Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
Worst kickers in the league (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Tom Baker
- Start date
A
awesomeness
Guest
Scott
pizzatyme
Footballguy
As a Colts fan, I completely agree with your list. Plus, Vinatieri is one of the highest paid kickers in the league. I'd gladly dump him and use his salary on another DT.
Jayrod
Footballguy
The Saints drafted a rookie kicker from Wisconsin named Taylor Melhaff.
I thought the kid would be great for the high powered Saints, but he narrowly lost the pre-season competition to Grammatica. Martin had a good pre-season as well, but he looked bad tonight.
Of course I know all this because I drafted Melhaff in my dynasty rookie draft and had to drop him. Nothing like following a pre-season kicker battle.
I thought the kid would be great for the high powered Saints, but he narrowly lost the pre-season competition to Grammatica. Martin had a good pre-season as well, but he looked bad tonight.
Of course I know all this because I drafted Melhaff in my dynasty rookie draft and had to drop him. Nothing like following a pre-season kicker battle.
pizzatyme
Footballguy
I say pick him up now! He will be on their squad sooner than later. Unless Carney gets the axe this week from the G-men.The Saints drafted a rookie kicker from Wisconsin named Taylor Melhaff.I thought the kid would be great for the high powered Saints, but he narrowly lost the pre-season competition to Grammatica. Martin had a good pre-season as well, but he looked bad tonight.Of course I know all this because I drafted Melhaff in my dynasty rookie draft and had to drop him. Nothing like following a pre-season kicker battle.
SproutDaddy
Footballguy
I never understood why the Saints dropped Carney for Gramatica. I know he's old and has lost some kicking power, but Gramatica has never been clutch. As a Saint's fan I now hate him more than Shockey!I say pick him up now! He will be on their squad sooner than later. Unless Carney gets the axe this week from the G-men.The Saints drafted a rookie kicker from Wisconsin named Taylor Melhaff.I thought the kid would be great for the high powered Saints, but he narrowly lost the pre-season competition to Grammatica. Martin had a good pre-season as well, but he looked bad tonight.Of course I know all this because I drafted Melhaff in my dynasty rookie draft and had to drop him. Nothing like following a pre-season kicker battle.
Carver Lee
Footballguy
Mild understatement. I thought I was about to witness a player faint on the field. Total chode.I never understood why the Saints dropped Carney for Gramatica. I know he's old and has lost some kicking power, but Gramatica has never been clutch. As a Saint's fan I now hate him more than Shockey!I say pick him up now! He will be on their squad sooner than later. Unless Carney gets the axe this week from the G-men.The Saints drafted a rookie kicker from Wisconsin named Taylor Melhaff.
I thought the kid would be great for the high powered Saints, but he narrowly lost the pre-season competition to Grammatica. Martin had a good pre-season as well, but he looked bad tonight.
Of course I know all this because I drafted Melhaff in my dynasty rookie draft and had to drop him. Nothing like following a pre-season kicker battle.
Pittsburgh United
Footballguy
I don't follow Kickers, but can someone confirm if Carney is in danger of getting cut? I was planning on picking him up this week.I say pick him up now! He will be on their squad sooner than later. Unless Carney gets the axe this week from the G-men.The Saints drafted a rookie kicker from Wisconsin named Taylor Melhaff.I thought the kid would be great for the high powered Saints, but he narrowly lost the pre-season competition to Grammatica. Martin had a good pre-season as well, but he looked bad tonight.Of course I know all this because I drafted Melhaff in my dynasty rookie draft and had to drop him. Nothing like following a pre-season kicker battle.
Wu-banger
Footballguy
renesauz
IBL Representative
Yep, but nearly perfect inside of 40 and still has a strong leg. Akers is a tough one to figure out. A lot of those long distance misses are heart-breakers bouncing off uprights, not big shanks.Definately in the conversation as "worst" ATM, but might well bounce out of it. Gramatica is a differant story. Guy jumps around celebrating after a long FG like he just won the super bowl, then hides and cries like a baby when he misses another fairly long one. I'm shocked that any coach would want him on their roster. He's WAAAAAAAAYYY too emotional for an NFL kicker.
Finkel, Einhorn, Finkel, Einhorn, Finkel, Einhorn...Finkel,Finkel,Finkel,Finkel!!!
Dr. Octopus
Footballguy
Lawrence Tynes is now healthy and ready to resume his role, but Coughlin seems reluctant to drop Carney (since he's been perfect on the season thus far). They did extend Tynes's contract and paid him rather nicely for a kicker so it is bound to happen.I don't follow Kickers, but can someone confirm if Carney is in danger of getting cut? I was planning on picking him up this week.I say pick him up now! He will be on their squad sooner than later. Unless Carney gets the axe this week from the G-men.The Saints drafted a rookie kicker from Wisconsin named Taylor Melhaff.I thought the kid would be great for the high powered Saints, but he narrowly lost the pre-season competition to Grammatica. Martin had a good pre-season as well, but he looked bad tonight.Of course I know all this because I drafted Melhaff in my dynasty rookie draft and had to drop him. Nothing like following a pre-season kicker battle.
Spartans346
Footballguy
I know all there is to know about the crying game.
It's kind of amazing when you think about it that kicking is so difficult that you can barely find 20 or so men that are really good at it... It's a job that you can make several hundred thousand a year to a million and of all the high school, college, soccer players, only about 1 or two a year are NFL above avg quality... It doesn't look like it would be, but it must really be an art form!
brednbuddah
Footballguy
Nugent has never been good (lived up to expectations) and is now hurt (quad) 
brady2moss
Footballguy
AV
Similar threads
