What kind of value does Jahvid Best have? (1 Viewer)

[solorca]

So I'm tired of Best's mediocre games and have been thinking about trying to unload him. Because of a few huge games, his overall numbers look pretty good, so I think I can get something decent out of him, but I'm trying to decide what his value is like.

Has anyone sold on him recently, or traded for him? What kind of value is he bringing?

 

[tkrull]

I tried to package him with a lesser QB1 to the Romo/Garrard owner for Chris Johnson. Couldn't get him to bite. I guess he wasn't in panic mode.

 

[JbizzleMan]

His value is warming my bench next weekend.

 

[ROBOPUNTER]

 

[thekidd2009]

should have sold him awhile ago and didn't....anyone that has been following football the last 5 weeks knows how poor best has been and i doubt you will be able to get much for him.

 

[solorca]

For some reason, Darren Mcfadden is extremely undervalued in my league (he's been traded three times for very weak deals), so I'm going to see if I can get him straight up for Best.

In a PPR, Best is extremely consistent in getting 10-12 points, but it's just not enough to give any confidence going forward.

 

[Trey]

I guess everyone must be down on him since he started the season on fire, but he's not the trash that everyone is making him out to be.

I like him as a PPR flex option with Stafford back in there. Very explosive offense and he should be good for a decent amount of touches each week.

 

[two_dollars]

I thought I saw a thread after week 3 calling him a top 5 pick in redraft and the top dynasty rb.. you should be able to get a king's ransom for him!

 

[dickey moe]

I've been offered Braylon Edwards and/or Santana Moss in a dynasty league for Best. I'd rather hold on to him.

 

[solorca]

I guess everyone must be down on him since he started the season on fire, but he's not the trash that everyone is making him out to be.I like him as a PPR flex option with Stafford back in there. Very explosive offense and he should be good for a decent amount of touches each week.

I don't think he's terrible, he's just not putting up points that are at a high enough level to help me that much. I'm getting the same amount of points from Beanie Wells, who I picked up for almost nothing.If I can get something that can actually help my team for Best, I'm going to go for it.

 

[fred_1_15301]

For some reason, Darren Mcfadden is extremely undervalued in my league (he's been traded three times for very weak deals), so I'm going to see if I can get him straight up for Best. In a PPR, Best is extremely consistent in getting 10-12 points, but it's just not enough to give any confidence going forward.

Not a chance you get that trade to work unless the other owner is senile...............

 

[Bonka]

Don't see the point in trying to shop him at the moment. His value has definitely dropped since week 2, but he's still putting up decent points in PPR. Once he starts scoring TDs again things should be good. If anything, go out and trade for him now if you can get him cheap.

 

[jon_mx]

He is still the 10th ranked RB in the league having outscored the likes of Ray Rice, MJD, Micheal Turner, Steven Jackson...he hasn't had a good game in weeks, but he still puts up some numbers for PPR. Having turf toe injuries in both feet has really impacted his explosiveness and caused him to lose quite a few carries. The injury will likely hamper him for much of the year, so he drops from a solid RB1 to an RB2. Still performing much higher than where people drafted him.

 

[solorca]

For some reason, Darren Mcfadden is extremely undervalued in my league (he's been traded three times for very weak deals), so I'm going to see if I can get him straight up for Best. In a PPR, Best is extremely consistent in getting 10-12 points, but it's just not enough to give any confidence going forward.

Not a chance you get that trade to work unless the other owner is senile...............

I would agree with you, but this league is strange. Mcfadden was traded two weeks ago for Cedric Benson. Last week, after scoring 49 points in our league, he was traded for Jeremy Maclin.I don't know what is up with this league, but he's waaaay undervalued. I didn't even try to get him because I didn't think that I had enough value that I was willing to give up for him...but for some reason, my league is wacky.

 

[fred_1_15301]

For some reason, Darren Mcfadden is extremely undervalued in my league (he's been traded three times for very weak deals), so I'm going to see if I can get him straight up for Best. In a PPR, Best is extremely consistent in getting 10-12 points, but it's just not enough to give any confidence going forward.

