YOUR Top 25 RBs for the REST of the season? (1 Viewer)

[DevilintheDetail]

This list is from here through week 16. Please post yours.

1. Tomlinson

2. Rudi Johnson

3. Larry Johnson

4. Westbrook

5. Alexander

6. Portis

7. Steven Jackson

8. Tatum Bell

9. Tiki Barber

10. Parker

11. Chester Taylor

12. McGahee

13. Dunn

14. Gore

15. Kevin Jones

16. Edge

17. Fred Taylor

18. Ronnie Brown

19. Bush

20. Maroney

21. Green

22. Thomas Jones

23. Jamal Lewis

24. Foster

25. Cadillac

 

[hollaatyaboy]

I've gotta bump LJ & Rudi down a couple spots. LJ due to QB and line issues. Rudi because of one hell of a sched.

 

[Shermanator]

You would draft SA fifth overall knowing he is out the next four weeks?

 

[jchapman70]

This list is from here through week 16. Please post yours.1. Tomlinson 2. Rudi Johnson3. Larry Johnson4. Westbrook5. Alexander6. Portis7. Steven Jackson8. Tatum Bell9. Tiki Barber10. Parker11. Chester Taylor12. McGahee13. Dunn14. Gore15. Kevin Jones16. Edge17. Fred Taylor18. Ronnie Brown19. Bush20. Maroney21. Green22. Thomas Jones23. Jamal Lewis24. Foster25. Cadillac

You've been the Bush Koolaid. Maroney I love but is not the starter. Westbrook is way to high on that list...he WILL get hurt sometime soon..and you have to take that into consideration. I think with Minny's schedule Taylor will end up in the top 5 to top 7. Cory Dillion as long as healthy will be in the top 15.

 

[Keys Myaths]

Let me try this.

1. LaDainian Tomlinson

2. Larry Johnson

3. Clinton Portis

4. Brian Westbrook

5. Tiki Barber

6. Rudi Johnson

7. Steven Jackson

8. Chester Taylor

9. Frank Gore

10. Willie Parker

11. Shaun Alexander

12. Ronnie Brown

13. Julius Jones

14. Tatum Bell

15. Edgerrin James

16. Ahman Green

17. Kevin Jones

18. Fred Taylor

19. Reggie Bush

20. Willis McGahee

21. Jamal Lewis

22. Cadillac Williams

23. Thomas Jones

24. Lawrence Maroney

25. Deuce McAllister

Good enough?

 

[ImTheScientist]

This list is from here through week 16. Please post yours.

1. Tomlinson

2. Rudi Johnson

3. Larry Johnson

4. Westbrook

5. Alexander

6. Portis

7. Steven Jackson

8. Tatum Bell

9. Tiki Barber

10. Parker

11. Chester Taylor

12. McGahee

13. Dunn

14. Gore

15. Kevin Jones

16. Edge

17. Fred Taylor

18. Ronnie Brown

19. Bush

20. Maroney

21. Green

22. Thomas Jones

23. Jamal Lewis

24. Foster

25. Cadillac

You've been the Bush Koolaid. Maroney I love but is not the starter. Westbrook is way to high on that list...he WILL get hurt sometime soon..and you have to take that into consideration. I think with Minny's schedule Taylor will end up in the top 5 to top 7. Cory Dillion as long as healthy will be in the top 15.

Bush is currently 24th in most non-ppr leagues and ranked even higher in ppr leagues....to assume he will only move up 5 slots is not much to ask. He is a rookie and I think he will only improve with time. By seasons end he will be ranked 10-15

 

[Sweeper]

You would draft SA fifth overall knowing he is out the next four weeks?

At least.

 

[Restricted]

Let me try this.1. LaDainian Tomlinson2. Larry Johnson3. Clinton Portis4. Brian Westbrook5. Tiki Barber6. Rudi Johnson7. Steven Jackson8. Chester Taylor9. Frank Gore10. Willie Parker11. Shaun Alexander12. Ronnie Brown13. Julius Jones14. Tatum Bell15. Edgerrin James16. Ahman Green17. Kevin Jones18. Fred Taylor19. Reggie Bush20. Willis McGahee21. Jamal Lewis22. Cadillac Williams23. Thomas Jones24. Lawrence Maroney25. Deuce McAllisterGood enough?

I had to check your list 3 times. Where's Dunn?

