What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Who is the #3 WR from the Class of 2014? (1 Viewer)

Who is the #3 WR from the Class of 2014?

  • Marqise Lee

    Votes: 62 53.4%
  • Odell Beckham, Jr.

    Votes: 24 20.7%
  • Brandin Cooks

    Votes: 12 10.3%
  • Other

    Votes: 18 15.5%

  • Total voters
    116

Bob Magaw

Footballguy
The consensus seems to be solidifying around Watkins and Evans as the top two WRs (especially with Evans having an exceptional workout with his measurables and field drills).

Than it gets kind of murky from there. Previously Marqise Lee seemed next in line, but he disappointed somewhat, while Beckham and Cooks had outstanding, phenomenal Combine workouts. I know some already had Lee lower than the other two. But did anybody that had Lee at #3 pre-Combine move him below Beckham and/or Cooks?

Where will these five WRs ADPs be at for dynasty leagues? If the lower ones are similar to the higher ADP, that could present good value.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I personally like Lee as the #2 wr in this class. After that I like Jordan Mathews. There is something about Evans that scares me.

He just doesn't look really fluid out there.

 
Evens is not a consensus 2 right now. I like Lee more.
I don't have a favorite between them, completely different skill sets and both should be great. Situation will win the tie breaker. Picking third I am sure I'll be picking Lee though. Consensus seems to have swayed to Evans second.
 
Good question. I've got the #3 pick in a few leagues and I don't know who I'm taking yet. Might go RB. Might go WR.

I thought Evans looked okay at the combine. Not great. He's a bit lean and he seems more comfortable moving in a straight line than planting and cutting. Reminds me a bit of Michael Floyd. I didn't think he was tremendous in the route running. Not terrible, but not great. A little bit stiff. I think there's upside there, but he's a player who scares me a bit. I'm more comfortable with sudden prospects who can plant and explode than straight line guys.

I think Lee will be a successful pro. Ceiling is the question. He came in lighter and slower than I expected at the combine. He looked very athletic in the routes and that's probably more important to me than outright burner speed. On the other hand, there's nobody with his build lighting up the NFL right now. He may end up being a Santonio Holmes (minus the diva factor) rather than a truly elite player. In other words, an 1100 and 5 guy as opposed to a potential 1500 and 10 guy. Is that worth a top 3 pick? Would you give up a top 3 pick for Kendall Wright-like production when there are bigger upside guys out there? That's an interesting call.

Beckham, Cooks, and Moncrief also have a case IMO. Beckham looked great in the drills. Great athlete. No bust risk IMO. He has some of the same negatives as Lee though. Inconsistent hands and less than ideal height. I don't really see him as a potential top 5-10 dynasty WR, which is the stumbling block for me. Very high floor. How high is the ceiling though? Never been a huge Cooks fan, but he was clearly the most explosive WR in attendance. He's going to be very hard to cover due to his burst and could end up being what people thought they were getting in Tavon last year. In a best case scenario, he could be like what Antonio Brown was this past season. Finally, Moncrief is a wild card because he might be the one guy in the draft who most closely aligns with the elite NFL WR prototype from a height/weight/speed/explosiveness standpoint. That doesn't guarantee stardom, but if you want to draft a guy with a top ceiling as opposed to a safer pick with a lower ceiling, I think he has to be a candidate.

 
With Lee and Cooks, the Pac-12 has the last two Biletnikoff winners in 2012 and 2013. After taking a closer look at Cooks, very impressive WR. He had a lot of receptions, but many examples below where they were downfield and contested. He is feisty and has very sticky hands (might be the best of the three?). His elite suddenness and electric burst were on display at the Combine. Check out the play at the :49 second mark below. He is behind the DB as the ball approaches, at the last second leaps in front of the DB and one hands the ball and bats it to himself. One scout talked about how he doesn't telegraph the incoming pass by getting his hands up late, an advanced WR skill. I think in the 2014 Dynasty (or Combine or both) thread Xue used Antonio Brown/TY Hilton as a combo comp. Mac32 prompted me to think of Steve Smith, and maybe that is another comp?

