Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Who Wins This Trade? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter chet
- Start date
Captain Hook
Footballguy
Before I give you my opinion, remember that you don't HAVE to win a trade - the bottom line is does it make your team better (even if you may have given away the best single player or slightly more talent....esp in roto scoring with category differential)
In this particular case the team getting Howard plus two players certainly has the advantage in this trade because
Howard > Berkman
and while Carpenter > Pelfrey, there is the risk he misses more time
and Blake added in
There is a scenario where the team trading Howard feels it is the right gamble for his team (he has HR covered, needs BA from Berkman, has a player =/+ to Blake on the bench AND needs what Carpenter might deliver if he pitches every week for the balance of the season)
In this particular case the team getting Howard plus two players certainly has the advantage in this trade because
Howard > Berkman
and while Carpenter > Pelfrey, there is the risk he misses more time
and Blake added in
There is a scenario where the team trading Howard feels it is the right gamble for his team (he has HR covered, needs BA from Berkman, has a player =/+ to Blake on the bench AND needs what Carpenter might deliver if he pitches every week for the balance of the season)
Mr. Littlejeans
Footballguy
I would probably rather have Carpenter and Berkman.
KenM746003
Footballguy
I'd take Howard, Pelfrey and Blake.
Unless you are penalized for strikeouts...
Blake shouldn't be overlooked - he's good for .280, 25, 85. Carpenter is a question mark, too.
Unless you are penalized for strikeouts...
Blake shouldn't be overlooked - he's good for .280, 25, 85. Carpenter is a question mark, too.