UPDATED OFFER: Dynasty: Gibbs/Deebo/Late 2025 1st for JJacobs/NCollins (1 Viewer)

[BearsFan4Life]

14 team standard .. was offered:

Gibbs and 2025 1st - projected late

for my

JJacobs and NCollins

I am 2-5 currently but only 2 games out of a playoff spot. Injuries and playing the wrong team on the wrong week is the reason for the record. If I do the deal I would be starting:

Mahomes or Daniels
Barkley
JTaylor
Gibbs
ARSB
Kelce or McBride.

I do have CMC sitting on my bench when/if he returns. My only concern with the deal is that if something happens to ARSB, my only WRs left are Dell and JSN thanks to the AIyuk injury.

Should Monty signing a new 2 year deal be of any concern as well?

Thoughts?

 

[am78]

Decent offer but Is it a keeper? If it is then No as a 1st loses Value. The problem is, it really weakens your WR depth and if You plan on making playoffs...then a def No
If you are out of the running then solid offer. Gibbs and Collins cancel each other (roughly with injury and all) amd you get 1 late 1st for Jacobs. It all comes down to of you plan on making a run or just deciding to setup for next year

 

[Jaruby]

Looking at your team’s future I’d say no. It’s not that it’s a bad trade you just need Collins more than you need Gibbs.

 

[RaidersAreOne]

Looking at your team’s future I’d say no. It’s not that it’s a bad trade you just need Collins more than you need Gibbs.

Agreed.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Decent offer but Is it a keeper? If it is then No as a 1st loses Value. The problem is, it really weakens your WR depth and if You plan on making playoffs...then a def No
If you are out of the running then solid offer. Gibbs and Collins cancel each other (roughly with injury and all) amd you get 1 late 1st for Jacobs. It all comes down to of you plan on making a run or just deciding to setup for next year

Dynasty league.. the 1st round pick is for the rookie draft

 

[LakeCowboy]

Going against others, but I think I'd take it. Your RBs are going to age out soon, where as ASB and Aiyuk are not. Tank Dell and JSN could still bounce back, plus the late 1st on a WR or RB.

Add in CMC/Taylor injury questions every year now.

 

[Tonycarpenter]

Sounds like you have a ton of talented RBs. I like your WRs but the late 2025 pick in 14 team standard scoring is going to get you a top TE or something.

 

[Tonycarpenter]

Reject

 

[am78]

Decent offer but Is it a keeper? If it is then No as a 1st loses Value. The problem is, it really weakens your WR depth and if You plan on making playoffs...then a def No
If you are out of the running then solid offer. Gibbs and Collins cancel each other (roughly with injury and all) amd you get 1 late 1st for Jacobs. It all comes down to of you plan on making a run or just deciding to setup for next year

Dynasty league.. the 1st round pick is for the rookie draft

Then I would pass. Keep the established starters

 

[BearsFan4Life]

14 team standard .. UPDATED OFFER

Gibbs, Deebo and 2025 1st Round Rookie Pick- projected mid

for my

JJacobs and NCollins

I am 4-6 and 1 game out of playoff contention

My starters are normally (can start a combo of 4 FLEX - Max 3 RBs):
Mahomes or Daniels
Barkley
JTaylor
JJacobs
ARSB
Kelce or McBride.

My bench:
CMC
Collins
Aiyuk
Dell
McConkey
JSN

Thoughts?

 

[Technician]

Don’t do it

 

[Jaruby]

My reasoning is still the same and still wouldn’t do it but if you choose to do it you’re not losing the trade so feel free to accept it if you want.