JohnnyU
Footballguy
This is not taking into account long term success. Only expectations for 2024, meaning they were expected to do better than other rookies not expected to produce in 2024. This shouldn't include project players that you know won't be given much of a chance in 2024.
1) Keon Coleman - Buffalo is the drawing card here, but let's not forget the separation issues he had going into the draft. That hasn't suddenly been fixed. Buffalo is an attractive landing spot, but if he doesn't get open Josh Allen will look in other directions.
2) Xavier Legette - another raw prospect without a route tree, one year wonder? He will need some time to develop IMO, if ever.
3) Adonai Mitchell - I'm not sure AR can support two WRs, let alone three. Great spot for the Colts. Perhaps not for your fantasy team in 2024.
4) Drake Maye - Poor decision making and footwork won't help him in the beginning once he takes over in 2024 (and he will). I have doubts about his ability to deal with pressure. He can be a top 10 QB with the right coaching, but it won't be in 2024.
5) Ricky Pearsall - Only on the caveat that both Deebo and Aiyuk don't get traded. I'm not so sure Pearsall will see enough targets in 2024 with so many options in SF (Aiyuk, McCaffrey, Kittle). Don't get me wrong, I love Pearsall. I'm not sure I love him in 2024.
1) Keon Coleman - Buffalo is the drawing card here, but let's not forget the separation issues he had going into the draft. That hasn't suddenly been fixed. Buffalo is an attractive landing spot, but if he doesn't get open Josh Allen will look in other directions.
2) Xavier Legette - another raw prospect without a route tree, one year wonder? He will need some time to develop IMO, if ever.
3) Adonai Mitchell - I'm not sure AR can support two WRs, let alone three. Great spot for the Colts. Perhaps not for your fantasy team in 2024.
4) Drake Maye - Poor decision making and footwork won't help him in the beginning once he takes over in 2024 (and he will). I have doubts about his ability to deal with pressure. He can be a top 10 QB with the right coaching, but it won't be in 2024.
5) Ricky Pearsall - Only on the caveat that both Deebo and Aiyuk don't get traded. I'm not so sure Pearsall will see enough targets in 2024 with so many options in SF (Aiyuk, McCaffrey, Kittle). Don't get me wrong, I love Pearsall. I'm not sure I love him in 2024.
Last edited: