I think I will always have a soft spot for Tyler Thigpen leading me to the title game with his awesome collegiate offense in Kansas City...it was only my 2nd year of playing Fantasy, I was an underclassmen in a league with my father's work buddies, and it was awesome to see "Welcome to the Thigpen" as my smack talk every week...right above his 30 point efforts as I waited until the second to last round for a QB and played waivers all year until Tyler came along after injuries.
That being said, in all the dynasty teams that I drafted, I have Roddy White. And I have since the draft in each one. And every TD he scores, every catch he makes, every time people doubted him when a rookie QB was brought in, just makes me like him that much more. He;s the first player I think I can truly say I was "right" on as I don't make many predictions.
Santonio could get there. I really like his talent. Not so much his pot-smoking.
A small corner of me is reserved for Jerome Harrison. My proudest call to date, and probably the best one I will ever make, was saying he would lead you to the title if you started him in weeks 14-16 of last year. And then he did exactly that, for me at least.