Tua or Caleb for Week 8? (1 Viewer)

[mogrod]

Who you trust more to perform this week? (1QB league)

Picked them both up to choose between in place of Jayden Daniels.

- Do we trust Tua is going to be all good and blazing against a bad Cardinals D, or will he be rusty/not "fully" healthy?
- Will Caleb get a "rookie bump" coming out of the bye after performing well going into it against bad defenses, or does he not need to do much against a Washington team who has not been bad defending the pass and could struggle offensively this week?

Would you go more possible upside in Tua or the possible safer floor in Caleb?

On a side note, this league rewards .5 points per completion. The only thing I notice with that though, especially in this offensive/QB environment this season, is it basically just raises the whole floor for all QBs. Still comes down to total yards and TDs for who puts up more points.

 

[Jaruby]

Trust…. Neither.

I’d probably start Caleb if I was in your situation. You know what you should get but you have no idea what you’ll get with Tua.

 

[Jamesinaz]

We'll I'm pretty sure Tua will be rusty and tentative to run at all. Who can blame him. Still he has the better weapons and against a lame AZ defense. Honestly I have no idea. I"m in the same boat with Darnold and Murray.

 

[brainee]

I have a "start Caleb or not" decision myself (for me between Caleb and Darnold).

In your case, I'd go with safer floor of Caleb. I'd want to see Tua make it through a game before starting him (if I can avoid it).

 

[GrantK]

I have a "start Caleb or not" decision myself (for me between Caleb and Darnold).

In your case, I'd go with safer floor of Caleb. I'd want to see Tua make it through a game before starting him (if I can avoid it).

Same here, we actually have all 3 guys. Sitting Tua and leaning Caleb. Darnold has 1 TD last 2 games on 58 attempts. Caleb played well last time vs Washington and their DB's blow. Let's go Caleb!

 

[YUMHAGGIS]

I bet Tua goes off… and I’m hoping so, as I have on my bench and wanting to trade.
BUT, I would not start him this week over Caleb… I don’t think.
Maybe I would… if you feel you are chasing your matchup, then maybe start Tua… as I think there’s a higher ceiling.
If you are favour Edna,ready, okay it safe with Caleb…

Maybe?
Sorry that might not be as def8nitvely helpful as you were hoping… lol


Please help me.
Thread title: “Start 2: Dobbins, Javonte, Conner”

 

[YUMHAGGIS]

Especially non definitive with all the typos… sorry… *if you are favored already, play it safe with Caleb*