Which of the Big 4 WR will finish #1? (2 Viewers)

[ComfortablyNumb]

In a non-PPR scoring system, a solid case can be made for any of these four, IMO. What sayeth the pool?

 

[FUBAR]

This year, Randy Moss barring injury

 

[BobbyLayne]

You could make a strong case for either Fitz, the Freak or Megatron.

Fitz was productive with McCown and Leinart so the supposed injury risk of Warner doesn't worry me too much.

However, when healthy, Boldin is a historically a better RZ threat.

Calvin? Gets hits regardless of who is chucking it in his general vicinity.

I'll go with the guy who carried my fantasy squad all last year.

:homergoggles:

In PPR, Andre has an equally strong case IMO. Can't go wrong with any of these studs.

 

[MCguidance]

For me:

Non-PPR Moss

PPR- Fitz

 

[jurb26]

Moss no matter the format. No WR has near the upside potential as Moss. He probably only has 2 more dominant years left, but he is my easy pick for WR1 and is in a tier by himself.

 

[ComfortablyNumb]

Pretty surprising results. I didn't think Fitz would finish a distant 4th, trailing Moss 25-6. There must be a lot of voters who are concerned about Warner's health.

I know Calvin had pretty weak QB play last year, but it might be even worse for him this year. But if anyone can overcome triple-teams and poor QB play, it's Calvin.