Which RB would you rather roster (1 Viewer)

[TheKillerBrees]

It's a full Dynasty (Everyone is a keeper and the only draft each year is a short rookie draft)

NON PPR scoring

My RB's are hurt all over the place, so I am looking at both overall upside and youth AS WELL as potential to maybe start a game or 2 for me

Which one of these guys would you roster?

Dion Lewis (the one currently on my roster who would get cut if I want to make a switch)

Alex Collins (Mess of a backfield, but maybe he takes the lead? + I actually drafted then cut him last year so I have a bit of a soft spot for him)

D Booker (If Anderson got hurt???)

Wayne Gallman (What a terrible line and backfield, but maybe that means there's a job to win?)

(there are also guys like Ivory, Oliver, Cory Clement on wire?)

Oh and hey... while you're here ;-)

Which QB to hold as the "Project for the future"

Brett Hundley

or

Jacoby Brisset

(potential for points this year is irrelevant, I won't start Brisset even if I pick him up anyway, so is Hundley the better long term?)

??

(thanks for any help and leave a link to yours if you so desire!!)

 

[beerbuff]

None are great options but if you want help this year I would go with Collins. He's the lottery ticket out of that group that currently has the easiest path to relevance. For the QB spot Brissett has current playability and seriously Luck could be one more injury away from being done. Hundley might have to wait a couple of more years.

 

[wlwiles]

In a non-PPR I think you're safe cutting bait on Lewis.  He's got loads of talent but as one of the 4 heads in that backfield, and it being non-PPR I don't see him as doing much for you unless he gets traded.   Booker has had some chances to show what he can do when Anderson is out, and what he can do is he can fumble with the best of em.  There's a reason Denver went and got Charles...Booker isn't the solution.  Giants are turrible right now and haven't had a reliable RB since the Jacobs/Bradshaw days, and even then they're going to be a pass first team with OBJ young and the focal point of that offense, so I don't see Gallman being the one to provide future value.  

I'd personally go for Collins.  Ravens backfield is a mess, and Collins has shown flashes.  If Buck Allen were the answer we'd have known it by now.  Woodhead is what he is - the pass catcher, who gets injured a lot.  There's always the threat of Dixon coming back but if Collins plays well this year I could see him forcing a timeshare next year with Dixon, and Collins may be startable in the second half of this season if you get desparate. 

As for QBs, I think Brissett has shown enough that he's the interesting one you want.  Yeah Luck is young and it's obviously his team, but given his injury history Brissett is good insurance, and there's always the chance that if Brissett shows well enough this year that he finds a new team a la Glennon/McCown and becomes a starter somewhere.   I don't think Hundley is ever going to see the field enough to be valuable, or to have a chance to even show what his value can be

 

[Trelocke]

Collins, hands down. Lewis is a decent lotto ticket if he gets traded, but right now I don't see the fit for him. Chargers maybe with Woodhead down. I think Collins is the slightly better roster stash.