Which side wins? (1 Viewer)

[Matt's Eagles]

12 team dynasty

Team A gets Derrick Henry, Sterling Shepard, 2018 1st (most likely late)

Team B gets AJ Dalton, Duke Johnson, Brandon Marshall, D Thomas pick 2.7

 

[Snorkelson]

As long as it's Aj dalton and not aj green, I like the Henry side long term but team b for this year. 

 

[Matt's Eagles]

I would be giving up A side....

 

[Snorkelson]

I like dalton Marshall DT for the next 2 years if I'm trying to win over Henry/Shepard/2018 1, I like what you're giving over the next 5. So team makeup would sway me a lot one way or the other. I like how Henry and shep looked, but Henry will be behind Murray for another year and maybe splitting carries for a year after that, and Eli may not have much left. DT is still physically dominant, dalton is always underrated, and Marshall may have one more year as a wr3, similar to Steve smith the last couple. Duke, well, he may do something cool someday, and is a reasonable throw in. 

Its Andy dalton, right? Do people call him AJ? 

 

[Matt's Eagles]

Oops yes Andy Dalton....don't know why I had AJ

Throw in RB was Duke or Woodhead

 

[Scot from LV]

I like the Team B side, despite the youth of Team A.

 

[jeaton6]

Team A landslide

 

[Warhogs]

Assuming start 1 QB I like the side getting Henry Shepard and the 1st.  Dalton isn't a great starter in a 12 team league.  Duke is also more of a bench guy and Marshall is getting old.  The only real piece lost is DT but that is getting some nice young pieces for him.

 

[aaj1997]

I would prefer Team A but if DT/Marshall are the missing pieces for a contender I think it is certainly a fair trade.

 

[Gally]

As someone mentioned in an earlier post, this is highly dependent upon team makeup.  In a vacuum I would prefer Team A as most of the players on the Team B side are blah.  I think Henry is special and Shepherd is solid.