 

[theberg11]

1. LT

2. Portis

3. Westbrook

4. LJ

5. Rudi

6. Tiki

7. Parker

8. Jackson

9. McGahee

10. Bell

12. Brown

13. Alexander

14. Dunn

15. Gore

16. Chester

17. Edge

18. KJ

19. Jamal

20. Cadillac

21. Julius

22. McCallister

23. Green

24. Taylor

25. Thomas Jones

 

[kal-el]

Ronnie Brown at 12-18? He's currently #8 in fantasy points scored by a RB and the Miami offense has been pathetic. He's got nowhere to go but up.

 

[avoiding injuries]

1. LT

2. Rudi

3. LJ

4. Portis

5. FWP

6. McGahee

7. SJax

8. Bell

9. Westbook

10. Tiki

11. Dunn

12. Chester

13. R Brown

14. Alexander

15. KJ

16. Edge

17. Maroney

18. Jamal

19. Cadillac

20. TJ

21. Green

22. Julius

23. Taylor

24. Deuce

25. Addai

The bottom five is a bit of a cluster ****, they are interchangable. I put Addai at 25 b/c I'd rather have him with upside then someone else at that position(25). I am assuming Alexander misses 4 weeks and it takes some time for him to get back in the swing of things when he finally returns. Not confident in Westbrook staying healthy for the rest of the year and I was never that high on Tiki which lowered them in my rankings.

 

[RudeDog]

Wow,

Lamont not even in the top 25......

Let's wait and see how he does against the Brownies this week before we pronounce him DOA.

 

[avoiding injuries]

Wow,Lamont not even in the top 25......Let's wait and see how he does against the Brownies this week before we pronounce him DOA.

Good call. He slipped my mind, for good reasons. I would have him in the 20-25 range with Freddy T and A Green.

 

[JAMMIN]

Gore has to be in the top 25.

 

[avoiding injuries]

Gore has to be in the top 25.

Well, I didn't forget about him but I also didn't add him. A case can be made for him especially since he was #9 in Keys list. I'm not up to date on his abdominal injury and goal line carries etc. If I knew the current info I would make the correct adjustments. It's tough composing the top 25. After 20, there seems to be a lot of equal talent and opportunity.

 

[rascal]

Don't forget about Droughns as well.

After this week we should know more about Lamont and Droughns.

 

[RamMan]

Ronnie Brown at 12-18? He's currently #8 in fantasy points scored by a RB and the Miami offense has been pathetic. He's got nowhere to go but up.

Coudn't agree more. He's got a decent schedule as well. RB ends up Top 10 at least.

 

[AngryGorilla]

no love for DeAngelo Williams? This thread mentioned Westy's injury history and Gore's, what about DeAngelo?

 

[avoiding injuries]

I'm more interested in seeing other people's top 25 as opposed to "what about _____". If you disagree, share your rankings.

 

[AngryGorilla]

I'm more interested in seeing other people's top 25 as opposed to "what about _____". If you disagree, share your rankings.

I'm more interested in a good discussion. If we have twenty or fifty or a 1000 different rankings.......umm, who cares? So, how about everyone post their rankings, so we can all feel good about who we think should be where.....This forum, thread, or whatever can't appease everyone. It's not about who's more interested in what.All in good fun my friend.1 LT2 LJ3 Portis 4 Rudi 5 Westy6 Tatum 7 FWP8 Tiki9 Chester T.10 SJax11 Ronnie Brown12 Willis Mc13 Dunn14 Gore15 Edge16 Caddy17 K. Jones18 Deuce (TD's)19 Fragile Fred20 Jamal Lewis21 Droughns22 T. Jones23 J. Jones24 DeAngelo Williams (I think it'll happen)25 Dillon or Maroney or Ahman if healthy, really stewing that last spot

 

[avoiding injuries]

I'm more interested in seeing other people's top 25 as opposed to "what about _____". If you disagree, share your rankings.

I'm more interested in a good discussion. If we have twenty or fifty or a 1000 different rankings.......umm, who cares? So, how about everyone post their rankings, so we can all feel good about who we think should be where.....This forum, thread, or whatever can't appease everyone. It's not about who's more interested in what.All in good fun my friend.

Understandable. I was just going off the title of the thread..."YOUR top 25 RBs for the rest of the season". If the are disagreements, who would you add/take out and why. I was in no way calling anyone out, sorry if it came across that way.

