Which side? (1 Viewer)

[Matt's Eagles]

12 team dynasty PPR

Team A gets Lesean McCoy, 2018 3rd rounder

Team B gets Paul Perkins, Braxton Miller, late 18 1st

 

[Arodin]

McCoy pretty easily here.

 

[drewd_21]

Same...McCoy easily

 

[Gally]

Agree.  McCoy is the only stud in the deal.  Take him easily.

 

[travdogg]

I apparently am higher on Perkins than everyone else, because I don't think this is an easy call at all. I'd still prefer the McCoy side, but its a fair deal.

 

[fightingillini]

It's not a lopsided deal, but I think McCoy is getting purchased here for about 85 cents on the dollar.....so McCoy side for me.

 

[Drinkin Buddy]

McCoys on the old side but will give you elite production in the short term. Certainly worth what you are giving up.

see mine pls:

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/756524-mccaffreysnead-for-hydecj-andersondevante-adams/

 

[amstaff24]

Thinking long term I like team B.  I would roll with Perkins, Miller and the 1st next year.

 

[burnall]

Shady side

 

[steelers1080]

Shady.

 

[Matt's Eagles]

He countered with

i give McCoy

i get Perkins, Ross, Jonnu Smith 18 1st

my roster

Dak, Palmer, Kizer, Dobbs

howard, McCoy, Lynch, Martin, Sims, Vereen, pumphrey, McGuire, T Cohen

wr TY Hilton, Mike Thomas, Larry Fitz, Sanders, Britt, Zay  Jones, Aiken, Darboh, Zamora, JJ nelson, A Stewart

TE Jesse James, d Allen, Higbee, McDonald

 

[jwsbowler]

what is your roster size???  what are your starting lineup requirements?   McCoy is the best of all the pieces in the latest offer... IMO, I am keeping McCoy

 

[Matt's Eagles]

I am leaning towards keeping McCoy... especially for that package.... start 1 QB, 2Rbs, 3 WRs, 1 TE, 1 flex...roster size is 25, we have to cut 1 week prior to season 

 

[jwsbowler]

I am leaning towards keeping McCoy... especially for that package.... start 1 QB, 2Rbs, 3 WRs, 1 TE, 1 flex...roster size is 25, we have to cut 1 week prior to season 

so, based on these.... I am keeping McCoy.

 

[motoclube]

I would get LeSean McCoy and 2018 3rd rounder

 

[RoninJT]

He countered with

i give McCoy

i get Perkins, Ross, Jonnu Smith 18 1st

my roster

Dak, Palmer, Kizer, Dobbs

howard, McCoy, Lynch, Martin, Sims, Vereen, pumphrey, McGuire, T Cohen

wr TY Hilton, Mike Thomas, Larry Fitz, Sanders, Britt, Zay  Jones, Aiken, Darboh, Zamora, JJ nelson, A Stewart

TE Jesse James, d Allen, Higbee, McDonald

The original trade idea, I take it since I think Perkins,etc gives you fair value and depth for years to come in exchange for a moderate downgrade at RB. This new trade proposal, keep McCoy. Not a one-sided trade but I don't think the upside is there anymore.