ok- I was away for the weekend. watched the game live, but couldn't transmit the agony in here. I'm going to spit it out now, and then read through what you all thought of it live. My thoughts...
I knew an away game in central america was going to be tough, especially a Guat type team. That said- if somebody had told me the US would give up two set-piece goals (and almost a third)... no way. I know he tripped, but it's strange not seeing any of the tall CBs in a place to defend the ball when it lands right on the 6 in the middle of the goal. also strange to not see anybody on the posts. also strange to have seen the first corner in that sequence go far post- with no US players marking anybody there.. very easily could have been a goal there too. Nice to see Gonzalez hasn't lost his ball-watching abilities playing in MEX. he seemed to get a really good look at the ball bouncing through to Ruiz, and an equally good look at Ruiz netting it. got to watch him find the space first repeatedly too... speedy, speedy Ruiz.
individual efforts aside, it was disheartening to see Guat win every second ball so clearly and easily. that shows me the tactical shape of the team was all wrong, let alone the individual desire; guys just weren't in the right place (*cough*cough* especially Mix). with Bradley dropped deeper, there was nobody in front of him to receive the ball or win second balls defensively. equally bad was Dempsey's lack of effort to help cover Woods and/or Mix. this left a gaping hole between Bradley and Woods that forced the backs to punch the ball long. Full credit to Guat for getting their shape right, but yuck.
it felt like a bunch of guys- Bradley included, which is crazy- that didn't appear to give the extra effort Frankie Hejduk talked about to step up and help their teammates. lots of ballwatching and lots of runs not made.
I'm not sure what happened with Bedoya, but it felt like the US got zero attack down his wing. seemed like he was pinching in way too much, which denied the US's ability to provide width on the left except for the very rare instances of Castillo pushing forward (not a bad game for him, IMO, aside from blasting the ball at Timmy for the goal conceding corner). No width, no shape through the middle... made a mess of the game.
But still the US generated some attack (especially with Nagbe pulling the strings) and had 4 or 5 super clear chances. despite being essentially one on one, Deuce and Bedoya hit 4 of those right at the keeper's hands instead of... oh- anywhere else. only Jozy got a good shot off to force an equally good save.
Woods needed a busier Deuce, IMO. and somebody else besides Mix to link with. really disappeared after a nice start. Deuce needed... dunno. usual nice skills when on the ball, but seems to get on the ball less and less. I was hoping to see a Zardoz earlier- give some width and desire to go at guys, plus his pace/athleticism. I was ok with the clang touches if he was going to push that Guat MF back a bit.
and man- that Guat team was not good.
even worse- BeIN's broadcast. really not clear on the need to show the game instead of close-ups and replays. hey- let's show the ref for two minutes instead of the action as we await the half-time whistle. and wtf was doing play-by-play... not JP. Schoen? god-awful. I turned it down as far as I could go without muting it... still heard his dumb-assery booming out of the damned TV.
Posting my writeup from Friday's game as a comparison, especially the bolded....
Bottom line difference- team shape with Beckerman behind Bradley, Z2 providing width and punch going forward and every player making the extra run- the second and third run- to help keep the spacing and pressure high up the field. even Deuce. especially Deuce. the team didn't "play" any better on the ball- but they worked much harder and set up much smarter off it.
Bradley and Deuce took that loss on Friday personally- you could tell. they were both all over the place in a good way and playing in front of one the better space/shape guys the US has who helped make it all better, especially with a hardworking Zusi and Zardoz keeping pressure on and still keeping some width. I haven't seen Deuce work that hard in a long, long time- loved it. Zardoz is a joke- a bad one- with that first touch. but his athleticism, strength and pace were needed on the night- and he consistently put himself in good places even if *clang*. and Zusi was consistently throwing himself into tackles and getting to the space defensively and offensively- nice to see. I don't know him much at all, but Finley maybe has some of the same athleticism as Zardoz? if so- I'm happy putting zardoz out to pasture until he can figure out his first touch. along with a nice desire to push at players with the ball, Pusilic made a decent poke tackle on a shielding Pappa- the only player who seemed to slow him down. he obviously needs to keep growing- soccer and physical-wise- but it was a perfect time to cap-blood him.
with Deuce working hard, I would have liked to see Woods find more space offensively- and combine better with Dempsey... but thought he did a great job running the channels and providing a ton of pressure on the Guat back four on both sides of the ball.
in spite of my snarky comments pre-game, Birnbaum was solid. didn't have to do much or get tested much, but played quite well next to Cameron who was a consistent elite player both games. Birnbaum certainly gives another CB option with Brooks, Gonzo, Beesknees, etc. IMO, with Bradley out against what should be a poor SVG, they can afford to experiment a tiny bit with Cameron pushing up to central MF.
yedlin played so much better with the field in front of him instead of having to go two ways... did a decent job shutting down that attacker on his side with speed and spacing. Castillo... ok. as others pointed out- I like his ability on the ball higher up the field but he makes me nervous playing a true LB trying the same moves in the defensive third.
Again- the US didn't play particularly "better", but they worked harder and set up smarter. and it showed that Guat is really just not good.... just as not good as they were on Friday, but defended much, much better. makes my brain 'splode watching both games and wondering how on earth the US can play so dispassionately and purposeless one night, and then flip the switch when they come home.