 

[coo2ie]

1 LT

2 LJ

3 Portis

4 Tiki

5 Brown

6 Rudi

7 Edge

8 SJax

9 Westy

10 Dunn

11 Parker

12 Alexander

13 McGahee

14 J Jones

15 Ahman

16 K Jones

17 C Taylor

18 Gore

19 Jamal

20 Caddy

21 Tatum

22 Jordan

23 D Foster

24 Drougns

25 Deuce

 

[Blue-Kun]

1. LT

2. Rudi

3. LJ

4. Westbook

5. Portis

6. Parker

7. SJax

8. Barber

9. McGahee

10. C. Taylor

11. T. Bell

12. Brown

13. Dunn

14. Gore

15. Edge

16. Duece

17. Alexander

18. Bush

19. Maroney

20. Betts

21. Green

22. Julius

23. F. Taylor

24. KJ

25. Cadillac

The bottom five are a real toss-up. I just see Detroit's O as awful and Caddy never fully recovering from his bleh start. Taylor probably won't stay healthy at his current pace anyway. Top 5 is pretty much the same, as there's only 6 real probable choices and 4 are academic. I'm pretty sure Dunn comes close or gets into the top 10 if he starts seeing the red zone at all... but I'm not going to attempt to predict that.

 

[GoinDeep]

Don't forget about Droughns as well.After this week we should know more about Lamont and Droughns.

Speaking of....a guy in my league has them as his #1 and #2 RBs. Talk about a rough start.Nnow back to your regularly scheduled thread...

 

[JayMan]

Results so far... 25 points for a 1st place vote... 24 for a 2nd... down to 1pt for a 25th place vote... 0 if not on the list...

LTomlinson	--	175LJohnson	----	163CPortis	-----	156RJohnson	----	155BWestbrook	--	144TBarber	-----	132SJackson	----	128WParker	-----	126TBell	-------	104WMcGahee	----	101RBrown	------	100CTaylor	-----	100SAlexander	---	85WDunn	--------	83EJames	-------	82FGore	--------	73KJones	-------	61JJones	-------	42AGreen	-------	40JLewis	-------	37CWilliams	----	36FTaylor	------	33DMcAllister	--	27LMaroney	-----	26RBush	--------	22TJones	-------	19RDroughns	-----	7LBetts	--------	6DFoster	-------	5LJordan	-------	4DWilliams	-----	2JAddai	--------	1

 

[Urlacher54]

1. LTomlinson

2. TBarber

3. RJohnson

4. TBell

5. LJohnson

6. CPortis

7. RBrown

8. FGore

9. WParker

10. SJackson

11. BWestbrook

12. CTaylor

13. SAlexander

14. KJones

15. JJones

16. EJames

17. WDunn

18. WMcGahee

19. JLewis

20. RDroughns

21. TJones

22. DMcAllister

23. LMaroney

24. RBush

25. CWilliams

Gore is being listed WAY too low on most lists. When was the last time a Norv Turner RB did not finish in the top 10?

I am a Mike Bell owner, and I think Tatum has a shot at finishing #1.

 

[Lemmiwinks]

I don't have time for a top 25 right now, but the Tatum hype is out of control. Top 5? Chance at #1? We don't even know if he's getting the GL carries. If he fumbles twice next week will Mike Bell be starting again? Can you trust Rat-Face?

I wish I had Tatum right now so I could move him for a Westbrook, FWP, Ronnie Brown, Chester Taylor, Tiki, SJax and many other RB's I know are safer in their starting jobs but who many people are listing below Tatum.

 

[On The Rocks]

I don't have time for a top 25 right now, but the Tatum hype is out of control.

i am a Tatum Bell owner and I say

 

[cr8f]

Tatum Bell 8? I don't buy that.

 

[On The Rocks]

don't ask me to justify any of this, but here is my list:

1 Ladainian Tomlinson

2 Larry Johnson

3 Tiki Barber

4 Clinton Portis

5 Steven Jackson

6 Brian Westbrook

7 Ronnie Brown

8 Rudi Johnson

9 Willia Parker

10 Sean Alexander

11 Willis McGahee

12 Warrick Dunn

13 Reggie Bush

14 Edgerin James

15 Frank Gore

16 Chester Taylor

17 Laurence Maroney

18 Jamal Lewis

19 Tatum Bell

20 Carnell Williams

21 Lamont Jordan

22 Thomas Jones

23 Dominic Rhodes

24 Julius Jones

25 Fred Taylor

 

[Lemmiwinks]

