Willis McGahee or Jones Drew? (1 Viewer)

[Louisville Slugger]

It's looking like both of these guys will be on the board when I pick.

Who would you go with?

 

[trader jake]

Redraft: McGahee doesn't have any competition for his carries and is hungry in a new situation.

Dynasty: Go with MJD

 

[amphibianbri]

McGahee will put up more yards and as the undisputed #1, will probably end up with 9-11 TD's. The only way MJD outscores him is if a) Taylor gets hurt, because at $5 million, Taylor will still get his carries or b) somehow he ends up breaking a lot of longer TD's. I also mentioned in another Jags post that I think Leftwich is better this year (especially in a walk year), and they may throw inside the 10 to those huge WR and TE options. I go McGahee.

 

[faux_bear]

Good question. Unfortunately, keeper league requires that I may have to take one of them at 1.10 this year. Would you still go McGahee in a PPR league?