It depends on the team and the year.For the Colts - 2002 meant making the playoffs, 2003 meant winning a playoff game, 2004 meant getting the the Super Bowl. So, 2002 and 2003 were successes, 2004 was not. Clearly this year - anything less than a Super Bowl victory would be a failure - and I've never said that before. For other playoff teams this year, I'd say the Redskins, Jags, Bengals, Bears, Bucs, and Giants can claim successful seasons without winning a playoff game this season. The Broncos, Seahawks need to win a playoff game (and therefore make the conference title game). The Steelers and Panthers are the hardest two to judge because they had Super Bowl aspirations before the season but it is difficult to see either making the Super Bowl this season because they'd have to win 3 road games to do it. The Pats and Colts are "win the Lombardi or bust" teams this season.