Lee (running away with the poll) was about a tenth of a second slower than expected, but showed explosiveness with the 38" VJ. I think he is a 25' long jumper?. Maybe it spoke to lesser coverage, but he was getting separation below. He seemed to have the ability to mix up speeds, and have an extra gear when he was going after the ball I like to see. Some players just have superior competitive, game speed when they are being chased that doesn't always show up in these kinds of drills. Jerry Rice was "slow" by conventional drill metrics, but he was always running away from DBs and rarely caught from behind in games. I asked a reserve DB for the 49ers once who was on the team when Rice was there how he explained it, and he said Rice had incredible short area explosion. EBF came up with a Greg Jennings/Santonio Holmes/Randall Cobb mashup, but they might have tested a little faster. Lee had the second best long jump in the nation (24'8") as a prep and a 10.74 100 m. Cobb had a similar best 100 m. time (4.46 40 at the Combine). Holmes may have run about a 4.45 at the Combine, and was on two Florida state champion 4 X 400 relay teams. Jennings seemed to have more deceptive, sneaky speed, but I thought he was very smooth ascending up the gear train. I think Jennings ran a 4.42 at the Combine.

I liked the below article on Beckham on his flawless running technique.

Excerpt -

"Overall, the thing that impressed me most about Beckham in these drills was that he’s very comfortable with his speed. Not only is he track and field-fast, he also glides through routes and catches the ball with confidence. On the gauntlet drill, he ran through and caught everything, keeping his feet on the line all the way through. A lot of receivers weave through (Mike Evans had an issue with this), but Beckham stayed with his speed. He’s compact in his movements and doesn’t shoot out of line. This matches up with his game tape — even when he’s creating explosive plays, he’s consistent with his movements.

Beckham looked pretty good on the six-yard slant, making a quick in-cut to catch the ball. But on the 10-yard out to the left, he rounded his cut a bit, though he caught the ball. The 17-yard in-and-up was a bit more of an adventure — Beckham was a bit slow in his break off the line, and he rolled through the second pylon. And if there’s one thing I’d say he needs to work on, it’s the consistent ability to cut and keep with a quarterback’s timing. On deep routes with fewer angles, Beckham was in his element – fluid off the snap and great acceleration up the field. Moreover, that speed is consistent, meaning that quarterbacks can time him with confidence. And I believe that’s one of the more underrated attributes a receiver can have. He adjusted to his right and left on deeper routes to grab passes that were a bit off, and you love to see a player who can bail his quarterback out. Again, that’s consistent with his LSU tape.

Beckham was slightly choppy on the 12-yard curl, but he was clearly trying to be better with his cuts there, and he was okay. He ran through nicely and sank his hips into the breaks. The final route was a deep post corner, where the receiver starts at the 15-yard line, cuts in at the 26, out at the 34, and bends the route to about the 50-yard line. He sat in his breaks (adjusted to cut momentum) very well here and made another nice adjustment to catch the ball.

I had Beckham 19th on my pre-combine Big Board, but with the benefit of more game tape, and the ability to see him up close, I wouldn’t have any problem with a team taking him in the top 15. He’s a special talent with room at the top of his game for improvement at the NFL level."

http://nfl.si.com/2014/02/23/odell-beckham-lsu-nfl-combine-wide-receivers/

I think Beckham's mother was an All American sprinter at LSU and current collegiate track coach, his father an LSU RB and his stepfather Gold Medalist Derek Mills from the '96 Olympics 400 meter relay team. You could almost say he was destined to be a speed merchant.

http://www.startribune.com/sports/232213211.html

HIGHLIGHTS

Marqise Lee

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIjzTV0r1po

Odell Beckham, Jr.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jZbGUMevcI

Brandin Cooks

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfnYcEOHqCk

 
Last edited by a moderator:
My fear with Beckham is that he'll end up becoming another Josh Boyce/Andre Roberts. Two very athletic, very smooth guys who have yet to translate that into great receiving production in the NFL. I like Beckham more than I liked either of those guys, so I'm not trying to dog him with those comparisons. Just pointing out that being really athletic at ~5'10-5'11" isn't necessarily a recipe for dominating at WR in the NFL. There seems to be a lot of value in a big body. Look at Brandon Marshall, Demaryius Thomas, and Larry Fitzgerald. They're plenty quick, fast, and explosive, but if you put them in a combine setting I would not expect them to fare much better than the likes of Boyce/Roberts/Beckham in the drills. It's the combination of their overall athleticism AND their plus size frames that makes them so dominant. There are a few short guys in the league who have had big receiving seasons (Steve Smith, Antonio Brown, Victor Cruz). They're outnumbered among the league's elite by the big targets like Fitz, VJax, Calvin, Demaryius, Dez, Marshall, Gordon, and Jeffery.

