Who Wins This Trade?? (1 Viewer)

[Spectrum]

10-team NON-PPR

My thoughts:
Ingram - would be great to have both Ingram and Kamara - schedule is just ok.
Ajayi - great schedule week 14-16, obviously could be top 7-10 RB in Philly if gets majority carries.
D. Henry - best sked in league week 15-16. But will he get more play than D. Murray? Would I start him since I'd have Hunt, Ingram, Kamara and Jones?
Hilton - classic sell high - his monster games were all matchup based. Maybe worst sked in league rest of way.
Hill - up and down like Hilton, but maybe compete with Kelce, Hunt and whoever for touches.

My roster:
(start 2 WRs, 2 RBs, 2 Flex)
QB - T. Taylor
WR - A. Brown, Hilton, D. Parker, Thielen
RB - Hunt, Ajayi, Kamara, Aaron Jones, Coleman, Darkwa
TE - J. Graham
IR - A. Rodgers

His roster:
QB - R. Wilson, C. Wentz
WR - A. Jeffery, T. Hill, J. Nelson, R. Woods
RB - Ingram, C. Thompson, D. Henry, D. Johnson Jr., Breida
TE - Kelce, H. Henry

Having depth is nice but does this improve my starters rest of season? We also get prize $ if win regular season. I'm 2 games behind 1st place (4th) but behind lots in points so not likely will win reg. season.

 

[Gally]

I would much rather have Ingram, Henry and Hill over Ajayi and Hilton.  I think you will get more consistent points out of those three and if Murray goes down you have a monster rest of season in Henry.  Hill may not have as huge of games as Hilton but I think he has a higher floor. 

 

[snoochieboochies]

Dont aim for regular season champ. In my league, its a curse. The regular season champ has never won the championship in my league....never! 

If i have to vote I would say make the trade. Hill is an upgrade on hilton, and ingram/henry have a higher floor than ajayi (for the time being).

That being said, i am curious if he would trade you kelce or wentz.

Aajyi + hilton + aaron jones for Wentz + Hill... Kelce + ingram

My thinking is that if you are playoff bound and you are going to be competitive,  I would aim for a higher floor across the board in order to get you that much farther in the playoffs. 

 

[Spectrum]

Dont aim for regular season champ. In my league, its a curse. The regular season champ has never won the championship in my league....never! 

If i have to vote I would say make the trade. Hill is an upgrade on hilton, and ingram/henry have a higher floor than ajayi (for the time being).

That being said, i am curious if he would trade you kelce or wentz.

Aajyi + hilton + aaron jones for Wentz + Hill... Kelce + ingram

My thinking is that if you are playoff bound and you are going to be competitive,  I would aim for a higher floor across the board in order to get you that much farther in the playoffs. 

True.

Hm, I doubt he would trade Kelce unless I throw in Graham, which I'd obviously do. Do you mean Ajayi, Hilton and A. Jones for EITHER Wentz and Hill OR Wentz and Ingram?

 

[Spectrum]

Anyone else? Tyrod Taylor by the way plays Indy and NE pass def week 14 and 16.

Should I try and trade for Wentz, like my Ajayi, Hilton and Jones for his Wentz, Ingram and Henry? Or should I accept the above trade ASAP?

 

[allgar]

If you can get all of that for Ajayi and Hilton, you should go for it! I have to be honest, it looks a little one sided, unless the guy you are trading with thinks Ajayi is going to be RB1 rest of way and that Hilton is a must start every week.

Do you have any reason to believe he'll make this trade?

If you can, I would upgrade your QB position. I like you floating out Ajayi, Hilton and Thielen in return for Wentz, Ingram and Tyreek. You don't need Derrick Henry, you are loaded at RB and even if you get to play four, you'd be playing Hunt, Ingram, Kamara and either Darkwa, Coleman, Tyreek or Parker. Wentz is a big upgrade.

Ajayi to Ingram - I take Ingram

Hilton for Tyreek - I take Tyreek

Thielen for Wentz - I take Wentz (with your depth)

I just don't see this guy valuing Ajayi and Hilton this much, but I do wish you great luck in the deal.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

I would ask about Wentz, but I like the deal on table for you now getting Ingram, Henry, and Hill

See mine regarding Henry dynasty deal .. thanks https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/762553-dynasty-brees-and-either-engram-or-kelce-for-luck-and-henry/

 

[snoochieboochies]

True.

Hm, I doubt he would trade Kelce unless I throw in Graham, which I'd obviously do. Do you mean Ajayi, Hilton and A. Jones for EITHER Wentz and Hill OR Wentz and Ingram?




 

Sorry bout that. I was just listing multiple options. Not one big trade. I like Tyrod, have him rostered in multiple leagues. Wentz is playing really really well right now and his extra points could be valuable if they can be had affordably. Main idea was to increase the overall floor and ceiling across the qb/rb/wr/te if possible.