wannabee Strategy Thread (4 Viewers)

[Cabby]

Hey Jeff,

I'm in a 12 team H2H Auction Keeper League

$200 salary

Basic Scoring

Start

1 QB

2 RB

4 WR/TE

1 DEF

We can keep 3 players for three years. We can also keep rookies based on what round they were drafted($10 for first, $5 for 2nd, etc)

I am keeping Rodgers for $3, can't go wrong with that price.

I am keeping Calvin Johnson for $20, another good value.

Other possible keepers are Lynch at $48, Moss at $40, and Lance Moore at $3.

I am keeping Chris Johnson at $10(doesn't count towards my 3 keepers)

Both Lynch and Moss are highly priced and I think I could get both of them either one of them back next year for a cheaper price. I don't like Lynch anymore with all the trouble he has been in lately.

The Jones-Drew owner may trade my round 1 rookie pick for Jones Drew at $40.(which may be a discount given that Taylor is gone). I already have traded away my second round rookie pick earlier, so this trade would leave me with no picks in the first two rounds. I have 9th pick and I don't think there will be anyone that is comparable to Jones-Drew. Do I make this trade?

This was the first year of the league, so I could keep Jones-Drew for 2 more years at that price. It might have the 12th round pick not the 9th in the rookie draft. Either way I thinhk the guy is willig to trade, he has some nice keeper options.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Hey Jeff,I'm in a 12 team H2H Auction Keeper League$200 salaryBasic ScoringStart1 QB2 RB4 WR/TE1 DEFWe can keep 3 players for three years. We can also keep rookies based on what round they were drafted($10 for first, $5 for 2nd, etc)I am keeping Rodgers for $3, can't go wrong with that price.I am keeping Calvin Johnson for $20, another good value.Other possible keepers are Lynch at $48, Moss at $40, and Lance Moore at $3.I am keeping Chris Johnson at $10(doesn't count towards my 3 keepers)Both Lynch and Moss are highly priced and I think I could get both of them either one of them back next year for a cheaper price. I don't like Lynch anymore with all the trouble he has been in lately. The Jones-Drew owner may trade my round 1 rookie pick for Jones Drew at $40.(which may be a discount given that Taylor is gone). I already have traded away my second round rookie pick earlier, so this trade would leave me with no picks in the first two rounds. I have 9th pick and I don't think there will be anyone that is comparable to Jones-Drew. Do I make this trade?This was the first year of the league, so I could keep Jones-Drew for 2 more years at that price. It might have the 12th round pick not the 9th in the rookie draft. Either way I thinhk the guy is willig to trade, he has some nice keeper options.

Hey, at least you have good options. The deal comes down to Moss and the 1st or MJD. Since I think RBs are worth more in a standard scoring league, I would be inclined to go for the deal. Maybe ask for a 2nd or 3rd rounder back. Lynch is easily not an option. If you cannot do this deal, Lance Moore at $3 is only an option if you feel there will be plenty of good options at the auction.

 

[Packers4ever]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, J. Cotchery, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

I have been offered A. Gonzalez for 2.08 & 4.06.

What do you think of this trade? If I did this trade I would be hoping that I could trade Cotch so I guess it comes down to if you like Cotch or Gonzalez.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, J. Cotchery, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

I have been offered A. Gonzalez for 2.08 & 4.06.

What do you think of this trade? If I did this trade I would be hoping that I could trade Cotch so I guess it comes down to if you like Cotch or Gonzalez.

I love the value of the deal for you, and Gonzo has great upside with Harrison to be released any day now. I like it for you, and I hope/assume that you can move Cotchery.

 

[Packers4ever]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, J. Cotchery, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

I have been offered A. Gonzalez for 2.08 & 4.06.

What do you think of this trade? If I did this trade I would be hoping that I could trade Cotch so I guess it comes down to if you like Cotch or Gonzalez.

I love the value of the deal for you, and Gonzo has great upside with Harrison to be released any day now. I like it for you, and I hope/assume that you can move Cotchery.

I did the trade for A. Gonzalez.What do you think about trading A. Gonzoalez and Cotch for S. Smith(Car). I am thinking that is too much to give up for an older WR. I already have a trade offer for Cotch for his 2010 3rd pick which will probablly be a high pick.

So do I just go with the Cotch for 2010 3rd pick or offer the other trade?

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, J. Cotchery, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

I have been offered A. Gonzalez for 2.08 & 4.06.

What do you think of this trade? If I did this trade I would be hoping that I could trade Cotch so I guess it comes down to if you like Cotch or Gonzalez.

I love the value of the deal for you, and Gonzo has great upside with Harrison to be released any day now. I like it for you, and I hope/assume that you can move Cotchery.

I did the trade for A. Gonzalez.What do you think about trading A. Gonzoalez and Cotch for S. Smith(Car). I am thinking that is too much to give up for an older WR. I already have a trade offer for Cotch for his 2010 3rd pick which will probablly be a high pick.

So do I just go with the Cotch for 2010 3rd pick or offer the other trade?

The only issue with this trade is that many would think that cotch is worth more than agonzo. I think I would hold off on the Cotch deal ... as long as you do not have to declare for a while. I also like the idea of giving both for a top tier wr. I like Smith, but you may be able to get a younger wr like colston or royal or bowe (might want a little more with bowe). Make no mistake, people are going to go nuts for AGonzo with the harrison cut. you may get a chance to sell him higher than you paid.

 

[dmac37]

Jeff- I would like to run a couple of trades ideas by you (PPR). I need a #2 RB and already have Rodgers and Schaub at QB

Give

Warner

Mark Clayton or Cotchery (doubt it would fly with Clayton)

Get

Addai

Holt

or

Warner

Bradshaw

for

LJ

Charles

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Jeff- I would like to run a couple of trades ideas by you (PPR). I need a #2 RB and already have Rodgers and Schaub at QBGiveWarner Mark Clayton or Cotchery (doubt it would fly with Clayton)GetAddaiHoltorWarnerBradshawfor LJCharles

Hey, on these two offers, i do not like the second one at all. I do not know if the KC backs are any more startable than Bradshaw. On the first, I like it as long as you dont give Cotch. Can you give Clayton and something small? I like Cotch with Coles out of the picture. I do think Warner might be worth more if sold for a pick, then trade the pick and something for a RB.