I've faced a similar dilemma in the past in rookie drafts and dev drafts. Specifically with Kendall Wright vs. Michael Floyd in 2012 and Odell Beckham vs. Donte Moncrief in 2013. Do you take the small guy with flawless movement skills or do you take the bigger guy who isn't quite as smooth? I chose Wright in 2012 and Moncrief in 2013. Jury's still out on those picks. I know that when I'm on the clock and it's down to guys like Evans/Moncrief vs. guys like Beckham/Lee/Cooks, the lower ceiling is going to weigh on my mind. Not an easy call to make, IMO. The dream scenario is the Dez/Demaryius who has the huge body AND the flawless movement, but that guy isn't in this draft IMO.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
isn't the question who is #4 after Watkins, Evans and Lee?
im on an island, but - Abrederris.
Abbrederis reminds me of Julian Edelman. Abby isn't quite the athlete Edelman is, but he's not far behind. Not the exact body type, but close. Similar style/skill set.

I think he definitely fills a role for a team from the get-go. He'll never be a WR1 (fantasy), but I think he could top out as a WR2, if everything falls into place.

 
Is it likely that all of these 3 end up playing out of the slot? Pretty sure beckham/cooks will but what about Lee?
Cooks has been compared to Antonio Brown, TY Hilton and Steve Smith, and they all have played at a high level outside. So maybe he will play in the slot, depending where he goes, but he may not necessarily have to.

Beckham reminds me in some ways of Harvin and Cobb. Harvin lines up outside a lot, but I think Cobb more inside. He might be the most talented WR on the team, so could be a WR1.

If Lee is like Greg Jennings, he seems to unambiguously be an outside WR. He might be the strongest runner of the three.

I could see all of them eventually with 80-1,100-6 potential with upside.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I personally like Lee as the #2 wr in this class. After that I like Jordan Mathews. There is something about Evans that scares me.

He just doesn't look really fluid out there.
Matthews had a great combine. He's an elite prospect.

6'3

212 lbs

4.46 40

21 reps on the bench

Great route runner

Huge hands

Great college career.

What's the problem?

 
isn't the question who is #4 after Watkins, Evans and Lee?
im on an island, but - Abrederris.
Abbrederis reminds me of Julian Edelman. Abby isn't quite the athlete Edelman is, but he's not far behind. Not the exact body type, but close. Similar style/skill set.I think he definitely fills a role for a team from the get-go. He'll never be a WR1 (fantasy), but I think he could top out as a WR2, if everything falls into place.
i don't think their game could be much different, Abbrederis is an outside guy, if we are going to compare him to white receivers he is much closer to Jordy than Edelman.
 
isn't the question who is #4 after Watkins, Evans and Lee?
im on an island, but - Abrederris.
Abbrederis reminds me of Julian Edelman. Abby isn't quite the athlete Edelman is, but he's not far behind. Not the exact body type, but close. Similar style/skill set.I think he definitely fills a role for a team from the get-go. He'll never be a WR1 (fantasy), but I think he could top out as a WR2, if everything falls into place.
i don't think their game could be much different, Abbrederis is an outside guy, if we are going to compare him to white receivers he is much closer to Jordy than Edelman.
That was going to be my comp too, if we're comparing only white guys...

 
I'm clearly in the minority, but I don't like Lee at all. I think he has a very limited ceiling, and brings nothing special to the table. I see Stevie Johnson when I watch him. Then again, one could argue that if Stevie played his career with Peyton Manning at QB, instead of the average to bad QB play he has had in Buffalo, maybe he'd be regarded more highly.

I like Beckham the 3rd most, and I also prefer Cooks, Benjamin and possibly Landry(despite an awful combine) to Lee.

 
isn't the question who is #4 after Watkins, Evans and Lee?
im on an island, but - Abrederris.
Abbrederis reminds me of Julian Edelman. Abby isn't quite the athlete Edelman is, but he's not far behind. Not the exact body type, but close. Similar style/skill set.I think he definitely fills a role for a team from the get-go. He'll never be a WR1 (fantasy), but I think he could top out as a WR2, if everything falls into place.
i don't think their game could be much different, Abbrederis is an outside guy, if we are going to compare him to white receivers he is much closer to Jordy than Edelman.
Good points. I guess I subconsciously did the white WR copout. Abbrederis IS an outside guy, but do you agree that he could play out of the slot?