Not a chance you get that trade to work unless the other owner is senile...............

I would agree with you, but this league is strange. Mcfadden was traded two weeks ago for Cedric Benson. Last week, after scoring 49 points in our league, he was traded for Jeremy Maclin.I don't know what is up with this league, but he's waaaay undervalued. I didn't even try to get him because I didn't think that I had enough value that I was willing to give up for him...but for some reason, my league is wacky.

Well I would definitely throw that offer out there and see if it sticks.........

 

[jamny]

I don't know...he's serving me well as the RB#2 that I drafted him as.

edit: he now sits at #10 in my league @ RB...ahead of my #1 pick MJD.

 

[ufgatorbuc]

I traded Best & Pierre Garcon for Adrian Peterson this week...Look at me!

 

[BobbyLayne]

Going into today, over the last 5 weeks (games 3-6 and the bye) we was RB40 on a PPG average in non-PPR.

If you get value for him, kudos. I haven't started him all month.

 

[Air Stich]

I traded Best & Pierre Garcon for Adrian Peterson this week...Look at me!

Sounds like you're in a league with some pretty sharky opponents.

 

[netnalp]

After week 5 I traded Best for DeSean Jackson.

 

[CravenM]

If you want him to break off 30+ points for you next week, just ask me to sit him on my bench - that's the only time he goes off.

My bad...

 

[norgay]

I'll echo what others have stated already. Despite his poor yardage per carry and lack of TDs recently, in PPR leagues he's still very serviceable due to his involvement in the passing game. Not spectacular, but serviceable, with ~12 points per game. A consistent 12 points from your 2nd RB or flex isn't bad as long as you are strong in other positions.

So, IMO at this point he's probably more valuable as a Flex than as trade bait. But there is still some hype about him and if he has another big week you may be able to pull in solid value for him.

 

[footballsavvy]

No one is concerned about Kevin Smith? It seems that each week he gets more healthy and confident and his role increases. 12 carries each this game, and Kevin Smith did not come out of the game on 3rd downs when it was "his series".

Maybe they are just keeping Best's load light since hes still somewhat injured.

 

[CravenM]

No one is concerned about Kevin Smith? It seems that each week he gets more healthy and confident and his role increases. 12 carries each this game, and Kevin Smith did not come out of the game on 3rd downs when it was "his series".Maybe they are just keeping Best's load light since hes still somewhat injured.

Maybe it's the booze talking but I thought Kevin Smith looked great from the plays I saw.

 

[oukurt]

Painful to watch anymore.

 

[Simayi]

I was able to trade Roethlisberger and Best for Adrian Peterson earlier this week (other guy had Romo as his QB)

 

[shortbow]

I think its pretty clear from last year and the year before, that Kevin smith is barely Jahvid Best's relief back.

 

[BobbyLayne]

No one is concerned about Kevin Smith? It seems that each week he gets more healthy and confident and his role increases. 12 carries each this game, and Kevin Smith did not come out of the game on 3rd downs when it was "his series".Maybe they are just keeping Best's load light since hes still somewhat injured.

Smith played well today, and looked decent before the bye. But no, I don't think he is going to take over barring an injury. He's been rehabbing for nine months and in his own words still isn't 100% (and probably won't be until after the season ends). He is a decent blocker and has good hands and I expect him to be part of the rotation; he more or less jump started the offense today, because the Lions had no rushing game until he started getting positive yards in the third quarter.Part of the mix, sure, but the main ingredient? Doubtful.

 

[footballsavvy]

No one is concerned about Kevin Smith? It seems that each week he gets more healthy and confident and his role increases. 12 carries each this game, and Kevin Smith did not come out of the game on 3rd downs when it was "his series".Maybe they are just keeping Best's load light since hes still somewhat injured.

Smith played well today, and looked decent before the bye. But no, I don't think he is going to take over barring an injury. He's been rehabbing for nine months and in his own words still isn't 100% (and probably won't be until after the season ends). He is a decent blocker and has good hands and I expect him to be part of the rotation; he more or less jump started the offense today, because the Lions had no rushing game until he started getting positive yards in the third quarter.Part of the mix, sure, but the main ingredient? Doubtful.

