Which Bottom of the Barrel QB Shines? (1 Viewer)

[Stompin' Tom Connors]

All of these QBs did not begin the season as their team's signal caller, but have been forced under center for a variety of reasons.

All seem to have fairly decent matchups:

Weinke faces an ATL D who is near the bottom of the heap in terms of yards allowed.

Rattay looked good last week, and the Browns couldn't sack groceries at the Piggly Wiggly, let alone a QB.

Campbell looks really comfortable with the WAS offence, has some good targets in Moss and Cooley, and faces a middle of the road Rams D.

Derek Anderson and the rest of his team were batted around by the Ravens last week, but Anderson still fared pretty solidly, all things considered -- and now faces a Tampa Bay team that pretty much cedes a TD and a half per game through the air.

Who do you think has the best day?

Me, I think Campbell may have the toughest matchup, but has looked the most consistent and steady. What say you? Choose and post an explanation,

ETA: FWIW I own none of these QBs.

 

[Gr00vus]

Tough choices here.

I think the Rams are actually the worst defense of the four, so that favors Campbell.

I think right now Rattay is probably the most "polished" of the selections.

But I went with wee willy Wienke because Steve Smith could blow up at any time and carry his qb to good numbers off a couple of quick outs or slants that he catches for 7 and takes for 57.

 

[The Football Freak]

I like Anderson here at home. He has put up some nice games the last three weeks against KC, PIT and BAL and is now home against the struggling Bucs. I think he puts up over 200 with a couple scores, maybe even breaks off a nice run or two. Of course you are taking a chance, because it is the Browns, but he looks like he could have a good week to me. Braylon and KW2 could get some decent stats this week.

 

[-OZ-]

I would start Campbell, but Rattay could go off big. Just too risky in his 1st start.