TY Hilton for this? (1 Viewer)

[Matt's Eagles]

12 team PPR 

i give TY Hilton

i get Sammy Watkins, Dalvin Cook, Darren Sproles

 

[PiKappEK328]

Is this a dynasty, keeper, or redraft?  How much PPR?  what's your starting lineup requirement?

 

[Matt's Eagles]

Dynasty, normal PPR, starting rqmts 2 -3 RBs, 3-5 WRs

 

[PiKappEK328]

I like the offense better in Indy, so I like Hilton more than Watkins.  However, Dalvin Cook is the heir in Minnesota, so he's a nice dynasty commodity.  If Watkins can stay healthy, I like the offense in Buffalo much better than last year's.  Sproles in Philly isn't bad, and he's a nice PPR option.  What's the rest of your team look like?

 

[fightingillini]

This really depends on the OP situation in his league.

If he's rebuilding.. his team isn't likely to contend, I would take this deal instantly.  Watkins has top 5 WR talent if he can ever stay healthy.  Cook should be the lead back in MIN sometime in the near future and should be a nice dynasty piece.

If he's contending for the title, it depends on his team's makeup.  If he's an OK RB2 away from contending and he has decent WR depth, I would take the deal and gamble that Watkins can stay healthy.  If he's contending, has good RB depth but suspect WR depth, then I would lean toward passing on the deal. since Hilton is a much safer option than Watkins.

So we can't totally answer unless we see the OP's team.  On the surface, it's a good deal as long as OP has the space to roster 2 more players.

 

[Matt's Eagles]

I am team with TY

Sstart 1 qb, 2-3 RBs, 3-5 WRs, 1 TE. It is PPR, TE yardage bonus

QB Dak, Palmer, Kizer, Dobbs

RB J. Howard, McCoy, Lynch, Martin, Sims, Vereen, pumphrey, McGuire, T Cohen

WR TY Hilton, Mike Thomas, Larry Fitz, Sanders, Kenny Britt, Zay  Jones, Aiken, Darboh, Zamora, JJ Nelson, A Stewart

TE Jesse James, D Allen, Higbee, McDonald

 

[sw20dan]

In a vacuum I would lean on the side getting Watkins and Cook but thats personal preference. Sammy is still young, has obviously had foot trouble but so did Julio a few years back. Cook has the opportunity to be a lead back for the next few years if he can take his chance. TY is obviously as reliable an option at WR that you could ask for but he has question marks too. Will he get more redzone looks or is Moncrief going to be the go-to guy there. I would say with your team, however, TY might be the safer bet. Your RB's are strong enough for a 12 team and your starting WR corps is good enough. You have to decide if you want to take the chance at getting younger at both RB and WR for the gamble on Watkins health and Cook hitting the ground running.

Reading this back, it hasnt really answered your question but its food for though if nothing else.

 

[Matt's Eagles]

Also got offered 

I give TY

i get Devante Adams, Mixon, Njouku, 18 2nd

 

[fightingillini]

Also got offered 

I give TY

i get Devante Adams, Mixon, Njouku, 18 2nd

Interesting offer, but I would pass.  I am not that high on Adams.  He had a career year in 2016 and I don't think he's that good.  Mixon could be good, but remember that 1) he has to compete with Hill and Bernard for touches, and 2) he's one strike away from being blackballed.  Not only that, you have good RBs and Mixon isn't going to be a starter.  Adams is a big step down from Hilton.  Deal hurts you in the short term and I am not convinced it helps you in the long run.

I would much rather take the Watkins/Cook/Sproles deal.  I like Cook's as a dynasty prospect, and OP has enough WR depth to cover Watkins potentially missing some games.

 

[Dan Hindery]

Also got offered 

I give TY

i get Devante Adams, Mixon, Njouku, 18 2nd

I would take that for sure. Especially with your TEs. 

That's two 1st round rookies and a future 2nd and that's more than enough to downgrade from Hilton to Adams. 

 

[Matt's Eagles]

Owner changed original deal... not quite sure if I like it any more..

i give Dak Prescott, TY, McGuire A Stewart

i get Brees, Cook, Sproles, Watkins