 

[dmac37]

Jeff- I would like to run a couple of trades ideas by you (PPR). I need a #2 RB and already have Rodgers and Schaub at QBGiveWarner Mark Clayton or Cotchery (doubt it would fly with Clayton)GetAddaiHoltorWarnerBradshawfor LJCharles

Hey, on these two offers, i do not like the second one at all. I do not know if the KC backs are any more startable than Bradshaw. On the first, I like it as long as you dont give Cotch. Can you give Clayton and something small? I like Cotch with Coles out of the picture. I do think Warner might be worth more if sold for a pick, then trade the pick and something for a RB.

Your right on the second and with Cotch on the first option, problem is #1 is not desperate for a QB. I will just have to be patient and hope to get value for Warner. What draft pick do you think Warner is worth for a team needing a QB?

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Jeff- I would like to run a couple of trades ideas by you (PPR). I need a #2 RB and already have Rodgers and Schaub at QBGiveWarner Mark Clayton or Cotchery (doubt it would fly with Clayton)GetAddaiHoltorWarnerBradshawfor LJCharles

Hey, on these two offers, i do not like the second one at all. I do not know if the KC backs are any more startable than Bradshaw. On the first, I like it as long as you dont give Cotch. Can you give Clayton and something small? I like Cotch with Coles out of the picture. I do think Warner might be worth more if sold for a pick, then trade the pick and something for a RB.

Your right on the second and with Cotch on the first option, problem is #1 is not desperate for a QB. I will just have to be patient and hope to get value for Warner. What draft pick do you think Warner is worth for a team needing a QB?

I think Warner is worth a mid-1st round pick with his new contract. For the first, can you give Warner, Clayton and another less than stellar player for the deal instead of Cotch?If not, I would wait and trade Warner for a pick.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Hello everyone, I hope the offseason is treating everyone well. As dynasty leagues are eagerly awaiting the NFL Draft, I was thinking about how players are valued. Just a head's up that I will start some polls here in the ACF about random players. The Shark Pool is great but people get too defensive about their own players. These polls will solely be about values. I will try to pick players that seem to be hot topics. Jeff

 

[Packers4ever]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)

My Team

QB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards

RB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry

WR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington

TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis

Def TEN

Draft picks 1.06, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.

What would you trade for the 1.01 pick with my team or would I be better off just picking the BPA at 1.06. The 1.01 was just traded to a team that will now have the 1.01, 1.03, 1.04 & 1.08 picks and this team likes to trade.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. EdwardsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. PerryWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis Def TEN Draft picks 1.06, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.What would you trade for the 1.01 pick with my team or would I be better off just picking the BPA at 1.06. The 1.01 was just traded to a team that will now have the 1.01, 1.03, 1.04 & 1.08 picks and this team likes to trade.

You have a good team, so I think any move has to be one that does not hurt your chances for the 2009 season. I do not know if your league mates come to this board. If not, I think it all matters which player you were targeting with the 1.01. In a 14 team, non-ppr league, I assume RBs are worth quite a bit. You might see how far you can trade up with LJ and the 1.06 as bait. I would keep Portis and SJax. If you cannot get the 1.03 (or better) I would stay put at 1.06 and take BPA, preferably a RB. You have a very good receiving corps. This is just my preference, but I would see what TEdwards would get me. Can you swap him for Cassel? I just do not trust Edwards and the TO signing makes him valuable to some.

 

[Packers4ever]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. EdwardsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. PerryWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis Def TEN Draft picks 1.06, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.What would you trade for the 1.01 pick with my team or would I be better off just picking the BPA at 1.06. The 1.01 was just traded to a team that will now have the 1.01, 1.03, 1.04 & 1.08 picks and this team likes to trade.

You have a good team, so I think any move has to be one that does not hurt your chances for the 2009 season. I do not know if your league mates come to this board. If not, I think it all matters which player you were targeting with the 1.01. In a 14 team, non-ppr league, I assume RBs are worth quite a bit. You might see how far you can trade up with LJ and the 1.06 as bait. I would keep Portis and SJax. If you cannot get the 1.03 (or better) I would stay put at 1.06 and take BPA, preferably a RB. You have a very good receiving corps. This is just my preference, but I would see what TEdwards would get me. Can you swap him for Cassel? I just do not trust Edwards and the TO signing makes him valuable to some.

I am looking at Crabtree to draft I had him in my college league and really like him. I don't think any of the members from my league come to FBG. It's funny you bring up Cassel because last night I was just offered Cassel for Garcia and my 3rd round pick in 2010 but I was not home and someone got him for a 3rd pick. The one time I get a good trade offered to me and I am not home to accept it right away.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. EdwardsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. PerryWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis Def TEN Draft picks 1.06, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.What would you trade for the 1.01 pick with my team or would I be better off just picking the BPA at 1.06. The 1.01 was just traded to a team that will now have the 1.01, 1.03, 1.04 & 1.08 picks and this team likes to trade.

You have a good team, so I think any move has to be one that does not hurt your chances for the 2009 season. I do not know if your league mates come to this board. If not, I think it all matters which player you were targeting with the 1.01. In a 14 team, non-ppr league, I assume RBs are worth quite a bit. You might see how far you can trade up with LJ and the 1.06 as bait. I would keep Portis and SJax. If you cannot get the 1.03 (or better) I would stay put at 1.06 and take BPA, preferably a RB. You have a very good receiving corps. This is just my preference, but I would see what TEdwards would get me. Can you swap him for Cassel? I just do not trust Edwards and the TO signing makes him valuable to some.

I am looking at Crabtree to draft I had him in my college league and really like him. I don't think any of the members from my league come to FBG. It's funny you bring up Cassel because last night I was just offered Cassel for Garcia and my 3rd round pick in 2010 but I was not home and someone got him for a 3rd pick. The one time I get a good trade offered to me and I am not home to accept it right away.

