Judge Smails
Footballguy
My eyes didn’t lie. When healthy this guy is special. Don’t know what to do now though
Gonna hold as I can’t find 10-189 on the wire. Hell even 6-70 is ####### impossible to findMy eyes didn’t lie. When healthy this guy is special. Don’t know what to do now though
Very true. But that 1-9 in your lineup down the stretch in a playoff hunt or in the playoffs will kill your team. It's not about the talent here. It's about the opportunity. If he couldn't put up halfway decent numbers when the Giants were low on healthy WRs it's hard to trust him in your lineup. He's a bench stash for now until he starts showing some consistency.Gonna hold as I can’t find 10-189 on the wire. Hell even 6-70 is ####### impossible to find
The way he was used indicates that he too is not a healthy WR. Hopefully that will change after the bye week, but there is no way of knowing with this coaching staff.If he couldn't put up halfway decent numbers when the Giants were low on healthy WRs it's hard to trust him in your lineup.
Our scoring just has him down for a 2 yard rushing loss. If he was sacked I don't think they'd have counted that as negative rushing yards. In college they do, but not the NFL. I didn't see the play either, however.Question about Toney related to FF scoring. Yahoo has him being “sacked” once this past game. Apparently he lined up in wildcat and got tackled for a 2 yard loss. I didn’t see the play.
Should that be a sack? Was he going to pass the ball?
That is where I landed so I dropped him for Van Jefferson after the Robert Woods news.Very true. But that 1-9 in your lineup down the stretch in a playoff hunt or in the playoffs will kill your team. It's not about the talent here. It's about the opportunity. If he couldn't put up halfway decent numbers when the Giants were low on healthy WRs it's hard to trust him in your lineup. He's a bench stash for now until he starts showing some consistency.
Agree. Last game, he had hardly any downfield routes. All short out routes. IDK if he was playing decoy with the ankle still mending or what, but he just has no vertical presence yet.I'm not falling for this again until he does something...
fwiw, that was my take as well.I'm rolling him out in two leagues. I think he wasn't fully healthy so they didn't scheme him into the game plan as much. Coming off the bye and fully healthy we should expect a much larger role.
Up 34 with his Brady and Godwin stack vs my Toney tonight. Find my self thinking of the range of outcomes for Toney and I can’t help but think it’s going to be a total dud due to non-usage, or a big game where he is featured. Doesn’t seem like there is any in-between with this guy. Anyone else feel the same?
All I want is 4 for 50 tonight and to get through a game in good health. I also want to see him in the slot and obliterate TB's slot DBs because TB DB's are in pretty big trouble. I'm just concerned that TB scheme is a lot for Daniel Jones, but IDK, Giants almost beat the Bucs last year. The Giants play hard and think they will be pesky tonight vs. Brady. Should be a closer game than most think IMOUp 34 with his Brady and Godwin stack vs my Toney tonight. Find my self thinking of the range of outcomes for Toney and I can’t help but think it’s going to be a total dud due to non-usage, or a big game where he is featured. Doesn’t seem like there is any in-between with this guy. Anyone else feel the same?
https://twitter.com/ihartitz/status/1460731398629777412?s=21Ian Hartitz @IHartitz
182 player sample: Kadarius Toney ranks 7th in yards per route run (2.44, PFF). Only guys with more: Deebo, C-Patt, Kupp, Adams, AB and Chase. That's it.
Toney's 34 targets this season are tied for 99th in the NFL.
Kadarius Toney caught 7-of-12 targets for 40 yards in the Giants' Week 11 loss to the Bucs.
That's a Rondale Moore-esque stat line for fellow rookie Toney, whose 12 targets easily paced the Giants on a night he saw 31.6% of the team's targets. Unfortunately, Toney didn't do much with them despite leading the team in catches and yards. Daniel Jones averaged a pitiful 4.4 yards per attempt, and his lone touchdown went to LT Andrew Thomas on a trick play. Toney was manning the slot for the G-Men with Sterling Shepard still out. His 12 looks were his second-most of the season and just the third time all year Toney has seen more than five targets. Toney is electric with the ball in his hands, but there was no room to be had in this one. Toney will be an upside WR3 next week against the Eagles, though things could get hairier if Shepard is back in the lineup.
Nov 22, 2021, 11:27 PM ET
Interesting use of speedy rookie WRs by multiple teams. Waddle had a 12 catch game for 58 yards (4.8 yp) and R Moore just had an 11 catch game for 51 yards (4.6 ypc).Need more than a 4 yard route tree
From PFFWat?
I'm hoping that just means really really bad bruise. I didn't watch but heard this was later in game when it was out of hand. But yeah the minor injuries are starting to exhibit a trend.From PFF
Monitor Kadarius Toney‘s health: The Giants' first-round rookie suffered a quad contusion late in the game and didn’t return. He was the Giants' favorite target in the game, which led to seven receptions for 40 yards. New York also missed Sterling Shepard in the game. As long as one of the wide receivers remains hurt, it ensures Darius Slayton has a big role in the offense. Pharoh Cooper primarily took over for Toney to end this game. All of these backups should be avoided in the vast majority of leagues.
Yeah, with the 12 targets and occasional pass, clear he is integral to their offensive schemes. He's gotta be one of the better pickups if available. I had him and dropped, but may go back.I'm hoping that just means really really bad bruise. I didn't watch but heard this was later in game when it was out of hand. But yeah the minor injuries are starting to exhibit a trend.
Can't say I am impressed with the Giants QB play. he tries to force it into coverage when someone else is open. I dunno. No scout or pro football player here and just observations of the first half.
If you need 4 yards, he'll get you 4 yards...Need more than a 4 yard route tree
I'm hoping that just means really really bad bruise. I didn't watch but heard this was later in game when it was out of hand. But yeah the minor injuries are starting to exhibit a trend.
that's putting it mildly....Jones is horrendous and is probably the biggest impediment to Toney stardom. Jones missed open guys all night, threw an awful interception across the grain. The good thing is it seems they realize that Toney is special and are trying to get him the ball. The guy needs to stay healthy though...it seems he's banged up after each game.Can't say I am impressed with the Giants QB play. he tries to force it into coverage when someone else is open. I dunno. No scout or pro football player here and just observations of the first half.
“Star” is being extremely generous.Yes seems to me that Shepherd is still the star here
Star wr in a mediocre offense is still the star. When he plays he gets all the targets and Toney isn't going to take that away from him“Star” is being extremely generous.
The biggest impediment to Toney is that Jones is rarely looking deep downfield. With whatever limited skills he's operating with, last night it seemed like he was looking to get the ball to his first read as quickly as possible. Griese noted the potential missed TD pass to Toney in the first quarter.
I have no data on this, but anecdotally it looked like Toney was running more slants and downfield routes than he was before the bye, which may have been an injury protection decision, so that was good to see.
As for injuries, I think people are operating with a small sample size here. Sometimes injuries happen in football, and sometimes they are going to come in bunches. Toney's in-season injuries aren't really connected:
- Ankle sprain/pull
- Ankle injury exacerbated the next week, which is probably the result of a poor decision by the Giants' coaching staff/training staff
- Finger crushed by helmet
- Quad muscle bruise/contusion
Those to me sound like things that happen in a football game. Sometimes they are going to come in bunches for some players. Other players will have nothing happen to them for a full season.
Toney did have that hamstring pull/strain in training camp. The fact that has not been a recurring issue is actually probably a big positive so far.
He's canned!If Garrett is canned today then maybe there's improvement lol