Instead of comps, here's what I think he does well: very good route runner, especially noticeable against press/man coverage; good receiving skills (hands catcher, high points ball well w/my ball mentality); tough, willing to go over the middle and take the big hit. Good with the ball in his hands, and can operate well in tight spaces (heh).

He also was Wisconsin's best receiving threat last year by a good margin, and still always seemed to be open. He would've put up 30% better numbers with any kind of help from his QB.

I think the Jordy comp is much better than what I came up with.

 
Why are we discussing Abbredaris in this thread. It is about Wr 3.

I like Abbredaris as well but, at WR 16 in this WR star studded draft...

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why are we discussing Abbredaris in this thread. It is about Wr 3.

I like Abbredaris as well but, at WR 16 in this WR star studded draft...
Well, I am because his name got brought up, and he's one guy I've actually seen a lot of. But then I made a bad/lazy comp, and had to re-say what I meant. Sorry bout that. I would add that I think WR16 is too low, but it's you're list. Back to lurking.

 
I personally like Lee as the #2 wr in this class. After that I like Jordan Mathews. There is something about Evans that scares me.

He just doesn't look really fluid out there.
Matthews had a great combine. He's an elite prospect.

6'3

212 lbs

4.46 40

21 reps on the bench

Great route runner

Huge hands

Great college career.

What's the problem?
Great Great Post.

Mark these words - Jordan Matthews is the best WR in this draft. In 2012 the discussion was about Blackmon, Floyd, Kendall Wright. Jeffery was on nobody's radar.

Matthews will be Alshon Jeffery 2.0

Unfortunately the group think of the NFL will allow Matthews to fall and Watkins and Evans will go way before we hear Matthews name. However an NFL smart team like GB, NE, NO, or DEN will grab him late in the first round and what a steal it will be.

 
I personally like Lee as the #2 wr in this class. After that I like Jordan Mathews. There is something about Evans that scares me.

He just doesn't look really fluid out there.
Matthews had a great combine. He's an elite prospect.6'3

212 lbs

4.46 40

21 reps on the bench

Great route runner

Huge hands

Great college career.

What's the problem?
Great Great Post.Mark these words - Jordan Matthews is the best WR in this draft. In 2012 the discussion was about Blackmon, Floyd, Kendall Wright. Jeffery was on nobody's radar.

Matthews will be Alshon Jeffery 2.0

Unfortunately the group think of the NFL will allow Matthews to fall and Watkins and Evans will go way before we hear Matthews name. However an NFL smart team like GB, NE, NO, or DEN will grab him late in the first round and what a steal it will be.
I cannot get behind this. Alshon he is not... If he can clean up the drops every game and the body catches maybe he's a poor man's.ETA: I said all along that Alshon would be the best WR in the '12 class, I'm too tired to look up the thread, but the sophmore Jeffrey was a better WR then than Matthews is now.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I personally like Lee as the #2 wr in this class. After that I like Jordan Mathews. There is something about Evans that scares me.

He just doesn't look really fluid out there.
X 2. I have never seen a player college WR push off more than Mike Evans and get away with it. I will let someone else draft him.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I personally like Lee as the #2 wr in this class. After that I like Jordan Mathews. There is something about Evans that scares me.

He just doesn't look really fluid out there.
Matthews had a great combine. He's an elite prospect.

6'3

212 lbs

4.46 40

21 reps on the bench

Great route runner

Huge hands

Great college career.

What's the problem?
Great Great Post.

Mark these words - Jordan Matthews is the best WR in this draft. In 2012 the discussion was about Blackmon, Floyd, Kendall Wright. Jeffery was on nobody's radar.

Matthews will be Alshon Jeffery 2.0

Unfortunately the group think of the NFL will allow Matthews to fall and Watkins and Evans will go way before we hear Matthews name. However an NFL smart team like GB, NE, NO, or DEN will grab him late in the first round and what a steal it will be.
I just watched all the tape I can on him. The only knock I see is he's a little light in the shorts. I mean he lines up everywhere for Vandy. Everybody knows he's getting the ball. He has a garbage QB throwing to him. He plays in the SEC. He still dominates.