I, too, like Crabtree and think he will be a good pro. But, I would still shoot for 09 with that good of a team

 

[dmac37]

Looking to aquire FWP as my #2 RB for 1-2 years. He also has T. Jones but I do not like that situation, with FWP we already know Mende is his competition and I think the Steelers ride out FWP for 1-2 more years.

12 team PPR

I want to offer either a draft pick, WR, or some combo. The other owner needs WR's or picks

My trade bait:

S. Moss

Driver

Gage

Hester

Mark Clayton

Picks- 1.9 thru 5.9

I also own both Winslow and Daniels and he really needs a TE, but I don't think FWP is worth 1 of these guys?

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Looking to aquire FWP as my #2 RB for 1-2 years. He also has T. Jones but I do not like that situation, with FWP we already know Mende is his competition and I think the Steelers ride out FWP for 1-2 more years.12 team PPRI want to offer either a draft pick, WR, or some combo. The other owner needs WR's or picksMy trade bait:S. MossDriverGageHesterMark ClaytonPicks- 1.9 thru 5.9I also own both Winslow and Daniels and he really needs a TE, but I don't think FWP is worth 1 of these guys?

this is just me, but I do not think FWP is worth the 1.09. I might throw out 2.09 and either Mark Clayton or Driver, depending on if you need a solid vet wr or one with upside. No way would I give either TE for FWP straight up.

 

[dmac37]

Looking to aquire FWP as my #2 RB for 1-2 years. He also has T. Jones but I do not like that situation, with FWP we already know Mende is his competition and I think the Steelers ride out FWP for 1-2 more years.12 team PPRI want to offer either a draft pick, WR, or some combo. The other owner needs WR's or picksMy trade bait:S. MossDriverGageHesterMark ClaytonPicks- 1.9 thru 5.9I also own both Winslow and Daniels and he really needs a TE, but I don't think FWP is worth 1 of these guys?

this is just me, but I do not think FWP is worth the 1.09. I might throw out 2.09 and either Mark Clayton or Driver, depending on if you need a solid vet wr or one with upside. No way would I give either TE for FWP straight up.

That's right in line with what I was thinking.Now another option- looking to aquire AddaiThe Addai owner is deep at RB and weak at WR, he also has Addai on the trading block. His only real WR's are Holmes and Gonzales and my WR's are AJ & Cotchery, the group above plus M. Walker & Kelly.I'm thinking of Cotchery plus a throw in for Addai- what do you think?Bottom line I can go after FWP and give up less or try for Addai but weaken my WR's

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Looking to aquire FWP as my #2 RB for 1-2 years. He also has T. Jones but I do not like that situation, with FWP we already know Mende is his competition and I think the Steelers ride out FWP for 1-2 more years.12 team PPRI want to offer either a draft pick, WR, or some combo. The other owner needs WR's or picksMy trade bait:S. MossDriverGageHesterMark ClaytonPicks- 1.9 thru 5.9I also own both Winslow and Daniels and he really needs a TE, but I don't think FWP is worth 1 of these guys?

this is just me, but I do not think FWP is worth the 1.09. I might throw out 2.09 and either Mark Clayton or Driver, depending on if you need a solid vet wr or one with upside. No way would I give either TE for FWP straight up.

That's right in line with what I was thinking.Now another option- looking to aquire AddaiThe Addai owner is deep at RB and weak at WR, he also has Addai on the trading block. His only real WR's are Holmes and Gonzales and my WR's are AJ & Cotchery, the group above plus M. Walker & Kelly.I'm thinking of Cotchery plus a throw in for Addai- what do you think?Bottom line I can go after FWP and give up less or try for Addai but weaken my WR's

I really do not trust either, but would rather have Addai because of upside ... plus his handcuff (maybe Rhodes if they re-sign) is a lot cheaper. Who are your WRs? I would think Santana and the 2.09 should be close. I would try to keep the 1.09 and take a WR and trade Santana ...

 

[dmac37]

OK Jeff, 2 line up choices, rest of the team would be the same.

PPR start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex

AD

Addai

AJ

Cotch

Driver

Hester

Winslow

Daniels

no 1.9 draft pick

or

AD

FWP

AJ

Evans

Cotch

Driver/ Hester

Winslow

1.9 rookie pick

pick up or draft a 2nd TE

My other RB's

Benson, Rice, Graham, Bradshaw

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

OK Jeff, 2 line up choices, rest of the team would be the same.PPR start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flexADAddaiAJCotchDriverHesterWinslowDaniels no 1.9 draft pickorADFWPAJEvansCotchDriver/ HesterWinslow1.9 rookie pickpick up or draft a 2nd TEMy other RB'sBenson, Rice, Graham, Bradshaw

If I am reading right, the difference are Addai and Daniels or FWP, Evans and 1.09. It is pretty even. I like Addai more than FWP/1.09 and the Daniels for Evans is even. Which side are you giving/getting? I would prefer to keep Daniels and sell Winslow (preferably for more).

 

[dmac37]

OK Jeff, 2 line up choices, rest of the team would be the same.PPR start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flexADAddaiAJCotchDriverHesterWinslowDaniels no 1.9 draft pickorADFWPAJEvansCotchDriver/ HesterWinslow1.9 rookie pickpick up or draft a 2nd TEMy other RB'sBenson, Rice, Graham, Bradshaw

If I am reading right, the difference are Addai and Daniels or FWP, Evans and 1.09. It is pretty even. I like Addai more than FWP/1.09 and the Daniels for Evans is even. Which side are you giving/getting? I would prefer to keep Daniels and sell Winslow (preferably for more).

