Would you trade McCoy for Brady if you had my team? (1 Viewer)

[joeyemma]

I need your help on this trade please...10 team redraft...no ppr...start 1qb 2rb 2wr 1flex 1teroster: Wilson/Rivers/BradfordMcCoy/Gurley/JHoward/JMcKinnon/HydeAntonio/Jordon Matthews/Hurns/Parker/MThomas/MFloydRudolph/Ertz/MBennett/FleenerThe Brady owner is desperate for a RB but also a real jerk. He wants McCoy for Brady. I know that is a lot, but I am deep at RB and I think Brady is going to blow the world up when he comes back. He won't do any of my other backs.He won't do a lesser back and a WR. The ONLY thing he will do is McCoy for Brady....I think it is overpaying but I also think my team would be better. I am currently in first place....and I want to stay there. Do I ship McCoy for Brady?Thanks.

 

[TheKillerBrees]

Value of guys it looks like a good deal, but you would actually become weak at RB in my opinion after that deal while having way to many QB's (you also have to many TE's, if there's anything on the wire at RB or WR drop a couple)

I would often say yes to any trade that gets you Brady in a re-draft, but I don't think I would do this one if I was you. Unless you can can get serviceable guys on the wore, pick up 2 more RB's with upside by cutting 2 TE's and then yea, I would do it (And then maybe even cut Bradford too) SO I guess it depends on your wire a bit....

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749016-can-i-start-dwayne-wash-over-t-coleman/

 

[RRaptors]

I would do it if I could find a WW RB worth it.

I have heard buzz about Kenneth Dixon (BAL RB) potential in the future (later part of the season after he returns from being out). I guess that doesn't help you now.

I agree with theKillerBrees, check the wire and if there is someone you can drop a TE for and get a decent replacement this could pan out for you.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749017-wdis-d-thomas-or-t-pryor/

 

[UofMAce]

I wouldn't do it.  You're giving up way too much for Brady.  Does he have another player to throw into the trade-  maybe a lesser running back.

 

[booda]

No, there is no need for you to do this.  You have Rivers to back up Wilson.  You are fine.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749036-pick-2-rbs-out-of-4/

 

[winkdogs]

Would not do this.  You need McCoy.  Your qb situation is great, Hyde is going to have clunkers and the others haven't done anything YET. 

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749032-week-5-dilemna-help/

 

[themeistersinger]

I would not do it.  Once you lose McCoy I would call your team weak at RB.  And the combination of Wilson (who should get healthy after the week 5 bye) and Rivers should be more than fine at QB.

I'd be looking to package a TE plus an RB to get a better RB, or package a TE to get a better WR.  TE is where you have crazy depth - two TE on your roster should be more than plenty

Unless your league greatly over weights QB for points, RB are the coin of the realm.  Trading McCoy for Brady would only make sense if Brady is in for a record breaking run in the next 12 games - merely being the best QB in the league would not be enough to justify the trade.

Here's mine

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749038-need-lineup-help-ppr-league/