IDrinkyourMilkshake
Footballguy
I am curious to see if a theory of mine has any merit. Which kickers made it to championship weekend?
It is actually the opposite. I'm trying to prove that kickers do matter. A stud kicker may be the best indicator of success. I'll be doing some heavy statistical analysis over the next three or four days to see if there are indeed any fantasy implications to my theory.Is the theory that kickers don't matter that much?![]()
Carpenter Vs. Carney in my league. And Carney is my kicker. I decided to go with him over Vinitieri.Bironas vs. CarneyThere goes your theory.![]()
SameBironas vs. Gostkowski.
In-laws coming in town, eh?IDrinkyourMilkshake said:I'll be doing some heavy statistical analysis over the next three or four days to see if there are indeed any fantasy implications to my theory.Jeremy said:Is the theory that kickers don't matter that much?![]()
Good thing you don't work for FidelityJeremy said:Is the theory that kickers don't matter that much?Bironas, Kaeding, and Tynes are the only ones in my 3 leagues that I can recall off the top of my head. Can't access my fantasy management sites at work.
exactly thisKaeding (me) vs Bironas
Ouch!TheFanatic said:Carpenter Vs. Carney in my league. And Carney is my kicker. I decided to go with him over Vinitieri.C-Bound said:Bironas vs. Carney
There goes your theory.![]()
I'm obsessively careful about DST matchups, but I tend to meet your description a little with kickers. This year, Nick Folk was KILLING me down the stretch and was a big part of me not winning the high points award at week 13 (which is a $1200 payout). Painful. I'm rolling with Hartley, but I'm considering: 1. Reed vs BAL2. SF kicker vs DET3. Kris Brown vs MIAI just don't trust my judgment with these damned kickers!!Man in the yellow hat said:That's a lot of Nate Kaeding already.One thing I noticed is a lot of owners don't pay attention during the season. They'll draft a kicker thinking they don't matter, but never adjust. So, they'll run the 20th ranked kicker out there every week even though there's someone better sitting there as a free agent.The same thing happens with defenses at times.I don't understand that mindset.
Me too, for now, though I might swap out Kaeding if the Tenn. weather picks up and put in Hartley instead, been carrying two kickers for the playoffs just in case. Of course, my only QB is Peyton, so I might get burned there instead.Mr. Know-It-All said:Kaeding v Tynes
This.Ted Lange as your Bartender said:Akers vs Kaeding
Me neither. I swap out PK and DT in most leagues almost every week based on matchups, and my points at those positions are usually among the league leaders.Right or wrong, in most of my leagues we can still work the WW even during playoffs, so in one of my title games my PK is not yet set (WW is tonight). In the other, where the WW has been closed for awhile, I'm starting -- yup -- Kaeding. Opponent has Tynes.Man in the yellow hat said:That's a lot of Nate Kaeding already.
One thing I noticed is a lot of owners don't pay attention during the season. They'll draft a kicker thinking they don't matter, but never adjust. So, they'll run the 20th ranked kicker out there every week even though there's someone better sitting there as a free agent.
The same thing happens with defenses at times.
I don't understand that mindset.
Unless you can land a Kaeding/Akers/Tynes type kicker, I think playing the wire is the way to go. Even Tynes and Akers can be potentially dangerous late in the season depending on weather. But having a kicker like Kaeding is a very nice luxury to have.Me neither. I swap out PK and DT in most leagues almost every week based on matchups, and my points at those positions are usually among the league leaders.Right or wrong, in most of my leagues we can still work the WW even during playoffs, so in one of my title games my PK is not yet set (WW is tonight). In the other, where the WW has been closed for awhile, I'm starting -- yup -- Kaeding. Opponent has Tynes.Man in the yellow hat said:That's a lot of Nate Kaeding already.
One thing I noticed is a lot of owners don't pay attention during the season. They'll draft a kicker thinking they don't matter, but never adjust. So, they'll run the 20th ranked kicker out there every week even though there's someone better sitting there as a free agent.
The same thing happens with defenses at times.
I don't understand that mindset.
I have Hartley in both my leagues, playing against Prater in one, Kaeding in the other.GreenMachine51 said:Hartley vs. Prater