1. LT

2. Westbrook

3. LJ

4. Rudi

5. Portis

6. Chester Taylor

7. FWP

8. R. Brown

9. Tiki

10. Dunn

11. SJax

12. SA

13. Willis

14. Edge

15. T Bell

16. Maroney (w/ Dillon injury or benching)

17. Julius

18. Caddy

19. McAllister

20. Bush

21. K. Jones

22. F. Taylor

23. T. Jones

24. Jordan

25. J. Lewis

 

[PACKER 7]

RB1 Johnson,Larry

RB2 Tomlinson,Ladainian

RB3 Barber,Tiki

RB4 Portis,Clinton

RB5 Johnson,Rudi

RB6 James,Edgerrin

RB7 Westbrook,Brian

RB8 Brown,Ronnie

RB9 McGahee,Willis

RB10 Alexander,Shaun

RB11 Foster,De'shaun

RB12 Bell,Tatum

RB13 Taylor,Chester

RB14 Lewis,Jamal

RB15 Jordan,Lamont

RB16 Gore,Frank

RB17 McAllister,Deuce

RB18 Green,Ahman

RB19 Parker,Willie

RB20 Bush, Reggie

RB21 Dunn,Warrick

RB22 Jackson,Steven

RB23 Taylor,Fred

RB24 Williams,Carnell

RB25 Jones,Thomas

 

[Resident A]

1. LT

2. Rudi

3. LJ

4. Edge

5. Portis

6. FWP

7. Westbrook

8. SJax

9. Willis

10. Tiki

11. Chester

12. T Bell

13. Dunn

14. SA

15. K. Jones

16. Cadillac

17. Gore

18. R. Brown

19. Jordan

20. A Green

21. J. Lewis

22. McAllister

23. F. Taylor

24. Maroney

25. T Jones or Benson

 

[section 8]

Lets wait till Monday and evaluate it then. Guaranteed all will change

 

[Reservoir Dog]

1. LT

2. Clinton Portis

3. LJ

4. Westbrook

5. Rudi Johnson

6. FWP

7. FRANK GORE

8. Edge

9. McGahee

10. Tiki Barber

11. Ronnie Brown

12. S. Jackson

13. W. Dunn

14. Chester Taylor

15. Tatum Bell

16. S. Alexander

17. L. Jordan

18. Cadillac

19. A. Green

20. K. Jones

21. J. Lewis

22. McAllister

23. F. Taylor

24. L. Maroney

25. T. Jones/R. Bush/C. Dillon

 

[JayMan]

Updated overall rankings... 13 lists accounted for...

LTomlinson    --  324LJohnson    ----  302CPortis    -----  286RJohnson    ----  284BWestbrook    --  263TBarber    -----  251WParker    -----  226SJackson    ----  216RBrown    ------  197WMcGahee    ----  188CTaylor    -----  184TBell    -------  183EJames    ------  176SAlexander    --  166WDunn    -------  153FGore    -------  140KJones    -------  95JLewis    -------  75CWilliams    ----  71JJones    -------  64AGreen    -------  61DMcAllister    --  55LMaroney    -----  52RBush    --------  49FTaylor    ------  47LJordan    ------  38TJones    -------  34DFoster    ------  20RDroughns    ----  13LBetts	--------  6DRhodes	-------  3DWilliams    -----  2JAddai    --------  1

 

[RBM]

1 L Johnson

2 L Tomlinson

3 C Portis

4 R Johnson

5 B Westbrook

6 T Barber

7 W Parker

8 S Jackson

9 T Bell

10 R Brown

11 W McGahee

12 S Alexander

13 C Taylor

14 F Gore

15 E James

16 W Dunn

17 C Williams

18 K Jones

19 J Lewis

20 D McCallister

21 J Jones

22 R Bush

23 D Foster

24 T Jones

25 C Dillon

 

[Browns Rule!]

I'll try it:

1 LT

2 Portis

3 LJ

4 Westbrook

5 Tiki

6 Rudi

7 SJax

8 Brown

9 Parker

10 Alexander

11 Dunn

12 C Taylor

13 Edge

14 McGahee

15 J Jones

16 Gore

17 Caddy

18 K Jones

19 T Jones

20 Tatum

21 Ahman

22 Jordan

23 D Foster

24 Droughns

25 Jamal

 

[bostonfred]

Point per reception leagues

1 LTomlinson

2 LJohnson

3 RJohnson

4 TBarber

5 BWestbrook

6 RBrown

7 CPortis

8 SJackson

9 RBush

10 KJones

11 WParker

12 TBell

13 SAlexander

14 CTaylor

15 WMcGahee

16 FGore

17 LMaroney

18 EJames

19 WDunn

20 CWilliams

21 AGreen

22 TJones

23 LJordan

24 JLewis

25 JJones

 

[avoiding injuries]

Lets wait till Monday and evaluate it then. Guaranteed all will change

Looking forward to it. Helps pass time between the weekends.JayMan, nice work combining the rankings.

 

[JayMan]

Thanks AInj...

Updated rankings... 16 lists compiled...

---

Guys moving up the most from preseason (justify or not?)... Parker / Taylor / TBell / Gore / Green

Guys moving down the most from preseason (injury or else)... Alexander / CWilliams / Jordan / Droughns

Interesting tidbits...

Bush & McAllister together at 22 & 23;

Portis preseason worries behind him at 3;

The battle of the Joneses - Kevin at 17 / Julius at 20 / Thomas at 26;

Maroney at 24 & Dillon at 34;

Some oldies still up there... Barber at 6 / Dunn at 15 / Taylor at 25;

Alexander down to 13 - even if he misses only a few weeks - CTaylor & TBell ahead of him?

---

LTomlinson    --  398LJohnson    ----  374CPortis    -----  352RJohnson    ----  349BWestbrook    --  327TBarber    -----  314WParker    -----  277SJackson    ----  271RBrown    ------  251WMcGahee    ----  226CTaylor    -----  223TBell    -------  220SAlexander    --  209EJames    ------  208WDunn    -------  185FGore    -------  172KJones    ------  127CWilliams    ----  95JLewis    -------  85JJones    -------  81AGreen    -------  71RBush    --------  70DMcAllister    --  61LMaroney    -----  61FTaylor    ------  47TJones    -------  47LJordan    ------  45DFoster    ------  26RDroughns    ----  15LBetts    --------  6DRhodes    -------  3DWilliams    -----  2JAddai    --------  1CDillon	-------  1

 

[bostonfred]

Bump for more responses a week later.

 

[minister]

RB1 L. JOHNSON

RB2 L. TOMLINSON

RB3 T. BARBER

RB4 R. JOHNSON

RB5 C. PORTIS

RB6 S. JACKSON

RB7 T. BELL

RB8 W. PARKER

RB9 R. BROWN

RB10 W. McGAHEE

RB11 W. DUNN

RB12 E. JAMES

RB13 S. ALEXANDER

RB14 R. BUSH

RB15 F. GORE

RB16 B. WESTBROOK

RB17 L. MARONEY

RB18 A. GREEN

RB19 K. JONES

RB20 C. TAYLOR

RB21 L. JORDAN

RB22 T. JONES

RB23 C. WILLIAMS

RB24 J. ADDAI

RB25 J. LEWIS

 

[pizzatyme]

1 LT

2 LJ

3 Portis

4 Tiki

5 Brown

6 Rudi

7 SJax

8 K. Jones (Biggest mover in my book. Due to offense starting to click)

9 Parker

10 Tatum Bell

11 Alexander (Due to injury)

12 McGahee

13 J Jones

14 D Foster

15 Westbrook (Due to possible surgery or rest)

16 Dunn

17 Deuce

18 Ahman

19 C Taylor

20 Addai (Now gets more involved with passing game due to tough upcoming schedule)

21 Edge

22 Gore

23 Jamal

23 Caddy

25 Jordan

 

[Brunell4MVP]

1. Tomlinson

2. Portis (would be #1, but they keep sticking in Betts)

3. Larry Johnson

4. Barber

5. S Jackson

6. McGahee

7. Alexander

8. K Jones

9. Dunn

10. Jordan (can't understand why he's so low on everyone's list...probably overreaction....yeah the Raiders suck, but he's their main option, has a fairly easy schedule, and Walters should improve)

11. Parker

12. J Jones

13. James

14. Rudi

15. Brown

16. Fred Taylor

17. Westbrook (injuries....every year)

18. Caddy Williams

19. C Taylor

20. T Bell (Still think he splits over the course of the year)

21. Maroney

22. Droughns

23. Bush

24. Foster (until he gets hurt, then I put D Williams in the top 15)

25. Lewis (Billick will stick with him if they keep winning)

 

[Blue-Kun]

Bump for the end of season reflection.

Hit on a few like Betts, Green, Taylor, LT and Westbrook.

Totally whiffed on KJ, Edge, McGahee and Gore rankings and good god were Tater Bell, Maroney and Dunn terrible choices.

How close were you?