I think he might be the best WR in this draft class to.

 
I personally like Lee as the #2 wr in this class. After that I like Jordan Mathews. There is something about Evans that scares me.

He just doesn't look really fluid out there.
Matthews had a great combine. He's an elite prospect.

6'3

212 lbs

4.46 40

21 reps on the bench

Great route runner

Huge hands

Great college career.

What's the problem?
Great Great Post.

Mark these words - Jordan Matthews is the best WR in this draft. In 2012 the discussion was about Blackmon, Floyd, Kendall Wright. Jeffery was on nobody's radar.

Matthews will be Alshon Jeffery 2.0

Unfortunately the group think of the NFL will allow Matthews to fall and Watkins and Evans will go way before we hear Matthews name. However an NFL smart team like GB, NE, NO, or DEN will grab him late in the first round and what a steal it will be.
I just watched all the tape I can on him. The only knock I see is he's a little light in the shorts. I mean he lines up everywhere for Vandy. Everybody knows he's getting the ball. He has a garbage QB throwing to him. He plays in the SEC. He still dominates.

I think he might be the best WR in this draft class to.
He is

 
I'm clearly in the minority, but I don't like Lee at all. I think he has a very limited ceiling, and brings nothing special to the table. I see Stevie Johnson when I watch him. Then again, one could argue that if Stevie played his career with Peyton Manning at QB, instead of the average to bad QB play he has had in Buffalo, maybe he'd be regarded more highly.

I like Beckham the 3rd most, and I also prefer Cooks, Benjamin and possibly Landry(despite an awful combine) to Lee.
Stevie had actual WR skills.

 
Just for the record, what I'm seeing is Watkins seems to be the highest graded WR, I thought Evans and Lee were close for #2 and #3, with Evans perhaps creating some separation between them at the Combine.

Consensus could mean taken from various mocks drafts, it could mean here on the board, etc. Put it this way. If we could know how all 32 teams graded the respective WRs, and found out 32 teams had Watkins the #1 WR in the class, he would be the consensus top WR. If it was divided among Watkins, Evans and Lee with a 11-11-10 distribution, there would be no consensus, it would be divided.

I could be wrong, but even if there may be individuals that like Evans better than Watkins here on the board, I don't think that is representative of the broader scouting community.

Someone might think Manziel falls out of the first round. Or that Tre Mason is the tenth best RB in the class. Or that Beckham or Cooks is the #1 WR in the class. All those could even be right over various time frames, eventually. But from where we stand now, my sense is those are not the consensus views of scouts but would be contrarian and outlier positions.

* Matthews should have been included in the poll, there are a significant number of *OTHER* votes (more than for Cooks and nearly as many as for Beckham last I checked). As to an example of consensus in the SP, look to Faust's 2014 1.01 Poll. In the standard and PPR scoring versions, Watkins was like 60% and 80%, and next closest Evans at about 8% and 6%, respectively (RBs were mixed into the poll). That is what I would call a consensus. :)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Evens is not a consensus 2 right now. I like Lee more.
You're right, He's consensus #1. Lee is nowhere near my top 3.
You Keep Using That Word, I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means"
I'm not sure jurb26 knows what that word means either.

Mike Evans is a consensus top 2 moreso than Lee is a consensus top 3.
What does one have to do with the other? I never said Lee was a consensus top 3. I simply said I like him more. Saying Evens is moreso a top 2 has nothing to do with anything. The only consensus in this group is that Watkins is the top guy. After that it's all debatable.

 
isn't the question who is #4 after Watkins, Evans and Lee?
im on an island, but - Abrederris.
Abbrederis reminds me of Julian Edelman. Abby isn't quite the athlete Edelman is, but he's not far behind. Not the exact body type, but close. Similar style/skill set.I think he definitely fills a role for a team from the get-go. He'll never be a WR1 (fantasy), but I think he could top out as a WR2, if everything falls into place.
i don't think their game could be much different, Abbrederis is an outside guy, if we are going to compare him to white receivers he is much closer to Jordy than Edelman.
Good points. I guess I subconsciously did the white WR copout. Abbrederis IS an outside guy, but do you agree that he could play out of the slot?Instead of comps, here's what I think he does well: very good route runner, especially noticeable against press/man coverage; good receiving skills (hands catcher, high points ball well w/my ball mentality); tough, willing to go over the middle and take the big hit. Good with the ball in his hands, and can operate well in tight spaces (heh).

