What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Trading for Josh Allen - Do I trade Judkins or Brown away? (1 Viewer)

Which RB would you trade for Josh Allen?

  • Chase Brown

    Votes: 3 75.0%
  • Quinshon Judkins

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • Neither, go a different route for QB

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    4

RaidersAreOne

Footballguy
0.5 PPR league. I am thiking of trading for Josh Allen.

My team:
  • Daniels (RIP)
  • Lamb, Metcalf, McLaurin (RIP), Jauan Jennings
  • Achane, Judkins, Chase Brown, Charbonnet, Allgeier, Bigsby
  • Fannin, Andrews
The Josh Allen owner would do either Brown or Judkins, one for one. Do you make the trade and for which RB? Keep in mind Chase Brown can be kept as a 6th next year and for 2 more years total, while Judkins an 8th and for another 3 years.
 
Based on the keeper aspect of things I would trade Chase Brown.
I too lean trading away Brown IF I were to do the trade. I just am not a fan of my flex position if I were to move Brown traded + Terry sucking, Jennings being meh, etc.

Wondering if it's best I go after a Darnold or McCarthy off the WW instead.
 
Based on the keeper aspect of things I would trade Chase Brown.
I too lean trading away Brown IF I were to do the trade. I just am not a fan of my flex position if I were to move Brown traded + Terry sucking, Jennings being meh, etc.

Wondering if it's best I go after a Darnold or McCarthy off the WW instead.

I was wondering about the waiver wire. Darnold isn't a bad fill-in.

Are there any decent flex options on the waiver wire? It's all about if you gain more in your lineup than you lose. Allen has been about 8.7 points/game better than Darnold. Brown is at 11 pts/game (and trending up with Flacco). Judkins around 13/game. Even if it's not an exciting option, are there WW flex guys who can give you at least 8?

I have a feeling there are, and I think I'd trade for Allen. I'd trade Brown, though I wouldn't blame anyone for favoring him over Judkins (focusing on recent games). It seems like keeping Judkins is better for you with the keeper rules too.
 
Based on the keeper aspect of things I would trade Chase Brown.
I too lean trading away Brown IF I were to do the trade. I just am not a fan of my flex position if I were to move Brown traded + Terry sucking, Jennings being meh, etc.

Wondering if it's best I go after a Darnold or McCarthy off the WW instead.

I was wondering about the waiver wire. Darnold isn't a bad fill-in.

Are there any decent flex options on the waiver wire? It's all about if you gain more in your lineup than you lose. Allen has been about 8.7 points/game better than Darnold. Brown is at 11 pts/game (and trending up with Flacco). Judkins around 13/game. Even if it's not an exciting option, are there WW flex guys who can give you at least 8?

I have a feeling there are, and I think I'd trade for Allen. I'd trade Brown, though I wouldn't blame anyone for favoring him over Judkins (focusing on recent games). It seems like keeping Judkins is better for you with the keeper rules too.
The best WW options as it stands:
  • QB
    • Darnold
    • McCarthy
    • Fields
    • Penix
    • Brissett
    • Stroud
  • RB
    • Gainwell
  • WR
    • Tucker
    • Mooney
    • Kirk
    • Watson
I got rid of Andrews so only have 1 roster spot left. I could move Brown for Allen and then put in a solid bid for Tre Tucker perhaps? Or keep Brown and just pick up Darnold.

Tough decision.
 
Update:

  • I ended up with McCarthy and also picked up Flacco as a bandaid solution at QB.
  • I have Charbonnet as my only viable flex play right now (Byes to others) but Tre Tucker and Shaheed are both available.
Would one suggest making the Allen trade for Brown, then picking up one of those guys and putting him in as flex going forward? Or roll with Flacco/JJM and keep Brown?

@Gally @brainee

Thanks!
 
0.5 PPR league. I am thiking of trading for Josh Allen.

My team:
  • Daniels (RIP)
  • Lamb, Metcalf, McLaurin (RIP), Jauan Jennings
  • Achane, Judkins, Chase Brown, Charbonnet, Allgeier, Bigsby
  • Fannin, Andrews
The Josh Allen owner would do either Brown or Judkins, one for one. Do you make the trade and for which RB? Keep in mind Chase Brown can be kept as a 6th next year and for 2 more years total, while Judkins an 8th and for another 3 years.
pick up sam darnold
 
0.5 PPR league. I am thiking of trading for Josh Allen.

My team:
  • Daniels (RIP)
  • Lamb, Metcalf, McLaurin (RIP), Jauan Jennings
  • Achane, Judkins, Chase Brown, Charbonnet, Allgeier, Bigsby
  • Fannin, Andrews
The Josh Allen owner would do either Brown or Judkins, one for one. Do you make the trade and for which RB? Keep in mind Chase Brown can be kept as a 6th next year and for 2 more years total, while Judkins an 8th and for another 3 years.
pick up sam darnold
Unfortunately I was outbid and had to settle for the scraps (JJ this week and Flacco ROS if I don't find an alternative).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top