Nor am I worried he will be the "main ingredient". I'm more concerned that they continue a 50/50 split. Coach iterated all along that Best would be his full time back, now he rotates every series.... Best may not be 100% but neither is Smith. I can't really imagine a scenario in which Smith goes back to a minor relief role the way he has been playing. His stats might not reflect how much better he looks running the ball than Best right now.

 

[Chili Cheese Burrito]

No one is concerned about Kevin Smith? It seems that each week he gets more healthy and confident and his role increases. 12 carries each this game, and Kevin Smith did not come out of the game on 3rd downs when it was "his series".Maybe they are just keeping Best's load light since hes still somewhat injured.

Smith played well today, and looked decent before the bye. But no, I don't think he is going to take over barring an injury. He's been rehabbing for nine months and in his own words still isn't 100% (and probably won't be until after the season ends). He is a decent blocker and has good hands and I expect him to be part of the rotation; he more or less jump started the offense today, because the Lions had no rushing game until he started getting positive yards in the third quarter.Part of the mix, sure, but the main ingredient? Doubtful.

He sure looked good picking up blitzes. I thought Kevin played a great game. If I were a Best owner I would be a little worried. This was at the end of the game when Kevin was getting all the playing time. Best is the guy, but I think the coaches went with the hot hand today.

 

[shortbow]

No one is concerned about Kevin Smith? It seems that each week he gets more healthy and confident and his role increases. 12 carries each this game, and Kevin Smith did not come out of the game on 3rd downs when it was "his series".Maybe they are just keeping Best's load light since hes still somewhat injured.

Smith played well today, and looked decent before the bye. But no, I don't think he is going to take over barring an injury. He's been rehabbing for nine months and in his own words still isn't 100% (and probably won't be until after the season ends). He is a decent blocker and has good hands and I expect him to be part of the rotation; he more or less jump started the offense today, because the Lions had no rushing game until he started getting positive yards in the third quarter.Part of the mix, sure, but the main ingredient? Doubtful.

He sure looked good picking up blitzes. I thought Kevin played a great game. If I were a Best owner I would be a little worried. This was at the end of the game when Kevin was getting all the playing time. Best is the guy, but I think the coaches went with the hot hand today.

Nothing new, since best injured his toe they have been alternating series, usually smith is in on the 2 minute drill but best snuck in a couple of those. Either way, former smith owner and believer, hes garbage in comparison, he would be a great change of pace back if they werent similar and best wasnt better in every way.

 

[monkeysee]

Wait, what? I wouldn't trade him for Rice, MJD, or Peterson!

 

[D'OHtis]

Dynasty PPR:

I'd still have no problem taking him Round 1 next year.

Personally not concerned about Kevin Smith. Felt the ideal opportunity to acquire Smith (as a dirt cheap backup that'll produce if/when gets hurt in future) was immediately after Best was drafted. Smith is one of the better backup RB's in the league. I expect Smith to hover in the 8-12 touch area & it's probably best for the long-term health of Best. Best's ability in the receiving game is what will make up for lesser carries.

Would depend on the upgrades in a multi-player deal. I'd be expecting a Top 10-15 fantasy player (if dealing 1-for-1)

 

[Clifford]

I would take whatever I could get at this point. Obvious his team is not going to put him in a position to succeed.

 

[GManiac]

I would take whatever I could get at this point. Obvious his team is not going to put him in a position to succeed.

Absolutely. In fact, he's only the 26th ranked player in my leagues, could probably snag Kitna or even Troy Smith (cross your fingers).

 

[Arizona Ron]

In a Dynasty league, he's a must-keep.

 

[GManiac]

In a Dynasty league, he's a must-keep.

I would still sell if I could get top value for him. Some owners in Dynasty leagues will still think just as highly of him, for good reason. Trying to get Ray Rice with him recently.

