Which QB should I target in trade (non-ppr dynasty)? (1 Viewer)

[northern exposure]

In a Zealots 12 team dynasty non-ppr league (53 man roster, start 1 QB) I have Brees, Bridgewater, Wentz, Fitzpatrick and Keenum at QB. I drafted Wentz and panicked when Bridgewater went down and added Fitz and Keenum as backups to Brees in case Wentz didn't get the starting job. 

Now with Bridgwater's future up in the air I think I need to find a young QB to pair with Wentz after Brees retires. Another owner has Carr, Luck and Newton at QB. So, he seemed like a logical target for a trade. That is until I started trade talks with him. He has said he may be willing to move one of them, but his asking price is pretty much the same for any of them.

His suggestion:

I give: T Y Hilton, 2017 1st, 2018 1st 

I get: The QB he decides to trade

To me that is a crazy high price in a 12 team league that only starts 1 QB. 

I would rank his QBs as Luck, Carr, Newton. 

So, which QB would you target and what ballpark of a counter-offer would you make?


 

 

[Snorkelson]

HAHA nice joke! That is stupid high, so forget that guy. You have a year or two to figure it out, Brees is still playing and wentz looks pretty good. Target one in the draft, or look for sneaky adds for right now like maybe cardale jones or Mike Glennon if they are on the ww. Hoyer could be a stopgap somewhere. Otherwise I'd maybe look for someone a bit cheaper like a dalton, flacco, or Eli coming off down years. 

 

[RC94]

HAHA nice joke! That is stupid high, so forget that guy. You have a year or two to figure it out, Brees is still playing and wentz looks pretty good. Target one in the draft, or look for sneaky adds for right now like maybe cardale jones or Mike Glennon if they are on the ww. Hoyer could be a stopgap somewhere. Otherwise I'd maybe look for someone a bit cheaper like a dalton, flacco, or Eli coming off down years. 

I agree with this.  You are good at QB for now with Brees and if you get a cheap, young QB like a rookie (in the 2nd or 3rd round) or someone like Glennon, to go with Wentz you have some upside to wait and see with for the future.  That guy's offer is so ridiculous that I wouldn't bother with him, even if you do want to trade for a QB. 

 

[Dave Stauff]

Without seeing his roster it's unclear how motivated he'd be to trade away from a strength.  Maybe he could care less about converting one of these QB's into added strength at another position.  I'd assume since he inquired about Hilton that he may feel thin there, but in the Shark Pool dynasty startup voting, Hilton came in at 14 and no QB has been selected yet (currently at 21 and Luck is close).  So I'd simply tell the guy it's Hilton for Luck - or it's any QB you choose for any WR I choose (and list your top 3)