He also was Wisconsin's best receiving threat last year by a good margin, and still always seemed to be open. He would've put up 30% better numbers with any kind of help from his QB.

I think the Jordy comp is much better than what I came up with.
both fast and quick too, only aspect about his game I question is his strength. Guys like him often go over looked throughout this process in favor of under developed potential with special raw tools. I prefer guys like him, Robinson, Matthews, and Adams to guys like Beckham and Benjamin. Not sure about Cooks vs them though. Little guys that play tall get my attention.

 
I think the team Evans/Lee/Beckham/Cooks land on will dictate where you rank. I think they are close enough in their talents that QB will dictate (at least in the short-term), where they'll be ranked going into dynasty (and certainly redraft). I don't think that is true with Watkins...

 
jurb26 said:
Xue said:
Donnybrook said:
Xue said:
jurb26 said:
Evens is not a consensus 2 right now. I like Lee more.
You're right, He's consensus #1. Lee is nowhere near my top 3.
You Keep Using That Word, I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means"
I'm not sure jurb26 knows what that word means either.

Mike Evans is a consensus top 2 moreso than Lee is a consensus top 3.
What does one have to do with the other? I never said Lee was a consensus top 3. I simply said I like him more. Saying Evens is moreso a top 2 has nothing to do with anything. The only consensus in this group is that Watkins is the top guy. After that it's all debatable.
Don't know about the broader scouting community, but at least in the SP, Faust's new Rookie 1.2 Poll reflects what I expected. Evans is winning over Lee in a Nixon/McGovern '72 election-like landslide.

 
Xue said:
Donnybrook said:
Xue said:
jurb26 said:
Evens is not a consensus 2 right now. I like Lee more.
You're right, He's consensus #1. Lee is nowhere near my top 3.
You Keep Using That Word, I Do Not Think It Means What You Think It Means"
I'm not sure jurb26 knows what that word means either.

Mike Evans is a consensus top 2 moreso than Lee is a consensus top 3.
Sorry man you lose here, you really make no sense.

 
My fear with Beckham is that he'll end up becoming another Josh Boyce/Andre Roberts. Two very athletic, very smooth guys who have yet to translate that into great receiving production in the NFL. I like Beckham more than I liked either of those guys, so I'm not trying to dog him with those comparisons. Just pointing out that being really athletic at ~5'10-5'11" isn't necessarily a recipe for dominating at WR in the NFL. There seems to be a lot of value in a big body. Look at Brandon Marshall, Demaryius Thomas, and Larry Fitzgerald. They're plenty quick, fast, and explosive, but if you put them in a combine setting I would not expect them to fare much better than the likes of Boyce/Roberts/Beckham in the drills. It's the combination of their overall athleticism AND their plus size frames that makes them so dominant. There are a few short guys in the league who have had big receiving seasons (Steve Smith, Antonio Brown, Victor Cruz). They're outnumbered among the league's elite by the big targets like Fitz, VJax, Calvin, Demaryius, Dez, Marshall, Gordon, and Jeffery.

I've faced a similar dilemma in the past in rookie drafts and dev drafts. Specifically with Kendall Wright vs. Michael Floyd in 2012 and Odell Beckham vs. Donte Moncrief in 2013. Do you take the small guy with flawless movement skills or do you take the bigger guy who isn't quite as smooth? I chose Wright in 2012 and Moncrief in 2013. Jury's still out on those picks. I know that when I'm on the clock and it's down to guys like Evans/Moncrief vs. guys like Beckham/Lee/Cooks, the lower ceiling is going to weigh on my mind. Not an easy call to make, IMO. The dream scenario is the Dez/Demaryius who has the huge body AND the flawless movement, but that guy isn't in this draft IMO.
Good post, thanks for the input.

I like Wright, but took Floyd that year and it was an easy decision for me. I'd make it again today.

I wonder if Beckham was underused in college, and if featured more like Harvin and Cobb (not comparing his skill set and game with Harvin directly, though Cobb seems like a closer comp - lets say if he was used in a simlar role, if not as high frequency a receiver), could he be the proverbial player that is a "better NFL than college" WR?

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top