You are reading it right, the offer for FWP was just rejected. I offered:S. Moss & Daniels for Evans & FWP (he has no TE). To me Evans has a little more value than Moss and Daniels has more value than FWP, especially because he has no TE. Daniels seems to be about the #5-8 TE. but he does not think Daniels is worth FWP- Parker would be his #3 RB ???Looks like I'm back to Addai and will most likely need to give at least S. Moss and 1.9 or Cotchery and 2.9

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

OK Jeff, 2 line up choices, rest of the team would be the same.PPR start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flexADAddaiAJCotchDriverHesterWinslowDaniels no 1.9 draft pickorADFWPAJEvansCotchDriver/ HesterWinslow1.9 rookie pickpick up or draft a 2nd TEMy other RB'sBenson, Rice, Graham, Bradshaw

If I am reading right, the difference are Addai and Daniels or FWP, Evans and 1.09. It is pretty even. I like Addai more than FWP/1.09 and the Daniels for Evans is even. Which side are you giving/getting? I would prefer to keep Daniels and sell Winslow (preferably for more).

You are reading it right, the offer for FWP was just rejected. I offered:S. Moss & Daniels for Evans & FWP (he has no TE). To me Evans has a little more value than Moss and Daniels has more value than FWP, especially because he has no TE. Daniels seems to be about the #5-8 TE. but he does not think Daniels is worth FWP- Parker would be his #3 RB ???Looks like I'm back to Addai and will most likely need to give at least S. Moss and 1.9 or Cotchery and 2.9

I might hold off for the short term. What happens if Wash does trade for Cutler or if the Jets sign Matt Jones? I do like Cotchery, but I do not know if he is a huge upgrade over Santana.

 

[Packers4ever]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)

My Team

QB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards

RB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry

WR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington

TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis

Def TEN

Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.

This is the trade I was just offered.

QB Eli Manning, NYG

TE Bo Scaife, TEN

PK Robbie Gould, CHI

2009 Draft Pick - Round 2.04 (via GaToR KinG)

2010 Draft Pick - Round 2 (via Planet Gaz)

2010 Draft Pick - Round 2

To receive from Eggy's Booze Hounds:

QB Jeff Garcia, TB

QB Trent Edwards, BUF

TE Jason Witten, DAL

2009 Draft Pick - Round 3.07

2009 Draft Pick - Round 4.07

2010 Draft Pick - Round 3

2010 Draft Pick - Round 4

I am thinking no way but the 2nd round picks might make a difference since they will probably by high picks. Would you be OK with Edwards being your backup QB and your starter for a few week since McNabb with probably be injured for a couple of games and how long will McNabb play. I guess those are the two questions. I really like Witten but now that TO is gone will that hurt him.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. EdwardsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. PerryWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis Def TEN Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.This is the trade I was just offered.QB Eli Manning, NYG TE Bo Scaife, TEN PK Robbie Gould, CHI 2009 Draft Pick - Round 2.04 (via GaToR KinG) 2010 Draft Pick - Round 2 (via Planet Gaz) 2010 Draft Pick - Round 2To receive from Eggy's Booze Hounds: QB Jeff Garcia, TB QB Trent Edwards, BUF TE Jason Witten, DAL 2009 Draft Pick - Round 3.07 2009 Draft Pick - Round 4.07 2010 Draft Pick - Round 3 2010 Draft Pick - Round 4I am thinking no way but the 2nd round picks might make a difference since they will probably by high picks. Would you be OK with Edwards being your backup QB and your starter for a few week since McNabb with probably be injured for a couple of games and how long will McNabb play. I guess those are the two questions. I really like Witten but now that TO is gone will that hurt him.

out me in the "no way" camp because Witten is worth so very much

 

[Packers4ever]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. EdwardsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. PerryWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis Def TEN Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.This is the trade I was just offered.QB Eli Manning, NYG TE Bo Scaife, TEN PK Robbie Gould, CHI 2009 Draft Pick - Round 2.04 (via GaToR KinG) 2010 Draft Pick - Round 2 (via Planet Gaz) 2010 Draft Pick - Round 2To receive from Eggy's Booze Hounds: QB Jeff Garcia, TB QB Trent Edwards, BUF TE Jason Witten, DAL 2009 Draft Pick - Round 3.07 2009 Draft Pick - Round 4.07 2010 Draft Pick - Round 3 2010 Draft Pick - Round 4I am thinking no way but the 2nd round picks might make a difference since they will probably by high picks. Would you be OK with Edwards being your backup QB and your starter for a few week since McNabb with probably be injured for a couple of games and how long will McNabb play. I guess those are the two questions. I really like Witten but now that TO is gone will that hurt him.

out me in the "no way" camp because Witten is worth so very much

Another trade I have been offered in this league.I get S. Moss, J. Norwood & 1.08 for V. Davis, M. Walker & 1.06.I guess it comes down to what is the diference in the 1.06 & 1.08 picks.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. EdwardsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. PerryWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Mike Walker, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, V. Davis Def TEN Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.This is the trade I was just offered.QB Eli Manning, NYG TE Bo Scaife, TEN PK Robbie Gould, CHI 2009 Draft Pick - Round 2.04 (via GaToR KinG) 2010 Draft Pick - Round 2 (via Planet Gaz) 2010 Draft Pick - Round 2To receive from Eggy's Booze Hounds: QB Jeff Garcia, TB QB Trent Edwards, BUF TE Jason Witten, DAL 2009 Draft Pick - Round 3.07 2009 Draft Pick - Round 4.07 2010 Draft Pick - Round 3 2010 Draft Pick - Round 4I am thinking no way but the 2nd round picks might make a difference since they will probably by high picks. Would you be OK with Edwards being your backup QB and your starter for a few week since McNabb with probably be injured for a couple of games and how long will McNabb play. I guess those are the two questions. I really like Witten but now that TO is gone will that hurt him.

out me in the "no way" camp because Witten is worth so very much

Another trade I have been offered in this league.I get S. Moss, J. Norwood & 1.08 for V. Davis, M. Walker & 1.06.I guess it comes down to what is the diference in the 1.06 & 1.08 picks.

This a great deal for you, especially if the SMoss is Santana. I like Norwood.

 

[Packers4ever]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, A. Gonzalez, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

The team that has B. Marshall is looking to move him just wondering what you think would be a fair offer for him or if I should even try to trade for him. I think he is looking more for picks then players since he has 9 good keepers right now. Would offering him the 1.04 & 1.05 be too much.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, A. Gonzalez, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

The team that has B. Marshall is looking to move him just wondering what you think would be a fair offer for him or if I should even try to trade for him. I think he is looking more for picks then players since he has 9 good keepers right now. Would offering him the 1.04 & 1.05 be too much.

I do not think giving both picks is too much. Basically, it is Gonzo and the picks since he would become a drop. I think I would start by either offering Gonzo and 1.04 and a mid-round pick or Gonzo, 4, and 5 for Marshall and other picks (in the 2-4 rounds. Do you think you can sell Gonzalez for picks? If not, I would try to include him in the deal and try to get picks back. It is a lot to pay, but Marshall is a stud and improves your starting lineup after he serves the suspension.

 

[Packers4ever]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, A. Gonzalez, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

The team that has B. Marshall is looking to move him just wondering what you think would be a fair offer for him or if I should even try to trade for him. I think he is looking more for picks then players since he has 9 good keepers right now. Would offering him the 1.04 & 1.05 be too much.

I do not think giving both picks is too much. Basically, it is Gonzo and the picks since he would become a drop. I think I would start by either offering Gonzo and 1.04 and a mid-round pick or Gonzo, 4, and 5 for Marshall and other picks (in the 2-4 rounds. Do you think you can sell Gonzalez for picks? If not, I would try to include him in the deal and try to get picks back. It is a lot to pay, but Marshall is a stud and improves your starting lineup after he serves the suspension.

Just offered Gonzalez, 1.04, & 6.10 for B. Marshall and he accepted the trade.My current keepers

QB J. Culter

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall

I think my team looks pretty good as long as Culter can do something in Chicago.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, A. Gonzalez, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have picks 1.04 & 1.05.

The team that has B. Marshall is looking to move him just wondering what you think would be a fair offer for him or if I should even try to trade for him. I think he is looking more for picks then players since he has 9 good keepers right now. Would offering him the 1.04 & 1.05 be too much.

I do not think giving both picks is too much. Basically, it is Gonzo and the picks since he would become a drop. I think I would start by either offering Gonzo and 1.04 and a mid-round pick or Gonzo, 4, and 5 for Marshall and other picks (in the 2-4 rounds. Do you think you can sell Gonzalez for picks? If not, I would try to include him in the deal and try to get picks back. It is a lot to pay, but Marshall is a stud and improves your starting lineup after he serves the suspension.

Just offered Gonzalez, 1.04, & 6.10 for B. Marshall and he accepted the trade.My current keepers

QB J. Culter

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall

I think my team looks pretty good as long as Culter can do something in Chicago.

I like it a lot, but I also think Marshall will be worth a lot after his suspension. Just like last year, he was worth a mint after he came back.

 

[dmac37]

Jeff,

I'm thinking of 2 proposals to aquire Addai, and on another message board they think that these offers are not even close to enough.

I need an RB and the other owner is needing a WR, 12 team PPR standard roster and scoring. I also know that the other owner just drafted both Cotchery & Daniels in a recent start up.

My 2 proposals with MFL ADP's from 5 recent drafts like our league would be:

Addai (59) & Carlson (117)

for

Cotchery (68) & Daniels (88)

or

Addai, Holt (142) , and 2.6

for

Cotchery, Daniels, and 3.9

Are these way off?

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Jeff,I'm thinking of 2 proposals to aquire Addai, and on another message board they think that these offers are not even close to enough.I need an RB and the other owner is needing a WR, 12 team PPR standard roster and scoring. I also know that the other owner just drafted both Cotchery & Daniels in a recent start up.My 2 proposals with MFL ADP's from 5 recent drafts like our league would be:Addai (59) & Carlson (117)forCotchery (68) & Daniels (88) or Addai, Holt (142) , and 2.6forCotchery, Daniels, and 3.9Are these way off?

I think those are close offers in PPR leagues. Many are down on Addai and worry about the Colts drafting a back later this month. Also, I am a huge ODaniels fan and think he will have a great season.

 

[pretender]

16 team dynasty league - 45 man in season roster. Start 2 RB, 3/4 WR 1/2 TE. Scoring is 1 pt per .10 yds rushing/receiving

6 pts TD - long TD 8 pts bonus on 100/200 yard receiving and or rushing games. Defensive scoring sacks 5 pts, tackles 1.5, assists .75 pts, FF 3 pts, FR 3 pts plus .05 per yard on recovery, interceptions 5 pts plus .05 return yds. Defensive TD's 6 pts.

Here was the trade - fair deal or should I have let it go.

I gave up Adrian Peterson - MN, Ben Obamanu, Xavier Adibi

I get 1.02, 1.03 Earl Bennett, Jamaal Anderson, Tavares Gooden, Kenny Phillips

Before the trade I had

ADP

R Grant

B Jackson

K Lumpkin

C Perry

C Benson

P Thomas

C Henry

B Obaman

M Jenkins

L Moore

K Walter

J Nelson

C Johnson

T McBride

B Mccray

J Peppers

Bishop, Desmond GBP LB

Burnett, Kevin SDC LB (traded for him after this trade)

Cooper, Stephen SDC LB

Gooden, Tavares BAL LB

Harrison, James PIT LB

Hodge, Abdul CIN LB

Leber, Ben MIN LB

Timmons, Lawrence PIT LB

Tinoisamoa, Pisa STL LB

Vilma, Jonathan NOS LB

Bullocks, Daniel DET S - 4 FA

Payne, Kevin CHI S - 8 FA

Phillips, Kenny NYG S - 4 FA

Pollard, Bernard KCC S - 6 FA

Sharper, Darren NOS S - 9 FA (traded for him after this trade)

I presume to get either Chris Wells and the other top RB or Crabtree and one of the two top RBS with 1.02 and 1.03

Thoughts - would I have been better off with Adrian Peterson or not??

Thanks Jeff

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Stud backs are hard to come by in 16 team leagues. I think the success (or failure) of this deal will hinge on the IDPs. Losing Adibi might hurt a little. You should be ok with the picks getting a RB, but the IDPs will determine the deal. Crabtree will help your WRs. This might take a couple of years to know if you made the right move. Will be hard to replace Peterson.

16 team dynasty league - 45 man in season roster. Start 2 RB, 3/4 WR 1/2 TE. Scoring is 1 pt per .10 yds rushing/receiving6 pts TD - long TD 8 pts bonus on 100/200 yard receiving and or rushing games. Defensive scoring sacks 5 pts, tackles 1.5, assists .75 pts, FF 3 pts, FR 3 pts plus .05 per yard on recovery, interceptions 5 pts plus .05 return yds. Defensive TD's 6 pts. Here was the trade - fair deal or should I have let it go. I gave up Adrian Peterson - MN, Ben Obamanu, Xavier AdibiI get 1.02, 1.03 Earl Bennett, Jamaal Anderson, Tavares Gooden, Kenny PhillipsBefore the trade I hadADPR GrantB JacksonK LumpkinC PerryC BensonP ThomasC HenryB ObamanM JenkinsL MooreK WalterJ NelsonC Johnson T McBrideB MccrayJ PeppersBishop, Desmond GBP LB Burnett, Kevin SDC LB (traded for him after this trade)Cooper, Stephen SDC LB Gooden, Tavares BAL LB Harrison, James PIT LB Hodge, Abdul CIN LB Leber, Ben MIN LBTimmons, Lawrence PIT LB Tinoisamoa, Pisa STL LB Vilma, Jonathan NOS LB Bullocks, Daniel DET S - 4 FA Payne, Kevin CHI S - 8 FA Phillips, Kenny NYG S - 4 FA Pollard, Bernard KCC S - 6 FA Sharper, Darren NOS S - 9 FA (traded for him after this trade) I presume to get either Chris Wells and the other top RB or Crabtree and one of the two top RBS with 1.02 and 1.03Thoughts - would I have been better off with Adrian Peterson or not??Thanks Jeff

 

[dmac37]

Jeff,

I have exhausted many many attempts for a RB#2, mainly trying to get a 1-2 year stop gap guy. Rather than give up more than I want for short term help what do you think about this for Addai:

Cotchery & 1.9

for

Addai & 2.6 or 3.6

My thinking is between Moss, Driver & Hester I can replace Cotchery easier than one of my RB's beaing a #2. The 1.9 will most likely be a WR and not sure this will be much of a upgrade over the young WR's I have now, also can use Daniels as a #4WR at times or 3 RB's at times

My roster 12 team PPR, start 2-3 RB, 3-4 WR and 1-2 TE:

Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB

Schaub, Matt HOU QB

Peterson, Adrian MIN RB

Rice, Ray BAL RB

Benson, Cedric CIN RB

Bradshaw, Ahmad NYG RB

Graham, Earnest TBB RB

Hart, Mike IND RB

Hillis, Peyton DEN RB

Jackson, Brandon GBP RB

Williams, Carnell TBB RB

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

Cotchery, Jerricho NYJ WR

Moss, Santana WAS WR

Driver, Donald GBP WR

Hester, Devin CHI WR

Walker, Mike JAC WR

Clayton, Mark BAL WR

Kelly, Malcolm WAS WR

Gage, Justin TEN WR

Winslow, Kellen TBB TE

Daniels, Owen HOU TE

Nedney, Joe SFO PK

Colts, Indianapolis IND Def

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Jeff,

I have exhausted many many attempts for a RB#2, mainly trying to get a 1-2 year stop gap guy. Rather than give up more than I want for short term help what do you think about this for Addai:

Cotchery & 1.9

for

Addai & 2.6 or 3.6

My thinking is between Moss, Driver & Hester I can replace Cotchery easier than one of my RB's beaing a #2. The 1.9 will most likely be a WR and not sure this will be much of a upgrade over the young WR's I have now, also can use Daniels as a #4WR at times or 3 RB's at times

My roster 12 team PPR, start 2-3 RB, 3-4 WR and 1-2 TE:

Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB

Schaub, Matt HOU QB

Peterson, Adrian MIN RB

Rice, Ray BAL RB

Benson, Cedric CIN RB

Bradshaw, Ahmad NYG RB

Graham, Earnest TBB RB

Hart, Mike IND RB

Hillis, Peyton DEN RB

Jackson, Brandon GBP RB

Williams, Carnell TBB RB

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

Cotchery, Jerricho NYJ WR

Moss, Santana WAS WR

Driver, Donald GBP WR

Hester, Devin CHI WR

Walker, Mike JAC WR

Clayton, Mark BAL WR

Kelly, Malcolm WAS WR

Gage, Justin TEN WR

Winslow, Kellen TBB TE

Daniels, Owen HOU TE

Nedney, Joe SFO PK

Colts, Indianapolis IND Def

I do not like it for you. I really do not think you to pay that much for a RB2 with so much RB talent on your team. I think I would keep Cotch and see if someone will give you one of these RBs for the 1.09errick Ward - to complete the RBs

Ryan Grant - even if you have to add to the pick (might wait until after the draft for this one) + you have BJax

Pierre Thomas - many are down on him

You have several startable PPR RBs. I think Benson, Bradshaw and Graham will be enough if you stay put.

 

[dmac37]

Jeff,

I have exhausted many many attempts for a RB#2, mainly trying to get a 1-2 year stop gap guy. Rather than give up more than I want for short term help what do you think about this for Addai:

Cotchery & 1.9

for

Addai & 2.6 or 3.6

My thinking is between Moss, Driver & Hester I can replace Cotchery easier than one of my RB's beaing a #2. The 1.9 will most likely be a WR and not sure this will be much of a upgrade over the young WR's I have now, also can use Daniels as a #4WR at times or 3 RB's at times

My roster 12 team PPR, start 2-3 RB, 3-4 WR and 1-2 TE:

Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB

Schaub, Matt HOU QB

Peterson, Adrian MIN RB

Rice, Ray BAL RB

Benson, Cedric CIN RB

Bradshaw, Ahmad NYG RB

Graham, Earnest TBB RB

Hart, Mike IND RB

Hillis, Peyton DEN RB

Jackson, Brandon GBP RB

Williams, Carnell TBB RB

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

Cotchery, Jerricho NYJ WR

Moss, Santana WAS WR

Driver, Donald GBP WR

Hester, Devin CHI WR

Walker, Mike JAC WR

Clayton, Mark BAL WR

Kelly, Malcolm WAS WR

Gage, Justin TEN WR

Winslow, Kellen TBB TE

Daniels, Owen HOU TE

Nedney, Joe SFO PK

Colts, Indianapolis IND Def

I do not like it for you. I really do not think you to pay that much for a RB2 with so much RB talent on your team. I think I would keep Cotch and see if someone will give you one of these RBs for the 1.09errick Ward - to complete the RBs

Ryan Grant - even if you have to add to the pick (might wait until after the draft for this one) + you have BJax

Pierre Thomas - many are down on him

You have several startable PPR RBs. I think Benson, Bradshaw and Graham will be enough if you stay put.

