Which Side of this trade do you prefer? (1 Viewer)

[Mr. Know-It-All]

Std scoring, 1 pt ppr, 6 pt tds (incl qb passing)

Team A - gives QB Brady, RB Hunt, WR Agholor

Team B - gives QB Smith, RB McCoy, WR Bryant

I am Team A and at first I thought I was giving up too much - but the more I look at it, and considering I have Prescott as my QB2....McCoy and Hunt are fairly similar and McCoy already done with bye week - and Bryant is significantly better than Agholor...or am I overvaluing Bryant because of his name?  Should I counter offer for Hogan or Crabtree?

 

[Pnishthm]

At first I thought you were giving up too much as well.  But you make sense in your reasoning.  I still don't think I pull the trigger.  We don't really know how it's going to affect Dak if Elliot gets suspended.  If you need a WR upgrade just try and trade one of your QBs straight up...

 

[J R]

I wouldn't make that trade either.

 

[abricru]

Hi,

I have similar scoring in my league.

I looked at the stats.  Hunt scored an average of about 5 fantasy points more per game than McCoy.

However, Bryant scored an average of 8 points more than Agholor.

Smith, Prescott, and Brady's averages were extremely close.

Just based on the stats so far, you would have the advantage if you did make the trade.

So I would say,yes,make the trade.

Good Luck!

 

[wlwiles]

What's the goal of the trade?  Are you needing an upgrade somewhere, or is the other guy trying to get a certain player/upgrade from you?  Gotta know what the purpose is to understand if you should do it or not.  Who made the offer/reached out to talk trade?  Whats the rest of your team? 

Let's say that Hunt and McCoy are equal.  Is the other owner wanting Brady?  Are you wanting Bryant?  Seems like a 3 for 3 trade is unnecessarily big without understanding the situation a little more. 

 

[g25crusher]

I'd make the trade.  Agholor seems like simply a throw in to even out the numbers.  I'm not a Dez fan, but he could help down the stretch especially if Zeke gets traded and the passing game needs to become more prominent.

Smith=Brady.  McCoy+Dez>Hunt+Agholor.  IMHO.

 

[wheeleke]

Is there a way to get another position player rather than Alex Smith? Why do you need a backup QB if Prescott has already had his bye week. Unless it's a 2 QB league. I would say McCoy and Dez is greater than Hunt/Agholor. Just hard to see Agholor getting consistent targets when he's 3rd on the target pole behind Ertz and Jeffery. He's maximizing his opportunities as few as they may be but to count on that efficiency is tough. I think Dez suffers from having no one else in their receiving corps drawing attention away from him but he still sees great target volume.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/762199-rate-my-team-moving-forward-will-help-in-return/