hartlbb]

If you were trading away a te. Would you trade bowers or kincaid away?

 

[Ramerica]

trade Kincaid. Looks like Bowers is a big part of their offense and is a big weapon.

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

^

 

[Gally]

Obviously you trade Kincaid because he is the worse of the two. But part of deciding who to trade is the return you will get. Without knowing the two different trade scenarios it really is hard to pick.

On sheer performance I would rather have Bowers on my team because he will score more.

 

[Jaruby]

I’d trade which ever I’d get more for. I’d guess probably Kincaid would bring in a better player in return but if it was Bowers I’d feel fine holding Kincaid.

 

[Gally]

I’d guess probably Kincaid would bring in a better player

Really? Based on what has happened performance wise this year I would be shocked if Kincaid brought in a better return than Bowers.

 

[Jaruby]

I’d guess probably Kincaid would bring in a better player

Really? Based on what has happened performance wise this year I would be shocked if Kincaid brought in a better return than Bowers.

I’d guess. Yup. He didn’t ask who to keep he asked who to trade. I’d trade Kincaid. He should get a decent player.

 

[Gally]

I’d guess probably Kincaid would bring in a better player

Really? Based on what has happened performance wise this year I would be shocked if Kincaid brought in a better return than Bowers.

I’d guess. Yup. He didn’t ask who to keep he asked who to trade. I’d trade Kincaid. He should get a decent player.

I agree you can't really evaluate which player to trade without knowing the trade pieces. If he really wants to trade one of them and wants the best return without factoring in what he will be left with he should put both on the trade block and see what kind of offers/interest comes in. That's really the only way to make an educated choice

 

[Jaruby]

I’d guess probably Kincaid would bring in a better player

Really? Based on what has happened performance wise this year I would be shocked if Kincaid brought in a better return than Bowers.

I’d guess. Yup. He didn’t ask who to keep he asked who to trade. I’d trade Kincaid. He should get a decent player.

I agree you can't really evaluate which player to trade without knowing the trade pieces. If he really wants to trade one of them and wants the best return without factoring in what he will be left with he should put both on the trade block and see what kind of offers/interest comes in. That's really the only way to make an educated choice

Agree.