Thanks for setting me straight, I have tried to acquire Addai, TJ, FWP, McGahee, Leon and Grant with no luck. I will give Ward a shot but as of now his team has no owner. I have studs at each position and depth at all positions I just need one of my RB's to step up to a serviceable #2.

 

[Packers4ever]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)

My Team

QB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards

RB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry

WR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Santana Moss, Nate Washington

TE's Jason Witten

Def TEN

Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.

His Team

QB's A. Rodgers, T. Romo,

RB's R. Bush, Jonathan Stewart, Brandon Jackson, Jerome Harrison, Kevin Faulk, Darren Sproles

WR's Fitz, Burress, Sidney Rice, Kevin Walter, Isaac Bruce, Limas Sweed

TE's Chris Cooley, Zach Miller

Would you trade C. Benson & 2010 2nd round pick for Zack Miller, 2010 3rd & 4th round picks.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)

My Team

QB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards

RB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry

WR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, Santana Moss, Nate Washington

TE's Jason Witten

Def TEN

Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.

His Team

QB's A. Rodgers, T. Romo,

RB's R. Bush, Jonathan Stewart, Brandon Jackson, Jerome Harrison, Kevin Faulk, Darren Sproles

WR's Fitz, Burress, Sidney Rice, Kevin Walter, Isaac Bruce, Limas Sweed

TE's Chris Cooley, Zach Miller



Would you trade C. Benson & 2010 2nd round pick for Zack Miller, 2010 3rd & 4th round picks.

I would not make that move. Benson has decent value in non-PPR leagues and could be a spot starter in a bigger league like yours. I think he has more value than Miller in non-PPR (bigger leagues where RBs are in short supply). You have Witten and if you want a backup TE, I would see if Martellus Bennett is on the waiver wire. You can always draft a backup TE in the rookie draft and be fine.

 

[Packers4ever]

Another trade from different league.

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have been offered these 3 trades by the same team.

Cassel, B. Jacobs, Chad Johnson for R. Brown, G. Jennings, & 3.05

B. Jacobs, Cassel & 6.09 for R. Brown, G. Jennings, & 3.05

B. Jacobs, Chad Johnson & 6.09 for R. Brown, G. Jennings & 3.05

His only other players are Westy, & Roy Williams.

Don't know if I really like any of these offers the only on that I might think about is the last but don't know if I like giving up Jennings.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Another trade from different league.

10 team league 8 keepers 7 vets & 1 Rookie 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's 1 TE, & 1 K Standard scoring with no PPR

My team( planned keeper in bold)

QB’s J. Culter, M. Bulger

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, Caddy, J. Harrison

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, K. Curtis, B. Engram

TE's C. Cooley, O. Danials

I have been offered these 3 trades by the same team.

Cassel, B. Jacobs, Chad Johnson for R. Brown, G. Jennings, & 3.05

B. Jacobs, Cassel & 6.09 for R. Brown, G. Jennings, & 3.05

B. Jacobs, Chad Johnson & 6.09 for R. Brown, G. Jennings & 3.05

His only other players are Westy, & Roy Williams.

Don't know if I really like any of these offers the only on that I might think about is the last but don't know if I like giving up Jennings.

I like your team and do not think any of these deals help you much. Jacobs is not a huge upgrade over Brown and I would try to keep your WRs together.

 

[Packers4ever]

What do you think Cotchery is worth in draft picks. A trade wants to trade him for draft picks but do not know if I would have enough to get him.

Would my 1.11 & 2.11 be enough or would I have to throw in a 2010 1st round pick which is hard to say were I will be in the draft since I finished second last year and don't know how I did with my team

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

What do you think Cotchery is worth in draft picks. A trade wants to trade him for draft picks but do not know if I would have enough to get him.Would my 1.11 & 2.11 be enough or would I have to throw in a 2010 1st round pick which is hard to say were I will be in the draft since I finished second last year and don't know how I did with my team

I would think you will need to add more than the 1.11. Might as well keep the 2.11 since few value second rounders. I probably would offer the 1.11 with a WR prospect for Cotch and not move the future first.

 

[Packers4ever]

What do you think Cotchery is worth in draft picks. A trade wants to trade him for draft picks but do not know if I would have enough to get him.Would my 1.11 & 2.11 be enough or would I have to throw in a 2010 1st round pick which is hard to say were I will be in the draft since I finished second last year and don't know how I did with my team

I would think you will need to add more than the 1.11. Might as well keep the 2.11 since few value second rounders. I probably would offer the 1.11 with a WR prospect for Cotch and not move the future first.

Was just offered Cotchery & D. Branch for Burress & 1.11.Don't know if I want to move Burress but I need to start 3 WR and only have Wayne & Edwards to start.What do you think should I take it or just pick the best WR at 1.11.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

What do you think Cotchery is worth in draft picks. A trade wants to trade him for draft picks but do not know if I would have enough to get him.Would my 1.11 & 2.11 be enough or would I have to throw in a 2010 1st round pick which is hard to say were I will be in the draft since I finished second last year and don't know how I did with my team

I would think you will need to add more than the 1.11. Might as well keep the 2.11 since few value second rounders. I probably would offer the 1.11 with a WR prospect for Cotch and not move the future first.

Was just offered Cotchery & D. Branch for Burress & 1.11.Don't know if I want to move Burress but I need to start 3 WR and only have Wayne & Edwards to start.What do you think should I take it or just pick the best WR at 1.11.

