What would a win-now team require to trade Barkley? (1 Viewer)

[Jonesin For Some Football]

12 team, .5 PPR, Start 1QB/1RB/2WR/2 Flex/1TE

Returning champ and built to win but someone is pushing for Barkley.  The offer is:

Antonio Gibson, DJ Moore, Irv Smith, 1.7, and 1.8

for

Saquon Barkley and 2022 1st (projected late)

My roster currently is:

QB - Dak, Carson Wentz, Big Ben, Sam Darnold

RB - Barkley, Kamara, Mixon, David Montgomery, Gus Edwards, Gio, Benny Snell, and Eno Benjamin

WR - Davante Adams, Tyreek Hill, Sterling Shepard, Perriman, Jalen Reagor, and Quintez Cephus

TE - Travis Kelce and George Kittle

Current Picks - 1.5, 3.9, 4.4, and 5.9

Is this enough for Barkley for a team ready to win the title this year?

 

[Gally]

The way it seems is one of Gibson or Moore replaces Barkley as your starter and the rest are bench fodder.  Irv isn't going to help you at all (other than to free up moving Kittle or Kelce if you wanted but that still is a stretch).  

I would need a stud in return that helps my starting lineup to make me think about moving him.  This offer doesn't really do that for me.  It's a solid offer and if you aren't sold on Barkley due to coming off a second major injury and a bad o-line then it could be close.  If you think Barkley is the redraft #1 or #2 guy as we was going into last year then you need more. 

 

[Jonesin For Some Football]

The way it seems is one of Gibson or Moore replaces Barkley as your starter and the rest are bench fodder.  Irv isn't going to help you at all (other than to free up moving Kittle or Kelce if you wanted but that still is a stretch).  

I would need a stud in return that helps my starting lineup to make me think about moving him.  This offer doesn't really do that for me.  It's a solid offer and if you aren't sold on Barkley due to coming off a second major injury and a bad o-line then it could be close.  If you think Barkley is the redraft #1 or #2 guy as we was going into last year then you need more. 

Thanks.  That is kind of my thoughts as well.  I was thinking of asking for Miles Sanders and Allen Robinson instead of Gibson and Moore but still feel like it hurts me this year.

 

[Gally]

Thanks.  That is kind of my thoughts as well.  I was thinking of asking for Miles Sanders and Allen Robinson instead of Gibson and Moore but still feel like it hurts me this year.

Again, none of those are clear stud at their positions.  It's basically a wash to Gibson and Moore.  You can make arguments on why each pair is preferred but there is no clear cut winner.