 

[odin33]

For reference (non PPR, standard scoring): Last week I sent Branch and Best for Flacco and Matthews

I only had Romo with solid RB depth, he needed WR help and was 3 deep at QB

 

[GManiac]

For reference (non PPR, standard scoring): Last week I sent Branch and Best for Flacco and MatthewsI only had Romo with solid RB depth, he needed WR help and was 3 deep at QB

I was considering trying to get Mathews with him. But Mathews has looked very mediocre. Best at least has shown some explosiveness. Mathews really worries me right now. Luckily I wasn't able to get him in my leagues.

 

[odin33]

For reference (non PPR, standard scoring): Last week I sent Branch and Best for Flacco and MatthewsI only had Romo with solid RB depth, he needed WR help and was 3 deep at QB

I was considering trying to get Mathews with him. But Mathews has looked very mediocre. Best at least has shown some explosiveness. Mathews really worries me right now. Luckily I wasn't able to get him in my leagues.

I agree I'd rhater have Best but I've got the depth (Gore, Bradshaw) to not be forced to use him, and I was in a real bind to get a starting QB.

 

[Kuz]

I traded him yesterday with Maclin for Hakeem Nicks

 

[Dr. No]

in a non-ppr where I have him, he's absolute bench-fodder.

However, I can't help but feel like I might give him another shot next year because it seems like the turf toe has been what killed him.

I'm not sure if I can think of too many hyped round 1 RB's that all got starting opportunities and all have blew them either because of injury or otherwise... best, spiller, mathews.... all were taken in the first 4 rounds.... none have done particularly well other than 2 of best's weeks.

 

[Hanz]

What kind of TE can one expect to get with Best?

a Zach Miller type or a Tamme type perhaps?

 

[damageinc]

Kevin Smith - RB - Lions

Kevin Smith (knee) was limited in Lions practice Wednesday.

Smith is coming off his most extensive workload since 2009 ACL surgery, so perhaps it shouldn't be a surprise that he's battling soreness or swelling in the knee. He came off the bench to lead the Lions in rushing in Week 8.

Nov. 3 - 7:44 p.m. ET

Jahvid Best - RB - Lions

Jahvid Best (toe) has resumed practicing without restrictions.

In the meantime, Kevin Smith was limited Wednesday with a knee injury. The two played in a rotation against the Redskins, so Best may be in line to retake the upper hand in the backfield. The extent of Smith's injury is unknown.

Nov. 3 - 7:43 p.m. ET

 

[Superty88x]

Just traded Jahvid and Brandon Marshall for Hakeem and Sjax in my ppr

 

[plyka]

Don't see the point in trying to shop him at the moment. His value has definitely dropped since week 2, but he's still putting up decent points in PPR. Once he starts scoring TDs again things should be good. If anything, go out and trade for him now if you can get him cheap.

I always wait for threads like this so I can move in the opposite direction.

 

[Squintz82]

Traded Best and Zach Miller for Mendenhall this week

 

[Clifford]

Kevin Smith - RB - LionsKevin Smith (knee) was limited in Lions practice Wednesday.Smith is coming off his most extensive workload since 2009 ACL surgery, so perhaps it shouldn't be a surprise that he's battling soreness or swelling in the knee. He came off the bench to lead the Lions in rushing in Week 8.Nov. 3 - 7:44 p.m. ET Jahvid Best - RB - LionsJahvid Best (toe) has resumed practicing without restrictions.In the meantime, Kevin Smith was limited Wednesday with a knee injury. The two played in a rotation against the Redskins, so Best may be in line to retake the upper hand in the backfield. The extent of Smith's injury is unknown.Nov. 3 - 7:43 p.m. ET

good find. he hasn't practiced on Wednesday in a while, but I didn't know that about Smith. Probably nothing, and I wonder if they would just use Felton or Morris more if he were out.Cmon Schwartz, feed the midget!

 

[sib]

I traded Best for the potential 1.1 in 2011 in a 10 team dynasty ppr league. The guy I traded with is in last place with 2 less wins than the 9th place team. This guy also plays the best team in the league this week and has half his team on bye week 10, so I'd say there is a great chance the pick could be 1.1; it will definitely be a top 3 pick.

 

[stubby]

I traded FOR Best. Got him straight up for Bowe in my 0.5 PPR league.