I would try to keep Plax over Branch if possible, but would not want it to be a deal-breaker. Any other WRs you can sub in to get Cotch? 1.11 + ? for Cotch

 

[Packers4ever]

What do you think Cotchery is worth in draft picks. A trade wants to trade him for draft picks but do not know if I would have enough to get him.Would my 1.11 & 2.11 be enough or would I have to throw in a 2010 1st round pick which is hard to say were I will be in the draft since I finished second last year and don't know how I did with my team

I would think you will need to add more than the 1.11. Might as well keep the 2.11 since few value second rounders. I probably would offer the 1.11 with a WR prospect for Cotch and not move the future first.

Was just offered Cotchery & D. Branch for Burress & 1.11.Don't know if I want to move Burress but I need to start 3 WR and only have Wayne & Edwards to start.What do you think should I take it or just pick the best WR at 1.11.

I would try to keep Plax over Branch if possible, but would not want it to be a deal-breaker. Any other WRs you can sub in to get Cotch? 1.11 + ? for Cotch

Not really already offered him anyone of these N. Washington, D. Thomas, J. Galloway, or D. Hixon with the 1.11 and said he does not want any of these WR's. So I am thinking I should just draft best WR at 1.11.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

What do you think Cotchery is worth in draft picks. A trade wants to trade him for draft picks but do not know if I would have enough to get him.Would my 1.11 & 2.11 be enough or would I have to throw in a 2010 1st round pick which is hard to say were I will be in the draft since I finished second last year and don't know how I did with my team

I would think you will need to add more than the 1.11. Might as well keep the 2.11 since few value second rounders. I probably would offer the 1.11 with a WR prospect for Cotch and not move the future first.

Was just offered Cotchery & D. Branch for Burress & 1.11.Don't know if I want to move Burress but I need to start 3 WR and only have Wayne & Edwards to start.What do you think should I take it or just pick the best WR at 1.11.

I would try to keep Plax over Branch if possible, but would not want it to be a deal-breaker. Any other WRs you can sub in to get Cotch? 1.11 + ? for Cotch

Not really already offered him anyone of these N. Washington, D. Thomas, J. Galloway, or D. Hixon with the 1.11 and said he does not want any of these WR's. So I am thinking I should just draft best WR at 1.11.

you might also see if you can trade the 2.11 for an aging WR like Driver. He would give you a legit WR3 until the rook at 1.11 develops. Also, I would keep Thomas. I think he might surprise this season.

 

[StuntRock]

Rookie/FA draft underway in a 12 team dynasty. I've got 1.11, 2.07, and a 3 third round picks (4, 7 & 9). I'm a bit hung up on my draft spot at 1.11, since Harvin was just taken. I'm looking at Stafford and Robiskie now (I like Sanchez too, fwiw). It's IDP, but I'm pretty good at LB and ok at DB. Crabtree, Nicks, Maclin, Harvin, DHB are the WRs who have gone so far.

Here's how my team shakes out roster wise:

QBs

Kevin Kolb (laffo)

Eli Manning

Aaron Rodgers

WRs

Earl Bennett

Keenan Burton

Greg Camarillo

Laveranues Coles

Colston

Early Doucet

Marvin Harrison & Ike Hilliard (waiver fodder soon)

Bryant Johnson

Manningham

Demetrius Williams

QBs 1 pt per 30 yards passing, 6pts per TD, -2 per int/fumble.

WRs no ppr, 1 point per 10 yards, 6 points per td

Decimal scoring.

The case for Stafford

Generally rated higher, so he'd be the BPA pick.

With Kevin Kolb being more or less useless, Stafford would leave me a lot safer at QB in case of injury.

The QB depth is incredibly shallow, WR is much deeper.

The case for Robiskie

Even with all the youth I've got, he's got the best shot of stepping in immediately.

Being opposite of Edwards will help him out.

He's much more certain than the "deeper" picks in the draft, thanks to a more clear cut situation (ie, both the Jax rookies)

I grabbed a RB (Shonn Greene) with my 1.7. Thoughts on what to do at this point?

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Rookie/FA draft underway in a 12 team dynasty. I've got 1.11, 2.07, and a 3 third round picks (4, 7 & 9). I'm a bit hung up on my draft spot at 1.11, since Harvin was just taken. I'm looking at Stafford and Robiskie now (I like Sanchez too, fwiw). It's IDP, but I'm pretty good at LB and ok at DB. Crabtree, Nicks, Maclin, Harvin, DHB are the WRs who have gone so far.

Here's how my team shakes out roster wise:

QBs

Kevin Kolb (laffo)

Eli Manning

Aaron Rodgers

WRs

Earl Bennett

Keenan Burton

Greg Camarillo

Laveranues Coles

Colston

Early Doucet

Marvin Harrison & Ike Hilliard (waiver fodder soon)

Bryant Johnson

Manningham

Demetrius Williams

QBs 1 pt per 30 yards passing, 6pts per TD, -2 per int/fumble.

WRs no ppr, 1 point per 10 yards, 6 points per td

Decimal scoring.

The case for Stafford

Generally rated higher, so he'd be the BPA pick.

With Kevin Kolb being more or less useless, Stafford would leave me a lot safer at QB in case of injury.

The QB depth is incredibly shallow, WR is much deeper.

The case for Robiskie

Even with all the youth I've got, he's got the best shot of stepping in immediately.

Being opposite of Edwards will help him out.

He's much more certain than the "deeper" picks in the draft, thanks to a more clear cut situation (ie, both the Jax rookies)

I grabbed a RB (Shonn Greene) with my 1.7. Thoughts on what to do at this point?

I like the Greene pick. Since you are pretty strong at QB, I think I would look at WR, either Robiskie or Britt. Both should be starting early on. I would take the one you like the best. A case could be made for either one. In 2nd, I really like Mike Thomas and Brandon Tate at WR. Each has a chance to be a stud in time.

In 3rd, I would look at IDP, and I like Shawn Nelson and Jared Cook, if you need a TE.